menu

A Tale of Two Churches

A Tale of Two Churches August 10, 2011

self-sacrifice, resurrection, social justice, Jesus, Spirit, God, Two Churches, Two Spirits

“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.”  For Dickens, those lines are meant to set the stage for a novel that takes place during the difficult times of the French Revolution. It is also a novel that struggles with the social injustices that come along with war and the pursuit of power.  It is sort of a call to arms for the characters that will be called upon to live out another of the book’s themes – self-sacrifice.  It also can be argued that the opening line is an inverted foreshadowing for one of the predominate themes of the book – resurrection.

Now, from what I just told you, you should be able to deduce two things rather quickly.  1) My first undergraduate degree, indeed, was in English (yes, I am a book geek) and 2) in his themes of social justice, resurrection and self-sacrifice, Dickens is clearly flirting with topics near and dear to the heart of the New Testament.

That is where the Spirit of God drives us, toward lives focused on social justice, metaphorical resurrections and, when even necessary, self-sacrifice. But increasingly, that is not the case in many traditional churches in the U.S.

Part of our problem is that we have attempted to domesticate the Spirit of God.  The very ruah (breath of God).  The wild winds that ignited the flames of creation as they whipped recklessly over the face of chaos – in the beginning; God’s essential nature described in Deuteronomy as a devouring fire; the radiant and elusive Spirit that gave the revelation of Jesus’ messiahship at his baptism; the Spirit Jesus himself would describe to Nicodemus as being mysterious and unpredictable like the wind; the winds that rushed into an upper room ripping the windows open, resting as a flame on the disciple’s shoulders, causing them to speak in tongues and be looked upon as if they were drunk; that Spirit scares us because we can’t control it.  So, we have attempted to domesticate God’s Spirit – much like the common dog.  We tried to tame it, teach it to curl up beside our hearths and be obedient.  We want to quantify it, objectify it, demystify it – train it, contain it and constrain it. Like our children, we want it stop being so wild and uncontrollable.  We want it to lose its propensity to form something new out of a world in which we feel comfortable.

The Spirit however is unruly.  It is apt to doing a “new thing,” to bringing about a change on God’s people and on the world which God created.  Should we really expect anything less out of the Spirit of God – not the God we created in our image, but the God that said, “behold, I am about to do a new thing,” the God who used chaos to form this world, the God who did the unthinkable and became human flesh, the God who overcame death itself…should we really expect the Spirit of that God to be docile, domesticated and dormant?  In churches throughout the U.S., we seem to.

Churches throughout the U.S. must ask themselves, which Spirit do we follow? The one we, as a society, have created out of our own needs?  The one that allows us to trust in ourselves?  The one that plays nice and gives us warm fuzzies?  Or are we ready to celebrate the Spirit of the biblical text?  One who is willing to grapple with chaos. One that is unruly, unexpected, unconventional and unconcerned with what we want or how things have always been done.  Which one do we truly celebrate?


History has proven that churches that survive, churches that move forward with God are inevitably ones that are willing to, particularly in the worst of times, embrace the Spirit of Change – God’s New Thing.“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.”  The difference between those two things (the best of time and the worst of times) is which Spirit we invite into our midst – the domesticated spirit of humanity OR the wild and wonderful Spirit of God.

The modern day story of the Church is the tale of two Spirits.  Much like Dickens’ tale it is the story of social-justice, self-sacrifice and resurrection.  Let us live into that story, our story, the story of the Children of God.  Let us make room for the true Spirit of God to work as we walk in the footprint of Jesus, being willing to sacrifice our fear of the unknown in order to bring about change, willing to let our wants be sidelined for God’s justice knowing that they are step on a lifetime’s journey to God that will conclude one fine day as we rest in the arms of the one whose Spirit has brought us this far.

I’d like to conclude the way I started, with a quote from Dickens’ A Tale of Two Cities.  And just as I started with the quote that opens his tale, I’ll conclude with the one that closes his book.  I think they are both more than appropriate for our tale of to Spirits.  As we choose what we are going to do, which Spirit we are willing to make room for, on our journey to our ultimate resting place with God, remember these words, “It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to, than I have ever known.”

"wow. you almost managed to slip some positive words in, probably by mistake. sickened, I ..."

Following Jesus in the Age of ..."
"In your comment here you are giving an example of someone who believes In Fear ..."

Following Jesus in the Age of ..."
"Fair enough, but now we are speaking of what is good policy. What I have ..."

10 Things You Can’t Vote For ..."

Browse Our Archives