Our second post in our roundtable discussion on Stephen Prothero’s book God Is Not One comes from Pagan blogger P. Sufenas Virius Lupus:
The basic premise of this book is one that got my attention, and seems extremely useful and appealing. The first chapter is quite good, and discusses this framing of the question of “world religions” in a fair amount of depth, from the historical perspective of people since the late 19th century and the first World Parliament of Religions, and the frequent statements of “perennial philosophers” since then, many of whom are involved in either interfaith dialogue or in world religions scholarship. Huston Smith, for example, is one of these, and not unlike many other such people (Joseph Campbell included), they resort to statements often from the Upanishads and the like to the effect that “The truth is one; the sages speak of it by many names.” The deficiencies of this viewpoint have been rehearsed quite a bit in my circle of associates, because it ultimately says “Your religion is valid insofar as it says exactly what mine does,” which is profoundly disrespectful. It assumes that the “goal” of all religion is to “climb the mountain,” and that the various religions are different paths up that mountain; and it often goes to the idea that one should have one’s eyes on the goal rather than the path (which will get you eaten by a grue, I think!).
For those of you who are scoffing at this type of perennialist thinking, and who are hard polytheists and the like, I’d invite you to take a step further and start looking at your own vocabulary: how often do you speak in terms of “the divine” or “deity”? While that’s not as egregious as saying “We’re all one,” nonetheless, it buys into what is ultimately a monistic understanding of divinities and divine realms and realities. To be valid, individual religions need not be aiming toward the same thing or talking about the same thing…and that’s really the point of the first chapter of the book, and indeed much of the rest of it. From the viewpoint of phenomenology of religion, that is utterly unnecessary; and yet, it is assumed that at least the mystics from all religious traditions worthy of the name “mystic” do fundamentally understand each other because of this underlying unity of divinity. While I think that is an observation that is true fairly consistently across religions–i.e. mystics often don’t have difficulty understanding one another–that brings up a variety of other questions before it even suggests to me that the underlying divinities involved, or the goals of individual traditions’ practices, are “one,” or are even necessarily similar.
Prothero then goes on to suggest that each of the various religions he covers has an underlying problem and a suggested solution to it. The way he lays this out is quite clearly based on the Four Noble Truths of Buddhism, in my opinion, which is a structural bias that I don’t think he properly acknowledges; and while his answers for the various religions do make a large degree of sense, I wonder if that particular viewpoint doesn’t have a great deal to do with it. (If one uses a theological framework from a non-theistic religion to argue for the underlying realities of many different religions in a religious studies framework…is that not a theological choice in itself? Hmm…) He then has eight substantive chapters, which go in the following order: Islam, Christianity, Confucianism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Yoruba Religions, Judaism, Daoism, with a final chapter on Modern Atheism, and then a short conclusion.
Why did he choose those religions and that order? He is attempting to talk about the eight most powerful religions. Why eight? I wonder if the Noble Eightfold Path suggested the number, given the implied Buddhist framework otherwise (he does not admit to come from any sectarian viewpoint, other than having been raised in Christianity, but he gave it up earlier in life). He admits in the introduction that he is sorry not to have included a chapter on Sikhism. He mentions Shinto in the intro as well, but does not have a chapter on it. I don’t recall him having mentioned neo- or any other type of paganism either; he does mention Wicca in the short litany of religions he has not included–which, in addition to the above-mentioned religions, also names the Bah’ai faith, Zoroastrianism, Jainism, Scientology, and Rastafarai. He puts Islam first because it has had the most profound effect on public life since September 11, 2001; he then follows with Christianity because, with about 2.4 billion followers worldwide, it is the largest world religion. He puts Confucianism third because as an individual whose teachings have been profoundly influential on the largest group of world population (China and much of East and Southeast Asia) for two thousand years, it’s very important–despite whatever debates still exist in some peoples’ minds as to whether or not it is a religion or not. And so on down the line. He includes Judaism, despite its very small numbers (14 million worldwide) due to its having given “birth” to the two top world religions.
I am happy about his inclusion of the Yoruba religions as a related and important, large, influential group, and he does make a very good explanation of how inadequate it is to include all “primal,” “primitive” or “aboriginal” religions in a group with shamanism and such in an introductory chapter in a world religions textbook, which would often include African and Afro-Diasporic religions amongst its grouping.
