Book Notice: John Goldingay on Proverbs

John Goldingay
Proverbs, Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs for Everyone
London: SPCK, 2014.
Available a

By Felicity Clift

If I was to attempt to summarise my first thoughts on Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs prior to reading John Goldingay’s study on these books “for Everyone” they may be something like this:

- Proverbs. An almost random collection of sayings for the purpose of teaching young men how to live wisely and prosperously… and a token chapter about a woman who is said to be exemplary at homemaking.

- Song of Songs. Written by Solomon; about sex; supposedly a metaphor for God’s relationship to his people; excessively pastoral (i.e. lots of fruits and vineyards); also telling girls to remain virgins until they’re married.

- Ecclesiastes. Realistic, and perhaps pessimistic; written by Solomon; a biblical anomaly.

In presenting these as my first thoughts I do not mean that I believe these to be a true understanding of these books. Instead, these are the ideas that have accumulated from various presentations and which remain the first thoughts which come to mind – my internal word-association (some of which need to be unlearned). I am blessed to be studying at theological college as I write, and have recently had opportunity to study further the biblical genre of wisdom literature, but higher education is not essential for a clearer understanding of these books. Instead, Goldingay’s ‘Old Testament for Everyone’ series offers clarification and simplification.

In my previous review of Deuteronomy and Numbers for Everyone by Goldingay (London: SPCK, 2015), I commented on the value of reading from the beginning. It seems this is Goldingay’s formula in this series – to lay important foundations in the introduction and then to fill these ideas out, and the ‘filling’ is worth reading. I particularly appreciate Goldingay’s lighthearted willingness to present his opinions openly. Goldingay has once again engaged my thinking in new and encouraging ways.

His explanation for the Solomonic association with these books suggests that Solomon was ‘clueless about love’ (p.3) and therefore an unlikely author. In fact, the association is because Solomon was the ‘patron saint of wisdom’ (p.3). Goldingay also encourages deeper reading and broader application of the text. He suggests that the links to Babylon and Egypt that are found in wisdom literature represent the ability to learn from anyone’s experiences. All people are image bearers of God in his world, irrespective of their culture or beliefs (p.4-5). Amongst many other ideas, Goldingay comments on Christian social responsibility (p.9), on a different biblical attitude to poverty (p.28), on making plans (p.86), and on the importance of feminine teaching (p.152). As a woman from an evangelical upbringing I find Goldingay’s preparedness to acknowledge the place of gender in the Scriptures encouraging. Instead of presenting the writer and the speakers within Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs as generically ‘human’, Goldingay explores what the gender of the speaker adds to our understanding of the text. He suggests that beginning and ending Proverbs with a focus on teaching from women (Wisdom, Folly, and the strong woman of Chapter 31) ‘completes’ the masculine teaching in the inner chapters, just as the story of Moses and Pharaoh (in Exodus 1-15) is set in the context of women (p.152). Song of Songs similarly is embellished in my mind by Goldingay’s suggestion that the young woman is an initiator in this egalitarian relationship (p.245) and not a mere piece of property, however cherished she is by the man.

In reading this study guide, Goldingay has helped me to recognise the half-truths of my first associations regarding these books:

- Indeed, Proverbs and Ecclesiastes do contain some random collections of sayings, but they do so for the purpose of encouraging the audience to learn from the experiences of others (both men and women) in a practical way in their present setting.

- Song of Songs is about sex but not in a metaphorical God/human sense. It is an acknowledgement of the present reality and management of human desires.

- Rather than being biblical anomalies, the language and content of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes and Song of Songs may be explained by their intention to look to the present (as distinct from other biblical books which tend to consider Israel’s future or past).

It seems that, just as the writer of Ecclesiastes wants to keep faith honest and so says ‘things that you wouldn’t have thought a churchman would say’ (p.177), Goldingay, too, wants to keep faith honest, and so presents ideas that are sometimes less conventional but not without grounds. His presentation remains engaging and rich and entirely God-oriented, and having now read two of Goldingay’s ‘Old Testament for Everyone’ study guides my appetite for the series, as well as the Old Testament, has been whet. Goldingay certainly makes it clear that, just as the Old Testament was ‘a living resource for understanding God, God’s ways in the world and God’s ways with us’ for Jesus and the New Testament writers, it remains so for Christians today (p.1).

Flyck Clift studies theology at Ridley College in Melbourne alongside working as a nurse in her local hospital. She is currently involved in leading a home group at church and enjoys encouraging people in integrating their belief in God with their daily living.

