Book Review: MUSLIMS AND THE MAKING OF AMERICA October 28, 2016

It’s hard to pin down Trump’s most offensive and un-American statements during his campaign, but the idea of deporting or preventing immigration by Muslims…by performing some sort of vague religious test…might well qualify. In his latest book, Muslims and the Making of America, professor and scholar Amir Hussain sets out to show just how tightly Islam and Muslims are woven into the fabric of America.

muslimsandthemakingofamericaHussain’s text is not an exhaustive account of every Muslim American’s contribution to art, culture, science, and politics. That would be impossible. However, he points out the All Stars, so to speak, some of whom, like Ali, will be familiar to most readers, while others, like Ahmet Ertugan, won’t. Ertugan was the founder of Atlantic Records and, therefore, responsible for shaping much of the history of American music.

Hussain makes a powerful claim: “There has never been an America without Muslims.” he backs this up with historical accounts of Muslim slaves brought over from West Africa and then traces the history of Muslims from those oppressed beginnings to reveal the myriad ways in which they have enriched American history and culture from politics to sports to art to architecture. In the process, many American Muslims have risen to solidly middle or upper-middle class communities, an achievement that, he argues, is more difficult in other parts of the Western world (114).

Hussain’s chief aim is to refute the idea that Islam and Muslims are anti-American with all the baggage that that critique brings. He points out that even though there are around seven million Muslims in the United States, most Americans claim that they don’t know any Muslims. One of the many strengths of Hussain’s work is the way in which he shows that violence hasn’t been the defining nature of the relationship between the United States and the Muslim world. Along those same lines, he consistently reveals the diversity of Islam and Muslim practice. Hussain writes, “[…There] are lots of Muslims who do things that we are not supposed to do as Muslims” (43). Of course, this is true of most Christians I know…including myself!

Muslims and the Making of America is an extremely accessible book and one that should be required reading for Christian communities across the country. It’s a well-researched work with a bibliography that points to sources for further reading. Hussain argues that America would be completely different without Muslims in it…and not for the better. Similarly, most of our lives would be different…and no doubt better…if we made the effort to get to know members of that faithful, and very American, community.

Muslims and the making of America (Baylor University Press, 142 pp.) is available on Amazon.

"Jason Isbell is country?"

At SXSW2017: Music Festival Day 3
"Ryan, will you change this yet?Jason Pollack literally changed facts and made up stuff. He's ..."

"Now that the unedited video is available and it shows that Pollock has created a ..."

"Jason Pollock is a fucking idiot. The film is a scam; cut and pasted, tons ..."


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Kactuz

    Islam and Muslims are not anti-American by definition. Rather they are anti-Infidel and against any principals that support full equality of persons, freedom of speech and separation of religion from law and state. This is obvious from the Quran, a book filled with hate and violence directed at non-Muslims and from simple everyday facts in all countries dominated by Islam. Yes, Muslims in the West say they believe in equality and freedom, but actions speak louder than words. Why should any non-Muslim believe anything that a Muslim says when they refuse to reflect of the hate in their dogma against the “lower than animals” non-Muslims (according to the Quran) and also refuse to condemn their prophet (Their noble example, also according to the Quran) for the atrocities in his attacks on this neighbors for 10 years?
    When Muslims, where they dominate, treat others as equal human beings, when they end hate and slander in daily prayers and in the mosques, when they repeal the apostasy and blasphemy laws, when they accept criticism of their religion and nefarious prophet — then and only then will they have credibility. This article, like so many in our press everywhere, is another example of the silly kumbayah PC garbage inflicted upon us by people who consider themselves morally superior, even as they ignore the sad reality of Islam and the broken bodies resulting from actions done in the name of this convoluted ideology.

    • JakobFabian01

      Everything that you condemn about Muslims is a thing that enlightened Muslims also condemn and a thing that unenlightened and hateful individuals all embrace, regardless of the faith they profess. And the scripture of any religious tradition of Antiquity can be easily exploited for evil ends. To name only a few examples from the Judeo-Christian Bible:

      What we would now call genocide is affirmed in the Bible (Deuteronomy 7: 1-2, Joshua 6: 21, Joshua 10: 40-41, Joshua 11: 19-23, &c.).

      Blasphemy, an ill-defined but absolutely unforgivable sin, is expressly included in Christian scripture (Mark 3: 29).

      I believe the sectarian, un-holy warfare that is causing such horrible bloodshed in much the Middle East today is remarkably similar to that which tore apart Europe during the Thirty Years’ War (1618-1648). We Christians, in particular, have no right to point a finger at Muslims if we know our own history.