Cardinal Dolan Takes to the Sunday Show Pulpit, Preaching the Message of True Freedom

I’m forever uncomfortable with the concept of the Sunday morning political talk shows. As someone both naturally inclined to and professionally obligated to watch such shows, I have always wanted them to be Saturday morning shows. I would watch Firing Line then back in the day and I would happily watch these news chat shows on a similar schedule.

A quick story that added to my discomfort: A few months back, David Gregory interviewed Michele Bachmann after she won the Iowa straw poll on Meet the Press. (Remember that? Seems so long ago. Also reminds you how valuable an indicator of electoral results that fundraiser for the Iowa GOP is = not so much of one.) He described religion as considering God as merely “a sense of comfort and safe harbor and inspiration.” I thought Gregory did a good job there of encapsulating exactly the challenge before us: We live in a culture where you don’t have to be actively, consciously hostile to religion to be a secularist — or an accessory to — wanting to drive it to the margins, wanting to keep its practice to inside a church or to a morning or end-of-the-day private reflection, something harmless and maybe healthy like yoga. The existence of these shows on Sunday mornings has always seemed to me a cultural gesture in favor of that marginalizing posture.

That said, there can be some wonderful, apostolic moments on those Sunday shows. Anyone who cares about what Cardinal Dolan said on Face the Nation in a taped interview that aired Easter Sunday morning, probably cares about the political points he touched on — the whole real point of having him on, right? But while as cardinal archbishop of New York and current president of the bishop’s conference in D.C., he finds himself with a political role, he is primarily a shepherd. So you can’t take that away from him when he’s participating in our political religion’s services.

In a closing exchange on Face the Nation, Bob Schieffer asked Cardinal Dolan about his “greatest challenge.” Dolan ran with the opportunity for a pastoral moment in the media. “In a way,” the cardinal said, “it is the same as it was that first Easter Sunday morning, to try to show that God, religion, the church is on the side of life and light and freedom and hope.”

“That is the biggest challenge, that life giving, liberating, ennobling, uplifting message … of the Bible, of morality, of the church, of Jesus,” the cardinal continued.

Engaging the man he is conversing with as much as the audience watching, Cardinal Dolan addressed the host, bringing him into the picture as much as anyone, not forgetting a soul as he delivers his message, which, of course, isn’t his but His:

that’s our challenge, Bob, and in a world — I mean you are on the frontlines, you got to report bad news all the time, most of the time we want to cry when we see the news, because there is so much darkness and tragedy and sadness, so the greatest challenge I got is try to preach the good news and try to show that the light and life and promise of The Gospel always trumps the bad news that we hear all the time. There is a great religious challenge.

Welcome to Easter Monday. Let’s get to work.

  • stan chaz

    Mr. Dolan claims that “Nor can we argue purely from revelation: why should other citizens respect our opinions if we do not present them as applicable to all people regardless of religion?” That’s precisely the problem: hiding under your tax-exempt mantle of “revealed” holiness, you want to tell the rest of us what to do, and how to live. The bottom line is that absolutely NO ONE is coming into our Churches or places of worship and telling believers what to believe…..or forcing them to use contraception. BUT If the Bishops (and other denominations) want to continue running businesses outside of their places of worship…businesses that employ millions of people of varying faiths -or no “faith” at all- THEN they must play by the same rules and rights that other workers live by and enjoy (especially if their businesses use our tax dollars, and skip paying taxes, in the process). If the Jehovah’s Witnesses church hires me, can they alter my health insurance to exclude blood transfusions? Even worse- what if they operated a hospital by their “rules”? This is not a “war on religion”. Never was. However, it IS a war BY some religions… on women and men who simply want to plan their families, to control their futures, to keep their jobs, and to have health insurance that allows them to do that. Likewise It is a war -not on religion- but on gays and others who the church deems to be second class citizens, and targets of its venom. The churches (or the IRS) need to decide whether these churches are  going to be political organizations proclaiming and practicing partisan politics from the pulpit…or….tax-exempt places of WORSHIP. Not both. Not in America.

    • Beth

      Is someone being forced or compelled to work for a Catholic institution against her will? Is the Catholic charity, hospital, school, etc., the only employment option for someone? Really?

      If someone wants prescribed contraception, let him or her apply for jobs at places that provide for it. Leave those employers who have moral issues with abortifacient contraceptives alone.

      Grow up.

  • Therese Z


    Women can buy their own contraception just like they can buy their own contact lenses or glasses, if they don’t have vision insurance, because their employer chose not to offer it to them.

    Simple. End of story.

  • Pingback: Was Jesus Just Some Good Dude Who Used to Live? | Kathryn Lopez

  • Pingback: gerejakristenindonesia: jesus – Google News: Was Jesus Just Some … | Social Media Somerset