Town criers on the Pew report

town crierOne of the greatest aspects of the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life report released Monday was the state-by-state data. Unfortunately, the coverage in my morning newspaper, The Indianapolis Star, was lacking. A combination of the Associated Press and USA Today made-up the above-the-fold front-page story while the jump had a small graphic comparing the Indiana data to the entire United States.

Some non-national newspapers such as The Dallas Morning News focused on the big headline of the report: “Most Americans say many religions can lead to eternal life.” According to a reader, the story received “big-middle-above-the-fold” placement Tuesday morning. In addition, the article has a helpful section on the report’s limitations. (Also see an online chat with the reporter Jeffrey Weiss on the subject.)

Next door to me in Ohio, The Columbus Dispatch gave their locally reported story similar front page above-the-fold treatment. Similar to the IndyStar, The Dispatch focused on the national story and included a breakout graphic on the state data. The Chicago Sun-Times did a similar article.

According to a reporter friend of mine, there were a large number of journalists on Pew Forum’s teleconference regarding this study. Based on what I’ve seen about the report, newspapers now have an tremendous resource to better understand their communities.

An excellent example of a reporter taking advantage of the advance time Pew gave journalists on this report is the story by the Orlando Sentinel‘s Jeannette Rivera-lyles:

Floridians aren’t jumping out of their beach chairs to go to church.

In fact, among Bible Belt states, Florida ranks last in church attendance among residents who consider themselves religious, according to a new study of more than 36,000 Americans.

Another great example is the article by the Tulsa World‘s Ryan Strong:

A national survey proves that Oklahoma continues to be a vital buckle on the Bible Belt.

The Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life released on Monday the second half of its U.S. Religious Landscape Survey, which indicated that a majority of Oklahomans are active participants in a faith-based community.

Surprisingly, The Los Angeles Times also led with the state perspective. The reporter Duke Helfand knows his audience. He puts the fact that 42 percent of the state’s population thinks that “Hollywood is a corrupting influence.” Not surprisingly, considering recent events, the issue of homosexuality appeared in the third paragraph:

Californians, long known for their propensity to buck convention, have apparently done it again: A national survey released Monday revealed that they are less religious and less certain about the existence of God than the nation as a whole.

Residents of the Golden State do not pray as much as people in other parts of the country. They are less inclined to take scripture literally. And they are likelier to embrace “more than one true way” of interpreting their religious teachings.

Fifty-nine percent of them say that homosexuality should be accepted by society, compared to 50% of people nationwide who hold that view, according to the U.S. Religious Landscape Survey.

Local journalists should take advantage of the advance time they receive with in-depth reports such as this and prepare an article that helps their readers better understand the nature of their community’s religious make-up. The national perspective is nice, but often that is something that readers have already heard about.

Photo of Peter Moore, Town Crier to the Mayor of London and The Greater London Authority, used under a Creative Commons Attribution license.

Print Friendly

  • http://perpetuaofcarthage.blogspot.com/ Perpetua

    Would you please add the link for the Los Angeles Times story?

  • http://www.getreligion.org/?p=2677 dpulliam

    Sorry about that. Too many links for my own good. Here is the link and it’s in the story now too.

  • http://religion.beloblog.com/ Jeffrey Weiss

    Thanks for the link! I agree with your main point and I’ll only note that the graphic had a whole section of Texas-specific stats.

  • FW Ken

    So is there a technical jounalism term for “big-middle-above-the-fold” placement? You know, the story that takes up 50% – 60% of the top middle of the page?

  • http://www.getreligion.org/?p=2677 dpulliam

    Not sure I am aware of a term that fits what you’re looking for FW Ken. “Big-middle-above-the-fold” was the term used by someone who sent us the article. Perhaps a copy editor or someone more familiar in layout would know?

    If I could find a PDF of the actual front page, I’d provide a link, but sadly I haven’t been able to find one.

  • FW Ken

    I know what it looked like because I saw it on the shelf at the 7-11; “Big-middle-above-the-fold” was my phrasing in a comment on the first post about this survey. I felt a little silly writing it, but didn’t know a proper term for the placement.

  • http://www.downeastpagan.com/ Ananta Androscoggin

    The story carried by the Portland Press Herald, about the data of this poll for the state of Maine, seemed to carry a strong disappointment on the part of the reporter that our state is NOT being overwhelmed by the evangelicals.

  • http://ungravenimage.com/blog Judy Rey Wasserman

    I read the story first online in the NY Times, where it became a popular emailed article for a couple of days. The article led me to discover your site as I worked on my own blog article about it as I question the causes. As an artist, a religious artist, I looked at visual art. I think the new media allows for more armchair exploration of other ideas, including visual ones.
    In my article as you have also) I link directly to the Pew site and study. The ease of accessing information through the Internet means that wherever anyone lives, they have access to the news from other sources, and thus, other slants.
    I now have your excellent site on my Google homepage. Thanks!


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X