Reading Modern Pagan History

When I’m not at my desk writing rituals and posts for Raise the Horns I sometimes venture out into the broader Pagan world where I often lecture and ramble about various esoteric subjects. One of those topics is often history, specifically the histories of Modern Paganism and the Western Magical Tradition. Some of my more ambitious presentations include L. Ron Hubbard and Joseph Smith, but usually I’m happy enough to simply chat about Gerald Gardner, Dion Fortune, and Margaret Murray. When I’m done with those talks I’m often asked about where to go for further information on the topic. This is my extended answer to that question.

Periodically I’ll have someone come up to me questioning my interpretation or understanding of a particular thing, and depending on the question/criticism that can be either positive or negative. It can be a positive when I learn something I wasn’t aware of before, or someone provides a twist on a theory or whatever. I don’t have all the answers, and I love talking about this stuff, so such interactions are all for the good. Things can take a pretty negative turn when people like to act as if they have some sort of “secret knowledge” that is in disagreement with what I’m saying. If the knowledge is secret, and you aren’t going to share it with me, how can you expect me to know it? And if you don’t feel like sharing it (and providing sources) then you should just keep your mouth shut because you aren’t really contributing to the conversation. I have a unicorn in my backyard too, but you aren’t allowed to see it and I can’t show you photographs either.

This all makes writing (and speaking) about Modern Paganism kind of difficult. A historian or a researcher can only write about what they have seen. If there are documents linking Gardner to an earlier Witch group a historian has to see them before they can say he was initiated into a coven back in 1939. That’s why historians like Ronald Hutton have to be conservative with what they write, whatever they say has to be backed up (that doesn’t mean I always agree with Hutton, but we’ll get into that later). The more conservative approach to Modern Pagan History (and yes, much of that history has revolved almost exclusively around Modern Witchcraft, just remember we are only seventy years in, that will change) is probably less fun than the alternative, but it’s how The Academy works. Mainstream scholars don’t argue that Jesus came back from the dead either.

Ronald Hutton is really where any discussion of what to read when it comes to the origins of Modern Paganism has to begin. Almost fifteen years after its initial publication (1999), Triumph of the Moon remains an important and vital text. It was the first scholarly attempt printed by an academic press to document the origins and influences in Modern Paganism, and in that regard the book succeeds brilliantly. There was an entire menagerie of factors and moments that helped to get us to where we are today and Hutton goes through every one, slowly and methodically building his case. From Swiss Judges to folklorists to Victorian Poets it all comes together in the 1940′s and 50′s, and every time I pick up Triumph I find something new to explore and ponder. Even if you find yourself disagreeing with Hutton you’ll still find something interesting in Triumph.

I was on an email list (in what feels like a lifetime ago) where we discussed Triumph of the Moon chapter by chapter. That list contained a lot of initiated Traditional Witches who disagreed with much of what Hutton was saying, especially when we got to the second part of the book dealing with the first public Witches (people like Gerald Gardner and Doreen Valiente). To this day I find Hutton’s characterization of Gardner sympathetic, even though Hutton didn’t exactly write what I wanted to read. Of course I wanted Hutton to say that evidence exists for Gardner’s initiation in 1939, but he didn’t, and that’s OK because scholars are limited as to what they can write. Hutton never calls Gardner a phony or a fraud, he simply writes about the evidence that’s available to him.

If there’s a problem with Triumph it’s that Hutton probably didn’t do enough digging around Gerald Gardner’s base of operations in the 1930′s and 40′s, New Forest England. Fortunately for us author Philip Heselton did dig around New Forest and what he found is borderline amazing. In Wiccan Roots: Gerald Gardner and the Modern Witchcraft Revival (2000) Heselton makes a pretty solid case for Gardner being initiated back in 1939. The New Forest area certainly had enough magickally talented (and eccentric) individuals around to make the prospect of a Witch coven there in the 1930′s completely plausible.

Sadly though, most of what Heselton has to offer in Wiccan Roots is speculation. There’s no smoking gun out there providing the evidence to determine exactly what happened in New Forest England back in the late 1930′s, but the case Heselton does build up is pretty convincing. I think he probably makes a couple of big leaps too many, but that’s part of the fun. In addition to Wiccan Roots, Heselton’s follow-up Gerald Gardner and the Cauldron of Inspiration (2003) is also essential reading. In fact the first third of Cauldron is just as importnat as anything in Roots.

Heselton’s exploration into the life of Gerald Gardner was too big to be limited to simply two books. In 2012 he released his Gardner-biography-duology Witchfather: A Life of Gerald Gardner, Volume 1-Into the Witch Cult and Volume 2-From Witchcult to Wicca. Sadly, I have not yet read either book as they were only available as e-books for several months and I desperately wanted both of them in print. (I’m weird about my Pagan library.)

