Jonathan Edwards on Mentoring

Jonathan Edwards Had an Opinion about Mentoring Too

By Rhys Bezzant (Ridley College)

I heard a leading American evangelist preach a sermon recently in which Jonathan Edwards was never named but his signature theology was everywhere. Edwards’s views on creation as an overflow of the life of God, and his understanding of the Christian life involving the gift of a new sense of God’s beauty are now commonplace in evangelical circles. Unfortunately, his influence has not yet washed through to the way we describe and practise mentoring. I often hear the basic argument, which doesn’t engage great theological themes, that just as Paul mentored Timothy and Titus, so should we find younger believers to invest in. Edwards has so much to teach beyond this.

For example, we can’t really explain what the goal of mentoring is, until we understand what the church is for. Edwards hoped that new practices generated by the revivals could exist side by side with traditional structures in the life of the church, and this was reflected too in his practice of mentoring: he gave permission to his mentees to grow into new roles responsive to new situations and saw the value of developing new strategies for faith transmission, while still holding on to the central Protestant conviction that the church is focused on a ministry of Word and sacraments. (Read my book “Jonathan Edwards and the Church” for more detail!) If the church is a tree, contextually shaped yet theologically rooted, mentoring within the church should work with new insights in pedagogy, pastoral theology and human culture, while at the same time helping others to grasp the authority which God gives to those set over us in the Lord. Submission is part of godliness, after all. Authority is from the top down, but takes into account the agency of those below. Mentoring can be a strategy for adaptive leadership development.

Edwards also adopts new ways of communicating with his mentees. He writes informal letters to them, addressing issues of relationships, finances, scheduling, and theology. Before his time, letter-writing was the preserve of the wealthy or powerful, for example generals, diplomats, kings or businessmen, who exercised their authority through their correspondence, but Edwards wants to empower as much as bark orders. His educational assumptions similarly gave room to learning through Socratic dialogue and mutual affection, with age-specific developmental expectations. Even the Indian children in his care in Stockbridge were not expected to learn their lessons by rote but through conversation or music. In one extraordinary miscellany, written around 1757 just before he died, Edwards argues that the exchange of two minds through conversation is a means for God to exercise his moral government of the world (Misc. 1338). Union with God and with each other is at the heart of Edwards’s vision for the world and ultimately the church, so what better way of encouraging that kind of unity than by friendship expressed in conversation: “And the wellbeing and happiness of society is friendship … but friendship, above all other things that belong to society, requires conversation.” Mentoring in Edwards’s estimation can play its part in God’s directing the world to its proper end.

And perhaps surprisingly for a man of Reformed convictions, Edwards frequently highlights the importance of the visual in his understanding of discipleship. The job of the preacher is to impress on listeners an experience of seeing the Lord, or to “placard Christ” as Paul says. No wonder then that Edwards believes in the power of example to help us along the path to glory. He edits the journal of David Brainerd, and provides a preface and an appendix, in order to make Brainerd’s life one worthy of imitation. He writes: “There are two ways of representing and recommending true religion and virtue to the world, which God hath made use of: the one is by doctrine and precept; the other is by instance and example: Both are abundantly used in the holy Scriptures.” If we shall be like the Lord when we see him at the end of our days, then perhaps we can be like the Lord when we see him in others during our lifetime. Providing a model to emulate appeals to the inductive approach of many evangelicals based on their own individual experience of regeneration. Mentoring involves multiple senses, and gives us a sense of personal integration in a world where our self-understanding is fragmented or broken.

We need to do better to cultivate the art of mentoring in our churches, and Edwards points us to profound resources for the task. We know that his theology highlights the first things and the last things, but what we don’t often realise is that these form the framework for us to celebrate and ponder the next things as well, namely our closest relationships in our daily lives.

Rhys Bezzant teaches at Ridley College, Melbourne, which is hosting the next Edwards Congress in August 2015 (

Review of Joseph Fantin’s Lord of the Entire World

See my RBL review of Joseph Fantin's excellent study Lord of the Entire World: Lord Jesus, A Challenge to Lord Caesar?Here's the blurb:How would the confession, ‘Jesus is Lord’, have been understood in the first-century Roman world? Was it more than a statement of one’s devotion to Jesus? Was it also an implicit challenge to the living Caesar, the lord of the Roman empire? There were many lords in the first century and the use of the title kyrios was complex. Clearly Paul was influenced b … [Read More...]