While I’m not a complete expert in every religion outlined, I was able to follow most of it and be familiar with many of his references. I was annoyed that there are two bits of it that he is completely wrong about, and both of them are in the Christianity chapter (though one of them is repeated in the Judaism chapter): first, that St. Augustine wrote the world’s first autobiography; and second, that there is mention of male homosexuality in the Bible, but not lesbianism. The first is incorrect because–though it has not survived–the Emperor Hadrian wrote an autobiography in the second century C.E., which is over two centuries before Augustine, and I’m fairly certain he was not the only individual in the Western world to have done so before the late fourth/early fifth century. Second, it is problematic to talk about anything in the Hebrew or Christian Bibles as “homosexuality”; but, independent of that, the Hebrew Bible has the various mentions in Leviticus and Deuteronomy that are taken as condemnations of homoerotic acts amongst males, but the only definite mention of this in the Christian Bible occurs in Romans 1, where both male and female acts are mentioned. (So, whatever one may think about the story of David and Jonathan, or of Ruth and Naomi, at very least, Paul mentions lesbianism as a bad thing!) While I can understand the wish to not draw attention to these passages for those who may be reading this book for other reasons (i.e. “Let’s not give homophobes something to build alliances with other religions upon!”), it’s inaccurate and should not have been allowed to get through the editors.
The final chapter on atheism is a very good summary of the “New Atheists” who are just as dogmatic and have as much proselytizing fervor as any Christian missionary. It makes a distinction, though, between these new atheists (a.k.a. “angry atheists”) and “friendly atheists,” which is a fair enough point.
Does his book succeed? Yes and no. It does demonstrate that each of the different religions has a different basic viewpoint on the world, and therefore a different idea on how to go about interacting with the world with that underlying concern in mind. To put it in slightly different terms (from Richard Grigg’s Theology as a Way of Thinking), each “what” has a “how” to go with it that is appropriate to it. But, along the way, a full historical view is not always given, and Prothero is often more concerned to give his spin on some clever phrase or metaphor than he is on giving useful information. For this same reason, it’s an entertaining and quick read, but it does suffer a bit in terms of thoroughness as a result. It may not be a good primer on world religions as much as a good way to outline an approach for looking at each religion in a way that respects its particularities.
Will it be useful for pagans and polytheists? Substantially, no. Methodologically, possibly. Not a bad book, by any means, but certainly not quite what one would hope with a title like that. I’d say the introductory and concluding chapters, though, are useful and would have wider applicability than to just what Prothero writes about here, including for modern pagans.
My Question for Stephen Prothero: If you were to write God Is Still Not One, and included eight more religions that were not covered in the first book, what would they be, what order would you put them in, and how would you characterize them (e.g. Buddhism as “the Way of Awakening,” etc.)?
Read Stephen’s answer to this — and other bloggers’ questions — here.
Return to the Patheos Book Club for more resources for deeper reading.
{Take & Read} is the blog of the 
I use the Divine as a plural word, encompassing all forms of theism.
Confronting an economy in peril, President Barack Obama unveiled a $450 billion plan Thursday night to boost jobs and put cash in the pockets of dispirited Americans, challenging Republican skeptics to embrace an approach heavy on the tax cuts they traditionally love. With millions of voters watching and ever skeptical of Washington, Obama told Congress, “Let’s meet the moment.”
Whether it is fake rolex or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking cheap rolex watches.
Thanks for your post. One other thing is when you are marketing your affiliate offer alone, one of the issues you need to be mindful of upfront is just how to plan affiliate marketing.
1791702 beers on the wall. sck was here
very good post. i like that very much. thanks so much for sharing. hope u can post much more good articles for us to learn together. thanks for your time.
140673 beers on the wall. sck was here
I’ve read a few good stuff here
Holly, I love this and when I first saw it, I knew I had to make something like it for our church library window display for July 4th. Thanks so much for posting it, for the link to the template and the explanation of how you put it together. Happy 4th of July!
As a website owner I believe the material here is reallygreat. I thank you for your hard work. You should keep it up forever! Good Luck.
My brother recommended I might like this web site. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!
This particular blog is without a doubt entertaining additionally factual. I have discovered a lot of interesting things out of it. I’d love to come back again soon. Thanks a lot!
This unique blog is definitely entertaining and informative. I have chosen a lot of helpful stuff out of this amazing blog. I’d love to come back again and again. Cheers!
You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something that I think I would never understand. It seems too complex and extremely broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!
Excelent info my friend!!, keep it comming!
Wanted terrific blog post on your blog, it truly provides me with an insight for this subject.
not because you want to do too much exaggerated to cover up defects the so-called overkill,uggs for men what should be just right, but not too far.
To become truthful, the release of genuine merino cheap uggs from Australian actually triggered a revolution inside the style footwear globe.
This particular blog is really awesome additionally diverting. I have chosen helluva handy tips out of this source. I’d love to return again soon. Thanks!
Sometimes I just think that people write and dont really have much to say. Not so here. You definitely have something to say and you say it with style, my man! You sure do have an interesting way of drawing people in, what with your videos and your words. Youve got quite a one-two punch for a blog!
