“Kalam Infinity Arguments and the Infinite Past”

 

A view of Montserrat with clouds
Montserrat, near Barcelona (Wikimedia Commons)

 

Many, though not all, criticisms of Mormonism and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints are fairly shallow and rather obviously flawed.

 

The so-called “kalam infinity argument” is not one of those.  Drawn from the works of medieval Islamic philosophical theologians — hence the Arabic word kalam, which literally means “speech” but, in this context, refers to a kind of dialectical theology that flourished in Islamic circles from at least the 800s AD — it’s a serious piece of thinking.

 

Blake Ostler responds to an attempt by the evangelical philosophers Paul Copan and William Lane Craig — both of whom I’ve met and for both of whom I have considerable respect — to apply the kalam infinity argument to Mormonism:

 

http://blakeostler.com/docs/Kalam.pdf

 

Posted from Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain

 

 

"So you're telling us that you HID those posts and SUPPRESSED them so that honest, ..."

Four Years Ago, Today
"JFK, while a bright and bold leader as well as a war hero, had an ..."

On Fatherhood, Chastity, and Traditional Values
"Which is not what Lou is saying. But hey - ridicule is often a popular ..."

On Fatherhood, Chastity, and Traditional Values
"Ahem. My point is that there are reasons people live in disaster-prone areas. The same ..."

A thought on one small portion ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment