Ancient Christian Villages of Galilee

There is an interesting book by Bellarmino Bagatti, Ancient Christian Villages of Galilee (a translation from the Italian original), which I had the chance to consult recently. Much of it focuses on Christian presence in later times, but in a few instances it is able to trace evidence back to a very early period.

Bagatti focuses particular attention on small communities with two synagogues, which suggests to him that there were groups that eventually refused to worship together. Sometimes this evidence from archaeology correlates with later evidence for the presence of Jewish Christians in that town.

I was particularly interested in the suggestion that a particular tomb in Sakhnin might be that of “min Jacob,” a Jewish Christian mentioned in Rabbinic sources. The tomb later became identified with a rabbi of a different name (Joshua), but there is a tradition associating it with that famous Jewish-Christian “heretic” Jacob of Sakhnin. It remains a sacred site shared by Jews, Christians, and Muslims. I visited the tomb on my first trip to Israel.


"How so? Clearly, the possibility of verification does little to stem the tide of false ..."

Resurrection, Rumors, and Romania
"Apologists often insist that, because "oral reporting can at times be verified", the earlier the ..."

Resurrection, Rumors, and Romania
"We don't have to admit anything of the sort. We don't know what they claimed. ..."

Rumors of First-Century Mark and the ..."
"Paul wanted everyone to be successful at spreading his particular version of the "good news ..."

Rumors of First-Century Mark and the ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • eldadkeynan

    Hey Jemas; I have a copy too. Unfrotunately, scholars disqualifiy Bagatti as “nonsense”, “not serious” etc. As always, Bagatti’s work should be on the table for criticizing and discussion. However – complete disqualification must be rejected.
    One way or another: following his “maps” I have reached many of the tombs I publish. In fact – in some of the places I’ve found more than he reported.
    All in all – a great book with lots of info. Considering the means Bagatti had back then – his work was really great