When Pastors Play God and Prey

When Pastors Play God and Prey December 5, 2023

Image by Thomas Wolter from Pixabay

The Supreme Court’s recent rulings, like some sort of holy high court, have been dabbling in the divine, blurring the lines in a way that would make even the prophets do a double-take. In decisions like Groff v. DeJoy and 303 Creative v. Elenis, they’ve given religious accommodations a front-row seat, making it seem like the Constitution is a living, breathing scripture open for interpretation. It’s a slippery slope when legal decisions start sounding like they’re straight out of a Sunday sermon.

Scriptural Selective Hearing

It’s baffling how some religious leaders treat the scriptures like a buffet, picking and choosing what suits their taste. Galatians 3:28’s message of equality seems to be the often-ignored broccoli on the plate. Instead, we’re witnessing a reinterpretation where hierarchies are sanctified, and spiritual superiority is served up as the main course. It’s a classic case of scriptural amnesia where the essential message of universal equality is forgotten in favor of a more self-serving gospel.

A Brief Jaunt Through History

Let’s hop in our time machine and rewind the clock. The clergy-laity divide isn’t a new Netflix special; it’s an old rerun. Historically, this divide was less about HBO’s Game of Thrones and more about control and maintaining social order. From the medieval church playing gatekeeper to heaven to the Reformation’s attempt to dial it back, we’ve been on a rollercoaster of spiritual hierarchy. It’s like history keeps hitting the replay button on the ‘us vs. them’ narrative.

Courtroom Revelations and Divine Omissions

The Arizona court case involving The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints turned into a divine tragicomedy. Here, church officials who knew about child sexual abuse conveniently hid behind the ‘clergy-penitent privilege.’ This isn’t just a loophole; it’s a black hole of moral responsibility. It’s like they’ve taken ‘thou shalt not bear false witness’ and given it a legal makeover. The full scoop on this judicial juggling act can be found here.

The Abuse Tally: More Than Just Numbers

The Catholic Church’s abuse allegations, numbering over 4,200, read like a horror script that even Stephen King wouldn’t touch. And it’s not just the Catholics; the Southern Baptist Convention has its own closet full of skeletons. These aren’t just numbers; they’re stories of lives turned upside down in the name of faith. When you read about their ‘godly governance’ gone wrong here, it’s enough to make your skin crawl.

From Spiritual Guide to Spiritual Dictator

The path from trusted spiritual guide to full-blown spiritual dictator is smoother than a televangelist’s greasy grin or Orange Jesus’ hairdo. These leaders, with their hotline to heaven, often end up dictating more than just spiritual matters. What starts as guidance slips into control, where congregations are more like flocks of sheep being herded by a shepherd with a God complex.

Take the case of the International House of Prayer founder, for example. Here’s a story where spiritual authority crosses the line into abuse and manipulation. This isn’t just about bending the divine will; it’s about breaking it to fit personal agendas. The disturbing details, highlighting how prophecy can turn predatory, are laid bare here.

The Spiritual Catnip Effect

The allure of secret spiritual knowledge is irresistible to many, acting like a divine lure. Followers get drawn in, mesmerized by the promise of deeper understanding and exclusive insights. But this spiritual bait often leads to a trap of manipulation and exploitation, leaving followers disoriented and disillusioned. It’s not just about losing faith in the leader; it’s about losing faith in faith itself.

The damage inflicted by this spiritual elitism is profound. Believers, who once sought solace and guidance, find themselves grappling with betrayal. They’re left questioning not only their spiritual path but their entire belief system. It’s a deep, personal wound that goes beyond the church walls, affecting every aspect of their lives.

The Mind Games of the Flock

Now, let’s talk about the mental gymnastics this clergy-laity circus causes. Imagine constantly being told you’re just not holy enough, spiritual enough, or – let’s face it – good enough. This spiritual gaslighting leaves deep psychological scars. Congregation members often grapple with guilt, self-doubt, and spiritual PTSD. It’s not just a crisis of faith; it’s a full-blown identity crisis, sponsored by those who claim to have a divine hotline.

Educate to Liberate

Knowledge is power, and in this case, it’s the power to see through the spiritual smoke and mirrors. Theological education and awareness among the laity are like kryptonite to the ‘divinely anointed’ power plays. When people understand their religious texts and traditions, they’re less likely to fall for the ol’ ‘God told me you should do this’ trick. It’s time to trade blind faith for informed faith – because the best followers are the ones who ask the tough questions.

Blueprint for a Spiritual Revolution

So, where do we go from here? It’s time for a spiritual revolution, my friends. We need transparency in church leadership like we need coffee on Monday mornings – desperately. It’s about holding these leaders accountable, not just to a higher power, but to the very people they serve. Grassroots movements within Christianity are already pushing for this change, advocating for congregational involvement in decision-making and calling out spiritual abuse. It’s not just about reform; it’s about transformation – turning the church from a monarchy into a community.

The Divine Dramedy Continues

In this divine dramedy, the punchline is a call to vigilance. True spirituality isn’t a private club with exclusive membership. It’s open, inclusive, and free from the trappings of power and control. So, keep those spiritual antennas tuned to authenticity and humility. Because when it comes to matters of faith, the only thing we should be playing at is sincerity, not divinity.


Also, do yourself a favor and follow Julie Roys’ work on holding the church accountable. Her insights and investigations are a valuable resource for anyone interested in the accountability and transparency of religious institutions.

Julie Roys’ Website

 

For more Snarky Faith check out the podcast:

 

About Stuart Delony
My hope with Snarky Faith is to incite change no matter how big or small. I want to cultivate conversations that help people to look for new ways to live out their faith. I'm also one of the weird ones who think that God still moves today - we're just looking in the wrong places. You can read more about the author here.

Browse Our Archives