Former Catholic priest James Kavanaugh’s poem, “There Are Men Too Gentle to Live Among Wolves,” offers a look into a kind of masculinity that gets overshadowed in today’s MAGA-driven bro culture. The gentle men in his poem are the ones who “wonder if the leaves will change their color soon.” This vision sharply contrasts with the loud, chest-thumping version of “strength” we’re so often shown. These guys aren’t outdated or old-fashioned. They’re symbols of a different kind of strength – one that doesn’t have to yell to make an impact.
Challenging ‘Bro’ Culture Through Quiet Masculinity
Kavanaugh’s portrayal of the gentle man is a quiet revolution. These folks find beauty in simple things like a leaf changing color or the far-off sound of a train. They’re living in a world that often mistakes their calmness for weakness. But it’s precisely in that calm where they find their strength while standing up against the ‘alpha’ mentality that’s all about dominance and making noise. Their presence in pulpits, in boardrooms, in politics, and in everyday life challenges the status quo, reminding us that being loud doesn’t necessarily mean you’re strong.
While brute force tends to split people apart, their contemplative posture brings folks together. They lead not by raising their voices, but by lending an ear. This way of doing things invites real collaboration, making spaces where different viewpoints get heard and authentic leadership can happen. Their gentleness isn’t a sign of weakness; it’s an act of courage in a world that often thinks aggression equals strength.
The MAGA Cult of the Alpha
Speaking of loud, let’s get into a movement that takes this ‘alpha’ mentality and runs with it: MAGA. The image of the alpha male is central to MAGA’s whole identity, pushing aggression and dominance as the ultimate signs of leadership. This mindset pushes aside those who are thoughtful and empathetic, acting like being loud and forceful is what matters. We see it everywhere—in political rallies, school board meetings, and even social media battles. Instead of discussing differences, there’s hostility, which just boosts a narrow and harmful idea of what it means to be a man.
This aggressive kind of masculinity is all over the internet as well. Confrontational voices get all the attention, and leaders who shout the loudest are the ones getting praised. It’s not just messing up politics; it’s creeping into our daily lives. The more we lift up this version of manhood, the more we shove aside true strength—things like contemplation and self-reflection.
The True Cost of Toxic Masculinity
So what’s the price we pay for putting this alpha on a pedestal? It’s high, and it’s personal. Toxic masculinity tells men they’ve got to be tough, aggressive, and keep their emotions in check. This leads to fragile egos and harmful behaviors. It’s a big reason why there’s so much violence, why men have such a hard time with mental health, and why rates of substance abuse and suicide are sky-high among guys who feel they can never show vulnerability. Being closed off emotionally isn’t strength—it’s a disaster waiting to happen.
The harm doesn’t stop with individuals. It messes up workplaces by creating toxic atmospheres that kill creativity. It hurts relationships, replacing real communication with control and dominance. It holds everyone back, chaining progress to old stereotypes that don’t help anybody.
A Call for Gentleness
So what’s the alternative to all this machismo? It’s about going back to something old but desperately needed. It’s time to look again at Kavanaugh’s vision—the idea that being gentle and thoughtful aren’t weaknesses but real strengths. The men who live these qualities show us there’s another way to be—one that doesn’t need to be the loudest to make a difference.
Turning a blind eye to this gentler approach comes with serious consequences. We’ve seen how toxic masculinity can ruin lives, tear communities apart, and stop progress in its tracks. Embracing a kind of strength that values empathy and connection isn’t just about being “nice”—it’s about survival. It’s about helping society thrive. Real leadership isn’t in the loud roar of aggression; it’s in the quiet voices of those who choose kindness, and who choose to listen.
It’s time to take a different road and shake off those arcane ideals about what men “should” be. Because sometimes, the most powerful movements don’t kick off with a roar—they begin with a well-thought-out whisper.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In