Metacriticizing Donald Trump

Metacriticizing Donald Trump February 6, 2017

The Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship unit in the Society of Biblical Literature expresses its opposition to the Executive Order issued by President Donald J. Trump on January 27, 2017, that immediately suspends entry of citizens of Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, and Yemen into the United States.

We recognize that the Bible bears contradictory views about immigrants, and we do not utilize the Bible as an authority to set any government policy or to oppose any government policy.

Our opposition is firstly based on the detrimental effect that such an order has on the welfare of victims of oppression and violence that will now be trapped within the listed countries. The Order, in effect, is a death sentence for thousands of men, women, and children of many religious backgrounds who are trying to flee violence.

As members of a community of scholars, we also are concerned that the Executive Order adversely affects the ability of scholars from the listed countries to interact with those in the United States. Such interactions are a key component of expanding knowledge and building relationships across the globe.

The Executive Order, along with many related statements made by Mr. Trump, suggest that the basis for this action is partly based on religious discrimination. He declared his intent to ban all Muslims in December of 2015, and he has since stated that he wants priority given to Christian refugees, who are not the majority of those experiencing violence in the listed countries. Identifying a religious preference for entry, or for the denial of entry, into the United States is neither consistent with our Constitutional principles nor with the general principles of equality.

We, therefore, denounce in the strongest possible terms the premises and consequences that this Executive Order will have for our fellow human beings and for the entire academic enterprise that is global in scope.

Hector Avalos (Co-Chair), Iowa State University
Rebecca Raphael (Co-Chair), Texas State University
Krista Dalton, Columbia University
André Gagné, Concordia University (Montreal, Canada)
Ed Silver, Wellesley College
Stephen Young, Appalachian State University

"___ Thank you Religion Prof. … for releasing my comment below. ____ 👍"

Redeeming the Christian Faith
"I don't think your first statement follows at all, nor do I understand your last ..."

Not Liberal, Just Literate
"I think Zehner's observation was perfect for our situation. For myself, when i am online ..."

Redeeming the Christian Faith
"That's a lie, which is again typical of the left."

Redeeming the Christian Faith

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Cynthia Astle

    May I have your permission to republish this statement along with a collection of other church-related statements that will appear on our website, United Methodist Insight? See us at Respond to Thank you!

    • This isn’t a church-related statement.

      • Cynthia Astle

        Yes, but it is from a group of scholars whose province is religion. We are also publishing statements from bishops of the United Methodist and African Methodist Episcopal churches in addition to our previous coverage of demonstrations.

        • Then please do include the several statements from AAR and SBL as a whole, as well as individual program units, that I have shared here!

          • Cynthia Astle

            An excellent idea. I’ll track them down. Thank you!

  • Chuck Johnson

    Over at John Loftus’ Debunking Christianity, the same declaration is posted by Doctor Hector Avalos.

    • Christine Lux

      His name appears above as one of those signing this declaration…

      • Chuck Johnson


        “His name appears above as one of those signing this declaration…”

        Yes, and Hector does write blog posts for John Loftus from time to time at D.C.