Today’s Child Sacrifice

Today’s Child Sacrifice September 4, 2013

The following will be delivered as a d’var Torah, reflections on the Torah reading on the second day of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, at Congregation Beth Israel, Asheville, North Carolina.

Let’s get straight to it. Child sacrifice.

The akedah, the story of the binding of Isaac, invites us to think about child sacrifice and putting an end to it. But haven’t we already put an end to it? Are children still being sacrificed? In the United States? In North Carolina? In Asheville?

Well, that depends on how you define sacrifice.

What would you call it when a girl is born to a poor mother, whose husband, when he’s around, abuses her, if not physically then emotionally, in, say, Charlotte, North Carolina? Born in Charlotte, that child, according to the Equality of Opportunity Project, has only a little more than a 4% chance of climbing out of poverty in her lifetime. If she is born under similar circumstances in Asheville, North Carolina, her chances improve: 7.1%. Given the miracle of life, this child’s opportunities for life seem severely limited from the day she is born. Is this a kind of child sacrifice?

What would you call it when a gay (or lesbian, or bisexual) teen, growing up in a culture in which he is bullied in school and in the neighborhood and his fear follows him home where he’s afraid to reveal his identity to his parents, so, seeing few choices to improve his life, he attempts suicide? Studies show that GLB youth are between one-and-a-half and seven times more likely to attempt suicide than heterosexual youth. When we contribute, knowingly or unknowingly, to a hostile environment for our gay, lesbian, and bisexual children, are we indirectly practicing a kind of child sacrifice?

Studies show that adverse childhood experiences—which range from parental divorce to emotional neglect and sexual abuse, and include growing up with family members who suffer from mental illness, alcoholism, or drug problems—lead to “negative adult outcomes,” including greatly increased risks of cancer, heart disease, emphysema, and chronic bronchitis (reported in “The Poverty Clinic,” The New Yorker, March 21, 2011).

Any of these adverse childhood experiences (ACES) can be triggered or exacerbated by unemployment. In North Carolina, where, during the recent recession, the unemployment rate climbed to more than 11% but is now at 8.8%, unemployment benefits have been drastically cut or have, for some, run out entirely. Why? Because North Carolina is the first state in the nation “to opt out of the federal long-term compensation program.”

So what would you call it when a boy or girl is born into a situation that is almost certain to cause serious, potentially life-threatening physical problems if and when he or she reaches adulthood? Is this a kind of child sacrifice?

What do you call it when young American servicemen and women, eighteen and older, adults though still our children, lose their lives or come home seriously wounded, having lost limbs or suffered serious brain injuries, after having served their country, having served us in questionable wars, of which I can certainly count at least two in my lifetime? When we allow ourselves to be misled by our leaders, are we not directly or indirectly participating in a kind of child sacrifice?

What do you call it when the parents of a black child, especially a boy, must teach their child at a young age how to respond when, because he looks suspicious just because he’s black, he’s stopped and questioned, interrogated, by the police or a member of a neighborhood watch? Maybe the kid walks away, physically unharmed; maybe not. Is this a kind of child sacrifice?

How far have we come in our efforts to establish racial justice and equality here? Ask Robert Avery, as NPR reporter Michelle Norris did recently as part of the “Race Card” series on Morning Edition. In August 1963, at age fifteen, Avery, with two teenage friends, risked his life hitchhiking from Gadsden, Alabama to Washington, D.C., for the March on Washington. His six words about the progress made since King delivered his famous “I Have a Dream” speech: “Not far, long way to go.”

The binding of Isaac story has a happy ending. Not because Abraham thought twice about what he was about to do. No, it has a happy ending because God, through an intermediary, an angel, intervenes and stays Abraham’s hand. God’s a great character at this moment in the story.

Story: Torah as story. The akedah is fiction, maybe even a fairy tale. How do we know? Here’s how it begins: “Once upon a time.” Literally, it’s “After these things,” these, say the rabbis, unspecified things. Like all good stories, this one exaggerates things to help us see something in our actual lives that we otherwise might not be able and might not want to see.

Early in Genesis, we read that humans were created b’tselem Elohim, in God’s image. If we want to live up to that generous characterization in Torah, we need to be the ones who stop Abraham—in whatever form he happens to manifest himself—as a state government, a corporation, a white American, or even a Bible-thumping, Torah-loving synagogue- or church-going man or woman—before, obeying a “higher power,” he sacrifices another child.

This very day, Rosh Hashanah, somewhere an Abraham may be poised to sacrifice a child. For the sake of the children, all the children, for the sake of us all, we must stop Abraham now.


Richard Chess is the author of three books of poetry,Tekiah, Chair in the Desert, and Third Temple. Poems of his have appeared in Telling and Remembering: A Century of American Jewish Poetry, Bearing the Mystery: Twenty Years of IMAGE, and Best Spiritual Writing 2005. He is the Roy Carroll Professor of Honors Arts and Sciences at the University of North Carolina at Asheville. He is also the director of UNC Asheville’s Center for Jewish Studies.

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Lois Bernard

    What needed to be said…I don’t dare begin to add as there seems to be no end to the children sacrificed today.

  • Peggy Rosenthal

    Powerful and, alas, all too true. We all, made in God’s image, are not doing anywhere near what we can to stop today’s child sacrificing.

  • Jessica Schort Saxe

    I was thinking of this post as we read today’s Torah portion in which Abraham casts out his firstborn son Ishmael and his mother Hagar. Here Abraham is guilty of neglect. I have never understood how Abraham could treat either of his sons as he did. I commend you for seeing Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son as a major failure in father love.
    Yes, if we are to live up to our potential of our creation b’tselem Elohim, we have our work cut out for us.

  • Tom Rosenberg

    Very meaningful Rick. I will share it with others. Wishing for a better world for everyone in 5774.

  • MeredithEugeneHunt

    On April 5, 2013 in Asheville, North Carolina a group of “full spectrum doulas” threw a fundraiser for a place that engages in bloody, violent child sacrifice. The doulas are a far cry from the Hebrew midwives. The place is called Femcare, which is a few blocks away from Congregation Beth Israel. (The former rabbi there, Shmuel Birnham once participated in a celebration of Roe v. Wade at Jubilee, a sort of church. His photograph was featured in the Asheville-Citizen Times.) The fundraiser took in $16,000 and was attended by at least two Asheville City Councilmen, one State Representative, and a leader in the state Democratic Party, Patsy Keever.

    At least those who are born have recourse to legal protection from being physically sacrificed. A pre-natal child has none. This is a fatal defect in our culture.

    • MeredithEugeneHunt

      I might add that two colleagues of Mr. Chess, UNC-A professors Lori Horvitz and Alice Weldon, were scheduled to speak at the abortion site fundraiser.

  • Danielle Earley

    I feel often the ideas of society justify sacrifice as a means for the greater good. In a world where there is always someone playing the role of I know best and you are my subordinate, the saving of another individual such as myself may turn out to be detrimental. If I claim to be a follower of God, what happens when my own arrogance gets in the way. Recently for me sacrifice has meant clarity because without the trappings of the old constrictions can I finally see a path I have been blind to for a long while.