Pleased I happened along that posting. I could in all honesty tell you that I learned something original today. Maybe I will have the same good fortune next time I have a look at your blog.
This particular blog is really cool and besides amusing. I have discovered a bunch of interesting things out of this amazing blog. I’d love to visit it again and again. Thanks!
I have recently started a blog, the information you provide on this site has helped me tremendously. Thanks for all of your time & work.
Good write-up, I am normal visitor of one’s blog, maintain up the nice operate, and It’s going to be a regular visitor for a lengthy time.
Amaze! Thank you! I constantly wished to produce in my internet site a thing like that. Can I take element of the publish to my blog?
Hey there would you mind stating which blog platform you’re using? I’m planning to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a difficult time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique. P.S Apologies for getting off-topic but I had to ask!
Is there any other branded footwear category that is much more practical than ugg bailey button boots?
It’s really a great and helpful piece of info
Hello, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, wonderful blog!
oh man i love this song memory lane!!!!
2007 oh yeah!
You made some remarkable points there. I checked on the internet for the issue and found some similar blogs that would be a wonderful read for anyone interested? I’ll sort the links out and post them later for you.
I have never seen such impressive ideas presented in writing. Your writer has a very unique way of presenting information in such a way as to catch the reader’s attention.
,chaussures louboutinWhen you work from home and you do article writing as part of it, like driving traffic to your site or simple blogging whatsoever,armani jeans, you always encounter that certain challenge to come up with not only good titles for your write-ups but also titles that will seize almost everyone’s attention. A catchy headline is almost critical and important as the body. Titles are the first thing people read and if those titles are interesting enough, readers will more likely check the whole article out. But if it’s boring or too general and doesn’t have an appeal at first glance,air jordan, then your potential customers will probably just ignore it.The following are two great concepts on what kind of titles you should think of before or even after writing an article for your work from home. First is making use of the word,abercrombie & fitch milano, “why” in your headlines. Most people search the Internet for some answers and they are really keen to topics and writings that may hold the solution to what they’re looking for. That’s why certain articles which have titles like, “..Reasons Why..,louboutin pas cher,” or “Why Is It Most People…,jordan femme,” or “Do You Know Why…” are very much bankable in terms of views and reads.Not only that,louboutin, another nice work from home technique would be using the word, “warning” in your article titles. It’s somehow difficult to come up with that one especially if there’s really no life-and-death situation involved but a little slice of creativity won’t hurt,ray ban, would it? For example,jordan pas cher, you can try “WARNING,armani homme! How To Avoid Being Banned From The Forums,abercrombie milano,” or “Scams Warning!” as titles for some article writing.Being aware of these useful tips and tricks on how to make your article titles a sure head-turner is a major asset for your work from home to deliver good results. We all know that in every step of the way, we come closer to our goals. Same is true with these little information which will lift us a notch higher to a productive article writing and article marketing.Related articles： 微博推荐 | 今日微博热点 将事先包好的纸包放回原处 记者接到玉山县下镇镇一名村民报料后 CF美女玩家香香揭秘职业游戏玩家生存境遇
Liu Hui, working in pictures from the Said the girls in the East,isabel marant sneakers, a senior internship in Nanjing, a real estate microblogging. Reporters learned that this is a real estate subsidiary of Nanjing Sea,isabel marant shoes, after the real estate has 400 million man yuan commission. □ Express reporter horse Lele broke the news 90 girls selling properties,isabel marant sneaker, 50 million the recent property market ushered in a rebound, Nanjing real estate Jones giving birth to noon yesterday, a Jinling property market trail users microblogging said Big East school beauty, 90, a senior at Reading, in a central enterprises high-end real estate practice, seven days sold over 50 million yuan house. microblogging with two pictures,isabel marant chaussures, a girl in daily life and work according behind microblogging users have this kind of performance surprised many people inquire about this girl, where is a real estate work. Users post soon also posted the picture, said to have been a recruiter interested in this big girls. Friends said that the real estate is in the sea Phoenix Hee shore. confirmation contracted internship yesterday afternoon, the reporter contact Nanjing, China Overseas Property stakeholders last year, the other substantiated. The source said that a girl named Liu Hui, indeed greatly and four students in the East. in the sea to go to work. the strength. the sea Phoenix Hee shore for sale listings in the average price of 26,000 yuan / square meter, equivalent to 50 million yuan of sales to sell a house to 10. This real estate recently opened to sell a hundred of. sold 50 million yuan house, how much commission they will