On Pamela Geller, Garland, and the Gunmen


A Texas mosque
There are many Muslims in Texas.  Good citizens, most of them, as well as devout believers in Islam.  This is a mosque belonging to the Islamic Association of North Texas.


Since some have asked, I’ll answer here:


I think that Pamela Geller and her associates had every right to put on that Muhammad-cartoon-drawing event in Garland, Texas.


I also think that it was foolish and irresponsible to do so, and that organizing events designed to mock the faith of others is contemptible.


It’s rather like, say, putting a crucifix in a beaker of urine in order to make a “statement.”


Yet I understand and sympathize with the defiant spirit of the Garland event.  We need to assert our freedom.


On the other hand, I would not have participated in it, and I would have condemned it and I do condemn it.  It was a profoundly un-Christian thing to do.  (Pamela Geller, of course, isn’t Christian, but I’m betting that many of those in attendance professed to be.)


Still, I also condemn those who, in the wake of the attack on the event by two armed Islamists, have vented their anger largely on the event’s organizers.  The two gunmen — who were killed before they could murder anybody (and despite their body armor and assault weapons) by a part-time security guard armed with a pistol — deserve anger and condemnation far more than the people they hoped to slaughter.


Even though I disapprove of those people.


Have I made my ambivalence clear enough?


Here’s a piece by David French, responding to Garland and its aftermath:





"The reason that atheists are unconvinced is that theistic claims are designed to be impossible ..."

Is Darwinism necessarily atheistic? (Part Two)
"Judge Roy Moore apparently says that "No" means "Yes."No WONDER that other fellow is confused."

A reflection about one person’s response ..."
"gemli: "I'm not asserting anything. I'm saying, along with many other atheists, that I'm not ..."

Is Darwinism necessarily atheistic? (Part Two)

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment