The "Twilight" Movie: Redefining "Natural" by Means of the Supernatural

The lowdown on Twilight: if you liked the book, you’ll most likely enjoy the movie. If you didn’t like the book, you won’t like the movie. If you have never read the book, you’ll probably be confused by the movie.

For those of us who liked the book but were not blind to its flaws, the movie actually presents some improvements. The pace is faster, and the movie introduces the villains—evil vampires who, unlike Edward Cullen and his family, drink human blood and dress like hippies—much earlier by showing the death and mayhem that follows in their wake. I thought that the movie would have been more interesting if it hadn’t immediately shown who was responsible for the killings, leaving Bella (and, theoretically, the viewer) with the suspicion that Edward was guilty. Unfortunately, I was not consulted.

The movie version also brings out an aspect present in the novel, but often ignored: the sad truth that high school boys generally act like monkeys. (Not that the girls, with their gossip-and-dress obsession, are much better.) The antics of Bella’s peers highlight one of the reasons she falls for Edward: he’s the first teenage (sort-of) boy she’s met who’s at her level of maturity. Their conversations occur in high school, but not of it: it’s as if they occupy a completely different sphere of reality when they begin to talk to each other.

However, in spite of her relative maturity, Bella still is a teenager, and one of the greatest improvements of the movie over the book is that we don’t have to hear Bella’s first-person gushings about Edward and all his beautiful beautifulness. Stephenie Meyer captures a teenage girl’s voice remarkably accurately, which is both the strength and weakness of Twilight the novel. In Twilight the movie, we (at least those of us who are over 18 and are not smitten with Robert Pattinson) get to see Edward a little more objectively. Part of this is probably due to Pattinson’s determination to portray Edward’s self-loathing, which is necessary in order to make him more than just a pretty-boy who likes to drink blood. Unfortunately, Pattinson also seems to have practiced his American accent by watching old Marlon Brando movies, so he lacks the mellifluous tones that are supposed to draw Bella to Edward.

Because I’ve always found Edward the more interesting character in the Twilight series (according to “Which Twilight character are you?” quiz, I am Edward), I’ve been following how various movie reviewers have reacted to him and his abstinence from both blood and sex. While some have patted themselves on the back for reaching the stunning and insightful conclusion that drinking or not drinking blood is a metaphor for sex (Have they never before seen or read anything featuring vampires? Ever?), others are repulsed by Edward’s restraint. New York Times reviewer Manohla Dargis calls Edward a “bore” because of his insistence on keeping “his fangs in his mouth.” Now, I’m not upset with her conclusion that Edward is a bore, but I’m disturbed by her reasons for reaching that conclusion: apparently anyone who doesn’t act on his or her impulses is boring. She lambasts Edward for recoiling from Bella’s advances “like a distraught Victorian”—which, since he was born in 1901, he technically is, though his formative years would have been during the Edwardian (yep) era. Dargis scolds Twilight for what she sees as its message: “that there actually is something worse than death, especially for teenagers: sex.”

Of course, if Dargis were familiar with the whole Twilight series, she’d find that this isn’t the message at all—sex between married couples is rather emphatically celebrated—but that’s not her responsibility as the movie reviewer, so I won’t fault her for that. However, her disgust with Edward’s abstinence is so strong, as if self-restraint is somehow unnatural and . . . inhuman. Edward, however, controls himself around Bella because he doesn’t want to kill her; he wants to be human and not the monster he believes he is. What Twilight illustrates for me is that maybe it’s “natural”—as well as sexy—to try to live a life according to one’s higher nature—one’s created human nature, good as God intended it to be. As Christians, we know that Christ has already declared us clean, and that God’s grace can enable us to gradually conform to what he has already said we are. This is what Edward lacks, and why he is a bit, as he himself admits, “sick and masochistic.” But, really, what’s more “natural”—to aspire to a better way of life or to sneer at all such striving?

More than anything else about Twilight, I’m interested in how it serves as a cultural barometer. It’d be nice if the winds are changing, if instead of being told to “be yourself,” teens are now being told “there’s a better version of yourself to be.” Whether they can hear that message through all the squeals is another question.

About Carrisa Smith
  • Dave Dunham

    Brilliant work Carissa!

  • http://www.classymommy.com/wii_giveaway/vote_view.php?contest=wii&name=Stephanie%20Early Jen

    My cousin Stephanie Early had her husband sent to Iraq on two separate occasions, therefore making family responsibilities greater. None the less, her two young girls have a smiles that light up a room, giggles that are contagious and loving hearts. They have moved a few time across the country as needed. This Christmas Stephanie wants to get her little girls and her husband a Wii. They’ve just moved into a new house so the situation is tight.

    Please help give this family a Wii for Christmas by voting for Stephanie Early at:

    http://www.classymommy.com/wii_giveaway/vote_view.php?contest=wii&name=Stephanie%20Early

    Help them have a very Merry Christmas!

    Merry Christmas to all the Moms and families out there too!! Thank you!!

  • Sandy

    I have been wanting to read the Twilight series, but never have time to finisht the books I already own. It sounds like I can get the general idea from the film since I come to it with basic “vampicic” kmnowledge. Thanks for an informative review!

  • Pingback: Rose di Cristallo

  • http://www.aaronhall.com/ Minnesota Attorney

    I have been hearing about this book series. Some people can’t put it down. Thanks for explaining what all the hype is about.

    Minnesota Attorneys last blog post..Minnesota DWI DUI Drunk Driving Attorney

  • Kristi

    This is hillarious! And insightful. Thanks! Great review.

  • http://www.coffeerama.com coffee

    i don’t understand what is the appeal of Robert Pattinson (Edward); he has an unusually shaped nose

    coffees last blog post..Circle K Coffee

  • David Dunham

    I finally saw this movie last night, honestly it seemed a forgettable film for me. My wife grew so bored with it she went to bed.

  • http://sjdeal.blogspot.com Shane Deal

    Great article. I’ve watched it for the first time about a week and a half ago, loved it. I’ve watched it over again about seven times since. Still love it! I plan to watch it again tonight.

    “What Twilight illustrates for me is that maybe it’s “natural”—as well as sexy—to try to live a life according to one’s higher nature—one’s created human nature, good as God intended it to be.

    I found that somewhat amusing, and quite true. :-)

  • http://www.electronicslab.ph/forum Seychelle Jean

    Twilight is the best movie i ever watched. I really love the vampire love story theme and i like Bella Swans character.

  • http://www.caramoantravel.com Janice Yu

    Twlight is really a great movie and i watched it several times. I love Kristen Stewart and also the rest of the cast of Twilight, they are really superb actors and actresses.

  • http://www.health-juice.net May Jaca

    i will watch every sequel of Twilight because i find this movie so good. the graphics is good, the cast is good and of course the storyline is great.

  • http://www.neighborcity.com/member-profile/231694-flute9oil/ visit this page

    Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article. I will make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I’ll certainly return.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X