Here’s a link to an excellent essay on Huffington Post by Rabbi Eric H. Yoffie, President of the Union for Reform Judaism. Here is the gist of the piece:
Americans are disenchanted with liberal religion because they crave religious passion, because they yearn for moments of religious ecstasy, and because they are disenchanted with religious institutions and leaders who spend too much time talking and who seem genuinely afraid of religious feeling.
It is understandable that UUs and other religious liberals have an aversion to enthusiastic – much less ecstatic – religion. Many of us grew up in religions where emotion was valued and reason was viewed with suspicion. I’ve seen good people have an ecstatic religious experience and then get themselves and others into all kinds of difficulties because they attempted to interpret it literally – either because they had been taught it should be viewed literally or because they knew no other way.
But just as the New Atheists are wrong to throw the baby of religion out with the dirty bathwater of fundamentalism, so are religious liberals wrong to shun emotional, passionate religious experience just because some people have gotten it wrong.
As a UU and a Pagan I have a foot in both worlds. As an engineer and a Druid, I have a foot in both worlds. I experience both worlds and I teach and speak from both worlds… or at least I try. Even when I lead rituals designed to make people really feel something, I tend to rely too much on the spoken word. Changing this requires conscious effort.
But… you have to be willing to let go. You have to be willing to relinquish control and let the Spirit take you where she will, even if only for a few minutes. If you are afraid of looking foolish, if you’re afraid of being judged, you aren’t likely to feel safe enough to loosen the reins. For this reason, the Denton CUUPS group saves our most ecstatic rituals for closed circles, when we know the only people there will be people who share our outlook on religious experience. But bit by bit we introduce a bit more experience into our CUUPS circles and into our Sunday UU services.
For me, reason is meat and potatoes. Ecstasy is fruit and vegetables. You can live on just meat and potatoes, or you can live on just fruit and vegetables. The question is why you would want to? You’re healthier with a wider variety of foods, and besides, variety is a lot more fun!
Some people will always be too skeptical to participate in ecstatic religion. That’s OK – there’s a place in liberal religion for them too. But we need to provide the opportunity for genuine religious experience to the increasing number of people who are seeking them.