While I’m not sure the definitive history of American Paganism has been written yet, Her Hidden Children: The Rise of Wicca and Paganism in America (2006) by Chas Clifton comes pretty damn close. While I wasn’t as initially impressed with Children as I was with Hutton’s Triumph, it’s grown on me over over the years and has turned into essential reference material. At first I was bothered by amount the amount of “book histories” contained within it, but books are essentially how American Paganism grew, to not write about them would be to skip a large chunk of our history. Like Hutton and Heselton the focus is on Witchcraft (though less exclusively so), but that’s probably to be expected at this point. Like I said earlier, that wil change, just give it some time.

One of the earliest attempts to put Modern Witchcraft into a scholarly context was Aidan Kelly’s Crafting the Art of Magic (1991). There are a lot of people who dislike Crafting, but Kelly deserves at least a little (and possibly more) credit for the attempt. No Pagan history library is complete without a copy of Kelly’s book. While it’s been out of print for almost two decades now it’s still easily picked up online.

Still important after all these year’s is Margot Adler’s (1979) Drawing Down the Moon, the first comprehensive look into American Paganism. Adler, who works for National Public Radio, approaches DDtM as an interested journalist which allows her to be thorough with her history while also being extremely sympathetic towards the people she’s writing about. There are parts of DDtM that feel a bit dated in 2013 (some of the Paganisms she writes about don’t really exist today) but as a history book it’s impossible to put down. There are passages in DDtM that foreshadow the work of Hutton and Clifton and much of what Adler writes about is only present in her work. You can’t be a Modern Pagan History buff and not have read Drawing Down the Moon.

One of the most interesting things about being a part of a modern religious movement is that many who created our history have written about it. The most obvious pioneer to have recounted her experiences is Doreen Valiente in her book The Rebirth of Witchcraft. While Valiente writes a little about Witchcraft predecessors, it’s her first hand accounts of working with both Gerald Gardner and Robert Cochrane that have always been the most interesting to me (especially the Cochrane chapter). It’s also interesting to note the changes in Valiente as she recounts her various experiences. This is an important first hand account from one of the most influential Witches in history.

Important first hand accounts from Witchcraft’s early days aren’t limited to Valiente either. Lots of first and second generation Pagans have written important memoirs. Patrica Crowther’s High Priestess is interesting because of the player’s involved and her take on Alex Sanders. In a similar vein I also whole-heartedly recommend Frederic Lamond’s Fifty Years of Wicca (2005) written by one of Gardner’s early initiates. Americans have also been busy writing about what happened on this side of the pond. On my “to read pile” is Merry Meet Again: Lessons, Life & Love on the Path of a Wiccan High Priestess by Deborah Lipp (2013) which has gotten a lot of solid reviews thus far. The one I’m really waiting for is Oberon Zell-Ravenheart’s autobiography which is currently in the “editing” stage.

My favorite first hand account of Pagan History since Valiente is Michael Howard’s Modern Wicca: A History From Gerald Gardner to the Present (2010). I don’t necessarily agree with everything in it (or Howard’s motivations in certain instances) but it’s all fascinating to read. What gives Howard’s story a large degree of substance is that he’s the longtime editor and publisher of Britain’s The Cauldron magazine. He was in the catbird’s chair during a lot of significant moments in Pagan history.

A complete 180° turn from most of the books here is Wicca Magickal Beginnings – A Study of the Possible Origins of the Rituals and Practices Found in This Modern Tradition of Pagan Witchcraft and Magick by Sorita D’este and David Rankine (it also wins an award for longest title). Magickal Beginnings is an investigation into the origins of the language used in early Wiccan ritual. Answering questions about which bits came from Crowley and which bits came from Kipling. There’s also some fantastic speculation and history about several magickal tools. This is a really great (and often overlooked) book that deserves a bigger audience.

When it comes to Modern Pagan History book essentials there are several titles that I’m not necessarily a huge fan that I still think people should read. Ben Whitmore’s Trails of the Moon (2010) was written as a critique of a Hutton and while I don’t agree with some of the assertions, is still contains some intriguing history. Just because I’m mostly in the Hutton-camp doesn’t mean that I don’t think people should read differing opinions. In a similar vein is The Pickingill Papers: The Origin of the Gardnerian Craft by E.W. Liddel (1994) which attempts to link both Gerald Gardner and Aleister Crowley to English cunning-man George Picnkingill. I personally don’t put much stock in what’s written in The Papers, but alternative theories on the development of Modern Paganism and Witchcraft should at least be looked at.

In the next few years I expect even more histories and memoirs that will shed light on Modern Paganism. While there is never as much material available as I might like, Pagan history was barely a genre even twenty years ago. We’ve come a long way and I love reading the chronicles of that journey.

About Jason Mankey

Jason Mankey has been involved with Paganism for the last twenty years, and has spent the last ten of those years as a speaker, writer, and High Priest. Jason can often be found lecturing on the Pagan Festival circuit, so you might just bump into him. When not reading and researching Pagan history he likes to crank up the Led Zeppelin, do rituals in honor of Jim Morrison (of The Doors), and sing numerous praises to Pan, Dionysus, and Aphrodite. He lives in Sunnyvale CA with his wife Ari and two hyper-kinetic cats.

