Jimmy Akin, Fount of Amazing Arcana, writes me…

Jimmy Akin, Fount of Amazing Arcana, writes me… October 17, 2017

regarding the series I am doing on Jesus and the Canaanite Woman for the Catholic Weekly, specifically the second piece in the series concerning the question of whether Jesus could learn things.  Sez he:

Howdy, Mark! Saw your piece on Jesus learning, and your commenter is mistaken in some of his claims regarding dogs.

First, not all dogs were wild. While many Muslims reject dogs as pets, ancient Jews could and did keep them as pets (cf. Ps. 68:23)/guard animals for house/herd (cf. Job 30:1, Is. 56:10).

The fact the dogs in the dialogue get to eat crumbs from the children’s table shows they were pets. Wild dogs would not have been allowed into the house!

Second, the dogs licking Lazarus’s sores is not an indicating they were preparing to eat him.

Dogs instinctively lick wounds–whether humans or their own. It is a behavior that relieves the pain of the wound (like rubbing your head) and cleans it out.

Although their saliva can carry germs (so there are risks here), it also carries protective substances. See links.

Dogs are bred to integrate with humans and to care about their needs. By licking Lazarus’s sores, the dogs in the parable are treating him as a member of their social group and trying to address his wounds the way they would address their own.

From a human point of view, this indicates Lazarus’s pitiable state, but it’s a natural dog behavior based on the sympathy they have for wounded humans.

Info on dogs licking wounds:

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/canine-corner/201106/can-dogs-help-humans-heal

https://www.labradortraininghq.com/infobites/why-do-dogs-lick-wounds/

I stand corrected!  And thanks for the super-interesting arcana about dogs especially!

""I think it is important to point out that a man acts nobly toward all ..."

Some Bad News
"I'll assume you intended this as a reply to my comment.I didn't mean to imply ..."

A reader has a question about ..."
"It wasn't necessary and isn't. After he was announced a heretic by 100 bishops in ..."

A reader has a question about ..."
""Heresy" is the theological opinion of the losing side. If it could be demonstrated to ..."

A reader has a question about ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment