Let's play "Spot the loaded verb"

Reuters religion editor Tom Heneghan has just used one of those verbs that taints an entire news story. At least, I think that “Pope’s ‘Living Will’ Wants Life Support to the End” is supposed to be a hard news story about the implications of a major papal address. Then again there is this: “The Catholic Church has traditionally taught that doctors and families could end artificial life-extending measures in good conscience if a dying patient’s prospects seemed hopeless. John Paul, who has long railed against a ‘culture of death’ he saw in abortion and artificial birth control, surprised moral theologians in a speech in March 2004 by insisting Catholics can no longer make such decisions even in extreme cases.” Whoa! Spot the loaded verb?

Print Friendly

About tmatt

Terry Mattingly directs the Washington Journalism Center at the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities. He writes a weekly column for the Universal Syndicate.

  • Stephen A.

    railed

    (Wow, I signed in just to type one word! I can’t do that!)

    Yes, this is again typical, creating a negative picture in the mind of the reader of what the pope’s been saying. I wonder if editors even notice this bias that creeps into so many news stories. Or if they even care.

    I wonder if they’d notice if someone wrote that Ted Kennedy “has long railed against the pro-life movement”?

    Bet they would.

  • http://www.jonswerens.com Jon Swerens

    The secret loaded verb is:

    insisting

    Because that means the pope is telling Catholics what to do! The nerve of the guy!

  • Brad

    I don’t see “railed” as a negative word alot of the time…some of the things he rails against need to be railed against.

    Brad

  • carol mcl

    Is it “surprised”, as if to suggest this is a totally new teaching, a turnaround from previous church teaching?

  • carol mcl

    Is it “surprised”, as if to suggest this is a totally new teaching, a turnaround from previous church teaching?

  • http://www.tmatt.net Terry Mattingly

    Railed it is.

    JPII did not rail against Communism. This is not a man who rails.

    And I don’t think I have ever read a use of “railed” that did not imply the person was a bit wacked out.

  • Jill M

    Spot the loaded verb — nice! I’m getting an excellent education reading GetReligion every evening! I’d recommend this blog for journalism students, seminarians . . . heck, even savvy high school students! (And I did figure out that is was railed, by the way. Just couldn’t sign in and post yesterday for some reason!)


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X