Of the Burning of Books There is no End

Tim O’Neill, on his blog History for Atheists, has tackled another widely-held misrepresentation, namely that Christians in ancient times typically conspired to destroy and suppress secular and/or “pagan” literature. Here is an excerpt:

What people like Nixey neglect to mention is the fact while some prominent clergy argued that the Bible and the works of the Church fathers were sufficient for a Christian’s education, other argued that all knowledge came ultimately from God and so “pagan” learning was a gift to be used. And the key point here is that these were the Christian authorities who won the debate over the use of non-Christian learning. It was not hardliners like Tertullian, Tatian or John Chrysostom who ended up setting the intellectual agenda for Christianity for the next 1000 years, it was the more liberal and open Justin Martyr, Origen, Clement of Alexandria, Basil of Alexandria and Gregory of Nazianzus. John of Damascus encouraged his readers to study “the best contributions of the philosophers of the Greeks” arguing that “whatever there is of good has been given to men from above by God, since ‘every best gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights’”(Philosophical Chapters, 1958,5). Similarly, Clement argued that philosophy was worth study because “[t]he way of truth is therefore one. But into it, as into a perennial river, streams flow from all sides.”(Stromata, I.5). Modern polemicists may sneer that these Patristic writers still saw philosophy as ancillary to or “the handmaiden” of theology, but that is essentially just condemning ancient people for not holding modern priorities. The fact remains that these were the authorities whose view prevailed, not the hardliners who the polemicists always highlight.

Click through to read the rest of the post, which includes a calculation of the relationship between how many pagan, Jewish, and Christian works we are aware of from the ancient world, and how many are lost to us.

When atheists misrepresent ancient Christians as typically having been intellectual terrorists who burned great works of literature and philosophy, are they not themselves doing the equivalent themselves, burning the actual history in the minds of those gullible enough to blindly accept their claims, in order to replace our accurate knowledge of the past with their own dishonest dogma and that alone?

Of related interest, see Sarah Bond’s article on what happened to pagan temples.

bradbury--fahrenheit--read-books

"You might be right, Puppy. We'll find out for sure in time. I think what ..."

Donald Trump as Antichrist
"For atheists to try to use mythicism as though it were an argument against Christianity ..."

Earl Doherty as Christian Reformer
"Ok , Trump or Bannon which one would you say?"

Donald Trump as Antichrist
"Trump is the Antichrist, only the Antichrist makes and breaks the 7 Year peace covenant ..."

Donald Trump as Antichrist

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Myles

    Archbishop Théophilus initiated a Papal Edict in 391 C.E. and destroyed the library at Alexandra, followed by Hypatia in 415 C.E. Their reasoning was that if the books agreed with the bible,they were not necessary, so no need to preserve them. No agreement or possible disagreement should be destroyed because they were insults to god. Jesuits and other black robes continued that policy to this day. Mayan,Aztec and Inca libraries and knowledge were destroyed for the same reasons. Still trying to find and/or read books blacklisted by the Catholic Church in 2017 is difficult.

    • http://historyforatheists.blogspot.com Tim O’Neill

      “Archbishop Théophilus initiated a Papal Edict in 391 C.E. and destroyed the library at Alexandra,”

      Please cite the source or sources that describe the destruction of this library.

      “followed by Hypatia in 415 C.E Their reasoning was that if the books agreed with the bible,they were not necessary, so no need to preserve them.”

      Please quote the sources of the time that put the blame for the murder of Hypatia on Christian opposition to learning.

      “Still trying to find and/or read books blacklisted by the Catholic Church in 2017 is difficult.”

      Please provide us with an example of a book “blacklisted by the the Catholic Church in 2017” and the difficulties you are having finding or reading them. Have you tried Amazon.com?

  • robrecht

    Nice quote by Ray Bradbury, who wrote Fahrenheit 451, in which books were outlawed and burned by firemen in a not-too-distant future American society. Obviously, we need not read Fahrenheit 451 literally, especially in light of this quote. I read it as a figurative prophetic work. It should be included in the canon, along with Jesus Christ Superstar.