Remember the Bart Ehrman Review Session at SBL

If you're going to SBL in San Diego then remember, remember the 22nd of November. Here's why:Extent of Theological Diversity in Earliest Christianity11/22/2014 9:00 AM to 11:30 AM Room: Room 8 (Upper level) - San Diego Convention Center (CC)Theme: A Panel Review of Bart Ehrman's How Jesus Became God: The Exaltation of a Jewish Preacher from Galilee (HarperCollins, 2014)David Capes, Houston Baptist University, Presiding (5 min) James McGrath, Butler University, Respondent (15 m … [Read More...]

If You’re Near Las Vegas this Coming Monday, Then I’ll Be Here!

Grateful for the invitation from Paul Trainor and John Anthony Dunne to speak at this event: … [Read More...]

Things to Do at ETS/IBR/SBL in San Diego

Okay, time for my annual list of things to do at ETS/IBR/SBL!Most important of all, remember that this year I will celebrate my 40th birthday at ETS/SBL! I think the best way for everyone to show their affection for me on this significant occasion is either by a gift certificate from Baylor Unive … [Read More...]

Le Donne on Bird on Social Memory

Anthony Le Donne has a post over at The Jesus Blog  where he notes my tacit endorsement of social memory as a hermeneutical framework for studying Jesus traditions. I have to confess that ever since I read the work of Anthony Le Donne and Chris Keith that I've had a side interest in the area. While I … [Read More...]

John Chrysostom on How God Became Jesus

So wish I knew of this quote before I wrote my chapters for the HGBJ book! Christ did not become god from human advancement - perish the thought ... We preach not a human made into a god, but confess a god made human. Cited from M. David Litwa, Iesus Deus: The Early Christian Depiction of Jesus as … [Read More...]

Jason Hood’s Hilarious Review of Rob Bell’s New Book on Marriage

Over at Books & Culture, Jason Hood has a hilarious review of Rob Bell's new book The Zimzum of Love by compiling the script for an editorial board meeting of the publishers to discuss Rob Bell's book.Here's part of it: JP: "Rob, I've been worried. Normally these books take six weeks to w … [Read More...]

Michael Holmes Appointed as Director of the Greens Scholars Initiative

Congrats to Mike Holmes who has been appointed as the executive director of the Greens Scholar Initiative. Assuming the role of executive director of the Green Scholars Initiative, Holmes will lead a team of researchers and student-scholars at more than 60 universities around the world advancing … [Read More...]

Interview about The Gospel of the Lord

I was interviewed over at Dunelm Road about my book The Gospel of the Lord.Thanks to  Jason Maston for the interesting questions! … [Read More...]

Book Notice: Thinking Through Paul

Bruce W. Longenecker & Todd D. Still Thinking Through Paul: A Survey of His Life, Letters, and Theology Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2014. Available at Amazon.comThere are a lot of good introductions to Paul out there (heck, I've even written one!). However, this one by Bruce Longenecker … [Read More...]

What Do Rick Warren, N.T. Wright, and Russell Moore All Have in Common?

Well, it turns out, that the Pope wants to know what they think about marriage? The three have been invited to a Vatican Colloquium on marriage and family.Read the article over at CT. Very interesting!In other Catholic news, some wonder if there is going to be papal schism with Pope Francis … [Read More...]

The Karl Barth and Katy Perry Song Challenge

Okay peeps, as part of the Ridley Follies, I've re-written the lyrics to the Katy Perry song "I Kissed a Girl and I Liked it" to "I Read Karl Barth and I liked it." Idea comes from Jessica Parkes, but execution is strictly my own.See the lyrics below.What I want to know is whether there … [Read More...]

Simon Gathercole’s New Book on Penal Substitution

Just saw this in the SBL catalogue from Baker!Simon Gathercole, Defending Substitution: An Essay on Atonement in Paul, 144 pp., due out in Feb 2015. In recent decades, the church and academy have witnessed intense debates concerning the concept of penal substitution to describe Christ's atoning … [Read More...]

Review of Gospel of the Lord by Mike Skinner

Check out the swell  review of GOTL by Mike Skinner. Wish I could use this line as a blurb!! In the end, perhaps the highest praise I can give this book is to say that it stands in my mind as a close cousin to N.T. Wright’s Jesus and the Victory of God. Bird mentions in the introduction that rea … [Read More...]