  • Lēoht Sceadusawol

    I am keen to see books on modern Pagan/Heathen history that isn’t Wicca dominated, simply because Wicca is only one facet of a much larger story.

    • JasonMankey

      So am I. There are probably some journal articles floating around about it.

      • Lēoht Sceadusawol

        I have to say, when I first got into Paganism, it was via Druidry. A lot of Druids claim lineage going all the way back to Iolo Morganwg, but plenty acknowledge Ross Nichols as a major influence.

        Nichols, in many ways, did for Druidry what Gardner did for Witchcraft.

        Indeed, Wicca and Druidry are what I would describe as the two major denominations of Paganism. Most eclectic Pagans will have influences from one or both paths.

  • Christine Hoff Kraemer

    > it’s her first hand accounts of working with both Gerald Gardner and Robert Cochrane that have always been the most interesting to me (especially the Cochrane chapter).

    Agreed! I thought that book was especially interesting to read next to Fifty Years of Wicca.

  • Jayelle

    I knew nothing about most of these books, so thank you. My pile’s getting bigger!

  • dashifen

    Well … there goes my paycheck. Thanks a lot, Jason, which I mean both sincerely and with snark ;)

    • JasonMankey

      Sadly the Heselton books (with the exception of the Gardner biographies) have not been picked up by an American Press. Checking on Amazon, “Wiccan Roots” (used) is going for 42 dollars . . . horrible (though yay me if I ever go broke). When it was first released I ordered mine from Amazon UK, so yeah you really will be losing your paycheck. The rest should be easy (and mostly inexpensive) enough to track down.

  • Cara Elizabeth Hoglund

    If you’re interested in the history of Asatru (Heathenism/anything Viking Age reconstructionist), a good place to start is Jeffery Kaplan’s book “Radical Religion in America: Millenarian Movements from the Far Right to the Children of Noah”. To be fair, the section on Asatru primarily focuses on Steve McNallen and the AFA branch, and only covers the time period up until the book was published in 1997. Still, I think that anything by Kaplan about Asatru is going to be the closest thing academia has to a well-researched, relatively unbiased analysis of the topic. Asatru has a whole different set of issues woven into its history than Wicca does, primarily dealing with the Neo-Nazism/white supremacy hence being included in Kaplan’s Radical Religions book), but every religion’s going to have its aggressively radical fundamentalists, I guess.

    I’ve also got a few papers that I wrote in grad school while getting my MA in Folk Studies (and often being both the ethnographer and the “native” being studied–long story) which summarizes the history and practices of Asatru. I’ll send them along to Jason to see what he can make of them :)

  • Christine Hoff Kraemer

    > Things can take a pretty negative turn when people like to act as if they have some sort of “secret knowledge” that is in disagreement with what I’m saying. If the knowledge is secret, and you aren’t going to share it with me, how can you expect me to know it? And if you don’t feel like sharing it (and providing sources) then you should just keep your mouth shut because you aren’t really contributing to the conversation.

    Yes, such bad manners — and the way I was trained, also a violation of the spirit of oaths. If knowledge is oathbound, it’s inappropriate even to allude to having it, because that partially reveals the knowledge. Silence is supposed to be a spiritual practice to deepen intimacy and understanding, not a mechanism for pretending superiority.

  • Jeanne Anne Decosta

    there are lotsuv witches & other pagans in 2nd Life Jason .. Cathbodva & Merlyn Herne are high priestess & high priest of the Artemis Tavern coven .. which is affiliated w/ the ppl who put on the big witchfest in the UK .. the AT bunch does a weekly book discussion & the previous book discussed was Lamonds 50 yrs of Wicca .. Merlyn actually knows Lamond in rl so i suggested that he invite him to sl .. Merlyn says that Lamond lives in Austria these days so he doesnt see him in rl anymore but they are in touch online so he says he will invite him !! hope he does .. would be way fun to have him participate in the AT circles :)

  • Scott Simpson

    For modern Pagan movements on the European continent, I can recommend our new book: Modern Pagan and Native Faith Movements in Central and Eastern Europe, published by Acumen.

    • JasonMankey

      I’ve added it to my book list, but that sticker price! $99.95! Ouch. Can you slide me a review copy?

  • Macha NightMare

    For a view of one fairly widespread Pagan tradition, see The Baby and the Bathwater, by Anne Hill.

    Fond as I am of Ron Hutton and much as I appreciate his work, his chapter in TotM called “Uncle Sam and the Goddess” is terrible. It contains factual errors, for one thing. I had no chance to chat with him about this when he was at the Cherry Hill Seminary symposium in SC this past Spring, but someday when I do, he and I will talk about it. ;-)