Brett Kavanaugh just claimed, in the Judiciary Committee hearings on his nomination to be a Supreme Court judge, that "a good judge must be an umpire." No. Not even close. That’s the typical conservative dodge to avoid talking about their approach to interpreting the law. I was an expert witness in John Roberts' confirmation hearings, where he compared his way of interpreting the law to that of an “umpire calling balls and strikes.” It has not worked out that way. Read more