Brant Pitre on the Divine Jesus of Mark’s Gospel

Is the Marcan Jesus identified with Yahweh? Brant Pitre draws on recent research to give an emphatic "Yes."Is Jesus Merely a "Human Messiah" in Mark? Are Meier, Marcus, Yarbro-Collins, Boring, and Hays off base to see Jesus’ egō eimi saying in Mark 6 as a reference to the divine name? If so, how does one explain the multiple connections between Jesus walking on the sea and key OT theophanies?Photo from The Jesus Blog. … [Read More...]

Jesus Quotes Republican Candidates

From Jimmy Kimmel, Jesus reads quotes from Republican Candidates. Hillarious! … [Read More...]

Hardest NT Essay Question Ever! Can You Answer It?

Preamble: Read Peter Lampe, Christians at Rome from Paul to Valentinus, 120-122.Bishop Callistus of Rome (217-22) had a problem. Many women from the Roman upper classes (senatorial and equestrian) had become Christians. However, there was a shortage of male Christians of the same social rank. So … [Read More...]

Book Review: Paul and the Vocation of Israel

Over at RBL is my review of Lionel Windor's volume on Paul and the Vocation of Israel: How Paul's Jewish Identity Informs his Apostolic Ministry with Special Reference to Romans.Sadly, SBL membership required in order to read it (grrhhh). … [Read More...]

Book Notice: John Goldingay on Numbers and Deuteronomy

John Goldingay Numbers and Deuteronomy for Everyone London: SPCK, 2015. Available at Amazon.comBy Felicity ClyftIt is a bold claim to say that a book can be ‘for everyone’. From a literary point of view we might wonder if this is even possible. What would such a book look like? John Gol … [Read More...]

Has Anyone Heard of the New Illuminations Commentary Series

I have belatedly just become aware of the Illuminations commentary series edited by C.S. Seow with Loren Stuckenbruck, Scott Jones, and Judith Newman, published by Eerdmans.So far only C.S. Seow on Job 1-21 is out, but some capable scholars are lined up and it looks like it could be a good … [Read More...]

Review of Mending a Fractured Church

Joe Valenti offers a nice review of Mending a Fractured Church (edited by M. Bird and B. Rosner, published by Lexham Press). The authors of these short essays do an excellent job of presenting their topics with clarity and brevity – showing from Scripture the goal of Christian unity, but also u … [Read More...]

Two New Books on Paul and Apocalyptic Theology

In my forthcoming book Anomalous Jew: Paul among Jews, Greeks, and Romans (Eerdmans), I have a chapter on Paul and apocalyptic interpretation. Wish I had access to these books when I was writing it:Just saw this coming out from T&T Clark/Bloomsbury, wish I had access to it a year … [Read More...]

Liberals Should Tolerate Anglican Views on Sexuality

Great article by James Mumford on "A Truly Liberal Society Would Tolerate the Anglican Church's Views on Sexuality," in The Spectator: Back in 2013 advocates for same-sex marriage argued that the church’s beliefs about sexuality shouldn’t be imposed on the rest of society. That makes sense. But now … [Read More...]

Great Refugee Story

University of Western Sydney has a great advertisement featuring the story of Deng Thiak, a Sudanese child soldier, now refugee lawyer. … [Read More...]

Book Review: Peter False Disciple and Apostate according to Saint Matthew

Robert H. Gundry Peter -- False Disciple and Apostate according to Saint Matthew Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2015. Available at Chris PorterIn this short work Robert Gundry advances an intriguing hypothesis that the Matthean Gospel presents the Apostle Peter as a ‘False D … [Read More...]

Imperator Caesar Augustus Divi Filius

Over the Christmas and New Year's break I began reading for pleasure, and to expand my knowledge, the recent biography on Augustus by Adrian Goldsworthy: Augustus: First Emperor of Rome. It is well written; and while Ancient historians will be in a much better position to judge Goldsworthy's … [Read More...]

The Gospel of Mark and Chalcedon

The other day I was reading through an old article by M. Eugene Boring on Markan Christology, and came across this quote: The explicit use of God-language for Jesus by later NT authors and the classical creeds is in continuity with the Christology already present in Mark. To state the matter … [Read More...]

Engaging Josh Jipp’s Christ is King, Chapter 5: King and Justice

In this post, I engage with Josh’s final chapter in his recent book Christ Is King: Paul's Royal Ideology: "King and Justice: God’s Righteousness and the Righteous King in Romans."Interacting with Josh’s carefully argued and evidenced-filled chapters has been rigorously instructive and thorou … [Read More...]