Pascal’s Wager is the classic gamble on the existence of God and the afterlife. The basic idea is this – believe in God just in case there is a heaven or a hell. The payoff? Eternal bliss and the avoidance of eternal torment. But let’s toss a wrench into this divine game of craps and ask anew a question for American Christianity: If you removed the gamble of the afterlife, would Christians still follow the teachings of Jesus?
Welcome to Snarky’s Wager.
The Ante: What’s Really at Stake in American Christianity?
Let us go back in time a bit. Early American colonists, particularly the Puritans, brought along an acute interest in salvation and damnation. Their brand of fire-and-brimstone preaching was all about scaring the hell out of people—literally. The Great Awakenings of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries really revved up the fear factor. Revivalist preachers like Jonathan Edwards and his famous Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God sermon filled their congregations with terrifying pictures of hell that left them quaking in their pews.
Fast forward to the 20th century, when evangelicalism cemented this fixation on the afterlife. Figures like Billy Graham grasped that portraying a personal relationship with Jesus as a passport into heaven, escaping the fiery pit of hell was something with allure. Sure, today some progressive Christian movements lean more toward love and inclusivity, but hellfire and brimstone rhetoric is hardly extinct in the American pulpit
The Deal: Heaven, Hell, and American Christianity
So let’s put American Christianity to Snarky’s Wager. There are two possibilities to consider:
Heaven and Hell Are Real: In the event of such, many an American Christian acts in concert with Jesus’ teachings out of a desire for heavenly reward or fear of hellish punishment. The afterlife serves as the ultimate carrot and stick.
Heaven and Hell Don’t Exist: Now, strip away the afterlife. What happens to Christian morality and behavior when no eternal reward or punishment is hanging in the balance?
Here’s where it gets interesting: if heaven and hell are off the table, what’s left? This isn’t just about what happens to individual behavior but how communities and institutions function when the ultimate stakes are removed. American Christianity has long leaned on the afterlife as a key motivator, but without it, would the same fervor for morality, charity, or even faith itself remain?
The Call: Fear, Love, or Just Playing It Safe?
Without a Hell, what really motivates American Christians? Is it love of God, real moral conviction, or just playing it safe? The truth might be uncomfortable.
Fear vs. Love: For many, it was the fear of hell that worked. Without it, would they turn the other cheek, love their neighbors, or feed the poor? Or would they shunt those inconvenient teachings aside like last season’s fashion? There’s a psychological component here that can’t be ignored.
Fear is a powerful motivator, but it’s also a shallow one. How deep does your faith run if it’s only as strong as your fear of eternal damnation?
Ethical behavior should largely rest on genuine belief and moral conviction. But if the threat of hell is the main driver, that says a lot about how weak faith might actually be. Are American Christians just hedging their bets, or might there be some deeper, more authentic motivation at play?
On the flip side, consider the social justice warriors within progressive Christianity who fight for causes not for heavenly rewards but because they believe in the inherent worth of every human being. These folks aren’t driven by a cosmic carrot or stick; they’re motivated by a belief that transcends the afterlife. Compare that to those who would falter without the promise of heaven or the threat of hell. It’s a stark difference that reveals much about what truly drives faith.
The Showdown: What Snarky’s Wager Reveals About Faith
What does Snarky’s Wager reveal? Without the celestial carrot or infernal stick, would American Christians still cling to the teachings of Jesus? Yep, it’s a mixed bag. Faith might flag without the high stakes of an afterlife for some; for others, commitment to Jesus’s radical teachings of love and justice might shine even brighter.
Snarky judgment here: If your faith depends on the afterlife alone, perhaps it’s time to refine what you believe. Maybe the real challenge isn’t about getting into heaven or staying out of hell; it’s living in the real transforming message Jesus brought into everyday life, with no strings attached.
Here’s a challenge to the reader: Take a minute and reflect. Is it fear, love, or something even deeper that drives you? Snarky’s Wager raises an interesting question: if heaven and hell suddenly fell out of the picture, would your faith stand firm or crumble like a house of cards?
For more Snarky Faith, check out the podcast:
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In