by Dr. Andy Bannister
The path through the trees was narrow and overgrown, meandering its way through birch, oak and elm, climbing gently as it wound its way up from the valley. A few minutes walking brought me to the ancient moss-laden wall that surrounded the forest, from which a wooden gate led out on the hillside.
From there the track quickly steepened as it wound sinuously up toward the mountaintop. I paused every so often to catch my breath, turning to watch the cloud shadows chase one another across the flanks of the hills on the farside of the valley.
Onwards and upwards I climbed, as the first hints of dusk began to take hold and the shadows grewlonger. I gained the summit ridge just as the westering sun was beginning to sink behind a bank of clouds hanging over the distant Langdale Pikes, among the most well known of Lakeland’s hills and loved by the poets, by Wordsworth, Coleridge and Southey.
Suddenly, as the sun dropped completely behind the cloudbank, the whole sky turned the colour ofburnished gold and the clouds themselves lit up as if on fire, a maelstrom of red, orange and ochre, with the occasional flash of silver. At that moment, through a gap in the clouds poured a great ray of sunshine, streaming into the valley below like a searchlight and throwing into stark relief the lines of fields, lanes and hedgerows.
All of this took place in utter silence: not a breath of wind, nor the cry of a bird, nor the plaintive bleat of a sheep. For a moment, it seemed as if the whole of creation had paused and taken a deep breath. I watched, transfixed, hearing just my heartbeat in my own ears from the exertion of the climb. The lightshow continued as colours mixed and mingled and shifted. I was awestruck with wonder, unsure what the right reaction was before such beauty ” one wanted to cry, to dance, to shout for joy. I was reminded of Mark Twain’s line:
The summer world was bright and fresh, and brimming with life. There was a song in every heart; and if the heart was young the music issued at the lips.2
For many of us, our instinctive reaction when faced with such beauty is to try to capture it on camera:perhaps we can somehow bottle the experience, pin it down, capture it in megapixels. But digital renderings are flat, lifeless things, capturing the colour, but not the sounds, smells, textures, emotions “the being-there-ness, what philosophers call qualia.
Reflecting on our reaction to beauty, two philosophies present themselves. The first is naturalism, the worldview of many of my atheist friends, which says that only material things exist: atoms, particles, stuff. There is no soul, no spirit, no transcendent reality and certainly no God. However, for those of ustruly love the outdoors, especially the wild places, naturalism patently fails; for it would claim that all I saw from the mountaintop that evening were atoms and photons whilst my experience ” well, that was only the motion of chemicals in my brain. Anthony Esolen playfully parodies this philosophy:
[For the philosophical naturalist] it is best to keep the word “only” ready in the arsenal at alltimes. The flame of the sky at sunset is “only” the part of spectrum that penetrates theatmosphere at that angle ” it is “only” something or other material that scientists know about ” or at least somebody knows all them in some Important Places. Beauty is “only” a neurological tic, or a personal opinion.3
Yet this does not come close, not even remotely, to my actual experience on the mountain that evening. Reminiscent of the “flat” digital photograph, naturalism represents a fumbling attempt to simplify and reduce an experience that is rich, deep, three-dimensional, to a caricature. It is not that the naturalistic explanation is entirely false, it is simply that it falls considerably short, just as describing Paradise Lostas a “a poem”, Chartres Cathedral as “a building”, or love an “emotion” equally does not do justice to their entire reality.
Beauty is one of many such experiences that strips away our pretensions, exposes the frailties of ourphilosophy and points us beyond ourselves. The instinctive reaction to natural beauty is that it causes us to yearn, to desire, to sing with joy. As Wordsworth, who loved the English Lake District with a passion wrote: “My heart leaps up when I behold ” the sky”.4But there’s more. I sensed that evening as I watched the fiery sunset a feeling almost akin tohomesickness, to a desire for something or somewhere more beautiful, more radiant, more real. Whereas naturalism struggles to begin to even to describe such emotions and the experience of seeing real beauty, a second philosophy, the Christian worldview offers a more compelling explanation. Consider these words of the Bible:
The heavens declare the glory of God, the skies proclaim the work of his hands.
Why do we respond the way we do to beauty? Simply because it points beyond itself to something else, to the God who is the very source of all wonder, all goodness, all beauty, the God who is creator and artist and has painted and sculpted in creation a myriad masterpieces. This understanding of beauty also helps explain that sense of “homesickness” I described; beauty reminds us, tells us, shouts at us that we are made for something more than just this world.
Atheist and existentialist Albert Camus, wrestling with these ideas, wrote: “Beauty is unbearable, drives us to despair, offering us for a minute the glimpse of an eternity that we should like to stretch out over the whole of time.”5
Tragically, I think that on naturalism this hold trues, because beauty points beyond itself and sets the heart yearning for something that molecules, atoms and particles alone can never ultimately satisfy.
In the Bible, we read these words: “God has made everything beautiful in its time; He has also seteternity in the hearts of men” (Ecclesiastes 3:11). Eternity in our hearts. I might also add “and our eyes”.
Plato once said, through the mouth of Socrates,6 that “wonder is the beginning of philosophy” and whilst that is true, it begs a question: where is its end? The answer, if we are to live authentically, is only in the fulfilment of wonder in the God who is the source of all beauty. Once again, I think it is often the poets who see this most clearly. Dante opens the third and final canticle of his epic poem, The Divine Comedy,with these words:7
The glory of the One who moves all things
penetrates the universe with light,
more radiant in one part and elsewhere less:
I have been in that heaven He makes most bright
and seen things neither mind can hold nor tongue
utter, when one descends from such great height;
But as we near the One for whom we long,
our intellects so plunge into the deep,
memory cannot follow where we go.
Nevertheless what small part I can keep
of that holy kingdom treasured in my heart
will now become the matter of my song.
Thomas De Quincey, Recollections of the Lake Poets, Edited with an Introduction by David Wright (New York:
Penguin, 1970 ).
Mark Twain, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer(New York: Dover Publications, 1998) 8.2
Anthony Esolen, Ten Ways to Destroy the Imagination of Your Child (Wilmington, DE: ISI Books) 236.
Wordsworth, ‘My heart leaps up when I behold’ in Stephen Gill (ed.), William Wordsworth: The Major Works(Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2008 ) 246.3
Albert Camus, Notebooks 1935-1951 (New York: Marlow & Company, 1963) 6.
Dante, The Divine Comedy, Paradiso Canto I.