The trap of being an A+ Christian (and how to escape)

The trap of being an A+ Christian (and how to escape) January 26, 2022

Growing up a well-trained evangelical, I knew my Bible. I knew Luther’s Small Catechism. And I knew all the words for most of the hymns in our hymnal. In short: I was a Good Christian. Want proof? I thought you’d never ask:

  • I got an A in Religion class every semester from kindergarten through college graduation.
    A+ Christian
    Are you an A+ Christian?
  • I was top of my confirmation class.
  • On those bulletin inserts with fill-in-the-blank sermon notes, I filled every blank, every week, with the correct word or phrase.
  • And I always had a backup trove of biblical truth in the hymns I knew by heart.

A+ Christian “facts”

Years and years of being “graded” on Christianity taught me (and I don’t think I’m alone on this) that following Jesus is more a matter of being right than being good. Or more precisely, being right guarantees being good. For example:

  • Thou shalt not kill” (Exodus 20:13) means abortion must be outlawed. Corollary: it is always wrong to vote for a Democrat. Period. (Read Pro-birth, Pro-life, Pro-choice, Part One.)
  • You shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination” (Leviticus 18:22) means any non-heteronormative attraction or activity is sinful. Corollary: it is always wrong to vote for a Democrat. (Read My U-turn from evangelical to LGBTQ+ affirming.)
  • I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” (Philippians 4:13) means any Christian who is struggling financially has a weak faith.
  • All things work together for good to them who love God and are called according to his purposes” (Romans 8:28) means anything from a cancer diagnosis to a horrific car crash is somehow part of God’s plan.
  • I don’t do the good I want to do. Instead, I do the evil that I don’t want to do” (Romans 7:19) means every action is either good or evil (and as an A student, I have the inside scoop on which actions are which).
  • But even if you should suffer for what is right, you are blessed” (I Peter 3:14) means that if I’m criticized for any of my beliefs, I’m being persecuted, and God blesses me for that. It never means I need to examine my beliefs – because I already know I’m right.

And so on.

(Commercial: if you question “business as usual” in Christianity – or want to question it – subscribe to my newsletter, and we can journey together!)

Still Christian – without the A+

It’s possible that I never would have walked away from this absolutist ideology if I hadn’t been smacked in the face by blatant bigotry and hypocrisy, and plain old ugliness, in the evangelical Christian community to which I belonged.

It was painful at the time, totally disorienting, downright crushing.

Then it was infuriating. It was so obvious to me that these people (Christian leaders) had sinned. Why was it not obvious to them?

Answer: because they assume they are always right. They assume they have the mind of Christ. They assume that anyone who is not in full agreement with them is doing evil (see Romans 7:19). And they assume that they don’t need to examine any of their assumptions. (Read Do you know God’s will for you, or just assume you know?)

The knee-jerk response of outrage against LGBTQ+ rights, immigrant rights, abortion rights, the right to “take a knee” or buy a “gay cake” or protest against war goes unexamined. (It was unexamined for me too – until it wasn’t.)

When I get into a “discussion” with an evangelical, I can say, “do you need to reconsider your viewpoint?” and when they ask me the same question, I can truthfully say “I already have.”

I know all too well how rarely a really good opportunity for change comes along, so I don’t get into those conversations much anymore. It’s just a waste of time to try to reason with someone who is positive they’re right. I guess the thing to do is hope and pray they will hit a life crisis that causes them to look critically at everything.

It’s possible, maybe even preferable to do such soul-searching when life is calm. But do any of us have the guts?

(If you are energized by challenges to the evangelical status quo like this, you’d enjoy my blog. Sign up for my free newsletter here!)

(If you would like to comment, please pop over to my Facebook page. All of my posts are there and open to constructive comment! I welcome your thoughts. And don’t forget to subscribe to my newsletter!)


Do you know God’s will for you, or just assume you know?

Conservative Christians need to outgrow binary thinking

The folly of having “right” theology 

How to be Christlike on the abortion issue

My U-turn from evangelical to LGBTQ+ affirming

We’ve made God in our image, and we’re answering our own prayers

Browse Our Archives