This is the connection between Isaiah and Matthew’s birth narrative for Jesus and Isaiah. Our culture’s naturalistic worldview means that what catches our attention is the scientific impossibility of a virgin birth, and this has distracted us from the political point that the author of Matthew’s gospel is making.
Welcome Readers! Please subscribe to Social Jesus Here.
This is Part 3 of the series When Christianity Becomes Complicit with Societal Injustice
(Read this series from its beginning here.)
Let me explain. Just as Ahaz submitted to the powerful king of Assyria, the Temple state elites of Jesus’ society had submitted to being a vassal of Imperial Rome. Their complicity in Rome’s exploitation of the region had brought them both power and wealth, but it was privilege for the few at the expense of the masses.
In Jesus’ world, the Jerusalem Temple was not only a religious center but also the administrative heart of a Temple-State, a political institution deeply entangled with Roman imperial power. After Rome appointed Herod the Great as client king and installed Roman prefects to govern Judea, the Temple leadership—particularly the high-priestly aristocracy—found itself operating within a system designed to maintain stability for Rome and to secure its own privileged status. The high priest was no longer chosen by internal Jewish processes but appointed and removed at the will of Roman authorities. This arrangement created a class of leaders whose power, wealth, and security depended on cooperation with the empire.
The Temple system collected tithes, offerings, and taxes from the people, on top of Rome’s own heavy taxation. Many scholars note that this dual burden intensified economic strain on ordinary people, especially peasants already living close to subsistence. Temple elites, benefiting from control of offerings, land, and commerce, were seen as aligning themselves with Roman economic extraction rather than resisting it. Their collaboration helped stabilize Rome’s rule and reinforced their own authority.
This complicity is a central backdrop to Jesus’ confrontations in the gospels. His overturning tables in the Temple didn’t challenge Jewish worship; it challenged a system that exploited the poor and legitimized imperial violence. By critiquing both economic injustice and elite collaboration with Rome, Jesus exposed how the Temple-State had drifted far from its vocation as a place of liberation and had instead become a partner in imperial domination.
This leads us to parallels in our time. In the United States today, certain sectors of Christianity have become closely aligned with nationalism, blending religious identity with political power and national loyalty. This alignment often frames a nation as uniquely chosen or divinely favored, and so transforms faith into a marker of cultural belonging rather than a call to ethical discipleship that follows the values and teachings actually found in the Jesus story, values such as nonviolence, inclusion of the marginalized, welcoming the migrant, and taking care of the poor. Christian symbols and language are sometimes used to legitimize policies that prioritize dominance, exclusion, or fear of the “other,” especially immigrants, religious minorities, and dissenters. In this framework, loyalty to the nation can eclipse core Christian commitments to peace, justice, and love of neighbor. National success is interpreted as divine blessing, while critique of the state is portrayed as unfaithful. This fusion risks turning Christianity into a tool for preserving power rather than a prophetic voice that challenges injustice. When faith is subordinated to nationalist goals, it loses its capacity to speak truth to power and to stand in solidarity with the vulnerable.
In the light of Isaiah’s critique of a union with Assyria and the gospels’ critique of a union with Rome, today’s Jesus followers are called to put their faith in the way of peace and justice. This holiday season, the birth narratives of Jesus give us cause to pause and assess whether our own faith practices are still in harmony with the stories we hold so dear.
Begin each day being inspired toward love, compassion, justice and action. Free.
Sign up at HERE.
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In