I plainly chose the wrong field

 

ya gotta link for that?

 

 

Most ordinary people, I suspect, would be reluctant to advise a neurosurgeon on how to do his job, or to take it upon themselves to explain quantum theory to a mathematical physicist.  They don’t typically think themselves better carpenters than the master cabinetmaker working in their new kitchen, or dismiss the training of their accountant.

 

Lots of people, though, whose only acquaintance with Islam and/or the Middle East comes from surfing the web or listening to a radio talk show, feel entirely qualified to lecture me on Islamic history and doctrine.  Obviously, the years I’ve put into study and research and reflection on the topic, the graduate schooling and the Ph.D., the effort of studying the relevant languages, and so forth, have been wasted.  A few minutes with the right website would have sufficed.

 

“You should read the Qur’an,” they often tell me — though I suspect that, in almost every case, they themselves actually haven’t.  They’ll sometimes go to the trouble of providing me with several Qur’anic passages (virtually always the same ones) that, they assure me, command all Muslims to kill all non-Muslims, and so forth.  Sometimes, they tell me about Qur’an 9:11 (note the uncannily appropriate chapter and verse), with its eerily accurate prediction of “a son of Arabia” who “would awaken a fearsome Eagle” whose “wrath . . . would be felt throughout the lands of Allah.”  And, when I tell them that no such passage exists in the Qur’an, anywhere, they respond, typically in a rather condescending tone, that I need to read a better, more accurate translation.

 

I know the passages (and the non-passage) well.  I read in the Qur’an virtually every day in Arabic, and have done so for years.  I teach the Qur’an twice each year, one semester in English translation and the next semester in Arabic.  (I’ve also read it in French and German, in a number of different translations.)  I’ve published a number of articles on themes in the Qur’an and on particular Qur’anic passages.

 

“You should learn something about Muhammad’s life,” they frequently tell me.  And I’ve tried to do that, of course.  I’ve even published a biography of Muhammad.  But, obviously, this did me no good, because what I have to say isn’t consistent with their favorite websites.

 

When, in turn, I suggest that they need to read more about the history of Islam and the Middle East, about the biography of Muhammad, and about the historical context of his life and his claimed revelations, some of them charge me with lying.

 

Worse still, one or two accuse me of being a “liberal” — which is really difficult for somebody to take who, while still a young boy and against the views of his parents, campaigned for Barry Goldwater; who twice voted for Ronald Reagan; who has subscribed to National Review since his thirteenth year and who helped to host William F. Buckley, Jr., when Buckley spoke at BYU; who spent two weeks in England and Scotland in the summer of 1976, hobnobbing with George Stigler, Milton Friedman, Murray Rothbard, and Friedrich von Hayek when the Mont Pelerin Society held its annual meeting at the University of St. Andrews; and who, whenever he can schedule it, not only attends but participates in the big annual libertarian FreedomFest in Las Vegas.  Some liberal.

 

(For an earlier meditation on this remarkable accusation, see this prior blog post.)

 

“Unlike you,” one zealous Mormon anti-Muslim once told me, “I support God’s modern prophets, not that mass murdering Arabian pedophile, Muhammad.”  And yet, when I mentioned the positive statement about Muhammad issued in February 1978 by the First Presidency of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, this self-proclaimed supporter of “God’s modern prophets” immediately dismissed it.  “Spencer Kimball was deceived by Satan,” he replied.

 

 

Print Friendly

  • Lucy Mcgee

    In our time of Twittering Tweets, where human knowledge is dispensed in under 128 characters, scholarship is more important than ever. Dr. Peterson, as a scholar who is willing to engage anyone, and who is often discredited, is an important voice. Any person who has committed themselves to a particular scholarly discipline for decades, has much to offer methinks. And although I have a far different world view regarding religion than Dr. Peterson, his insights are, to me, important, interesting, and worthy of contemplation.

    Several months ago, in a wildly expansive search, I found a voice, which I found harmonized a story quite appealing. For those who may want to spend an hour with professor A.C. Grayling, here’s a link: http://vimeo.com/59623363

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Peterson/634891356 Daniel Peterson

      Thanks for the kind comments.

  • Collin Simonsen

    I agree with what you say in this article. But not all anti-intellectualism is unwarranted. When lay people hear “Islam is a religion of peace” we get kinda confused and wonder if the intellectuals are getting it quite right.
    But then again, I’m not sure if it was an intellectual or a politician that said that.

    • Collin Simonsen

      And yes, I just implied that politicians are not intellectuals. :)

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Peterson/634891356 Daniel Peterson

      I dislike oversimplifications. “Islam is a religion of peace” is one such, and is false. At least, it isn’t true without complications and qualifications. But “Islam is pure evil,” expressed in one way or another, is also a falsehood and an oversimplification.

  • William Carter

    Some time ago I asked Bro. Peterson to share with us the most beautiful or inspiring passages he has found in the Book of Islam. With all this talk of “the Prophet” and how important this Book is, I found it very dreary, repetitive, punitive and “uninspired”. Admittedly, I couldn’t finish it. Surely Bro. Peterson has found the “pearls” I overlooked.

    Please share with us….

    • danpeterson

      Brother Peterson has a life, and he sometimes fails to comply on schedule with some demands. He assures me that he’ll post a few things on the topic when he gets around to it.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Peterson/634891356 Daniel Peterson

      Brother Peterson has a life, and he sometimes fails to comply on schedule with each and every demand. He assures me that he’ll post a few things on the topic when he gets around to it.

    • florwood

      Yep. Some people describe the Book of Mormon the same way. What you think about it depends in part on how you approach it.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X