get? As Phoenix Hee shore pricing is more expensive to 0.8%. The calculation is 40,isabel marant boots,000 yuan (Editor’s note: Modern Express sic). In the sea did not disclose specific figures, saying only that the calculation of basic fly. hype? In the sea: dry Not long ago, the same in the micro-Bo, a man named The friends first posted the photo of the Phoenix Hee shore a male salesperson, said the salesman last year, selling 400 million yuan, Nanjing property market sales champion. just a few days later,isabel marant boots, Meng and again made the microblogging broke the news, the Phoenix Hee shore there is a saleswoman equally amazing, last year, selling 380 million yuan. The friends also said that Jiangsu, a well-known male host intention to purchase the Phoenix Hee shore property. microblogging triggered netizens Some industry insiders also said that speculation of this repeated wearisome. post such a thing is not dry. He said not to judge the rights and wrongs of the post also Dankan last night, a called do not deserve it. 50 million of sales on the one hand with the pricing of the company’s products, on the one hand and their own efforts. My performance and not the best, but as a couple, but also the results of their own efforts. I hope my achievements will give graduating students and to society in the workplace of people power and confidence. share: welcome to comment I want to microblogging recommended | today’s micro-Bo hot
Twins Patricia and Joanne (data plan ) ,isabel marant sneakers BEIJING ,isabel marant chaussures, March 23 – According to Taiwan Police analysis,isabel marant boots, their lives cut off from outsiders , may be death, but also need to investigate the exact cause of death . twin named Patricia and Joanne ,isabel marant boots, their lives are of each other and never married . Patricia and Joanne showbiz in the 1950s to perform, and later moved to the Great Lakes region , California ,isabel marant sneaker, reclusive life . recently been discovered that Patricia and Joanne died at home , the scene there was no blood , no signs of fighting , but also unlike suicide . the Police said Patricia and Joanne , do not need others to help support each other , because they too rely on each other after the death of one person ,isabel marant shoes, another person may soon also died . share : welcome to comment I want to comment the microblogging Recommend | hot microblogging today ( edit : SN026 )
Popcorn eating small yang to popcorn, listening to music, keyboard, is really cool home,Juicy Couture Outlet! This hot weather, out of hate to have roasted, or blowing fan cool! Have become nocturnal people, the sun does not set is not out of the dorm the door,Chanel Bags, in addition to the class, it is not only armed out. In summer, and the everyday eating watermelon day, but also to create their own weight, M to Jiujiang than say I was fat, I said to eat good! She just looked down me there not for a long time to their own microwave popcorn, go home Oh buy two the bag eats, let my father work on technology, tomorrow to teach my _! ^ ^! High-heeled shoes flower skirt recent comparative woman,Karen Millen Dress, haha! Because of wearing new shoes, Teenmix, and HH wearing a flower skirt, white pink flower, today Ann saw I said, ah! Today wear pretty lady HH. HH but small Yang yesterday specially called to tell me to wear couples dress, I also don’t wear. Who knows she’s special to me sway point. Oh! Poor man ~ wear heel heel my penguin side high, hee hee! He always walked with a stoop, so significantNot me! Ha ha ha! Today feel front was black head, hey! There’s a way? Tall also love wearing high heels, compare the smug, still in Beijing! Not so many amazing eyes HH really exaggerated HH windy outside, dress is blowing a lift lift, well! Well! But don’t fly well, back to our class students directly blown to the blow-up, made us several " wow " stop. Find themselves recent comparative narcissism, last night, a whitening mask, feel suddenly turned white, ^ _ ^! Good mood recently my mood is good, the scenery is not bad, there are green green trees and the green green grass was. Every day sunny, is the sun more vicious, sun people not. First start so early sunscreen, the first time that does not hold up an umbrella to go out to his life, is the first of the sun will go out. So, in summer, and commom; cynical start HH Sunglasses back out to take sunglasses, the glare of the sun in my eyes, look pale sunshine on the ground, according to the body, as if to pierce the body, good afternoon classes start sad!Sleepy, I hate not to wear a sunglasses to go to class, the teacher knows only sleep!! work French teacher wants us to do the dialogue, every 3-5 minutes, was a real life, phonetic symbol also didn’t finish does one’s long dialogue, is a little difficult for us! Just to British and American culture homework finished, copy of don’t know what to write letters.
very interesting subject.
Columbia and New York University rank high on this year’s U.S. News & World Report lists of the country’s best graduate schools. In its annual survey of more than 1,000 graduate programs chanel bags price, the magazine scored each school on its acceptance rate, job placement, student/faculty ratio and student retention. For the second year in a row, Columbia’s law school was ranked fourth in the country and NYU placed fifth. Yale’s law school remained in first place. Among business schools, Columbia’s was ranked eighth, slipping from last year’s sixth place. NYU’s Stern School of Business dropped from 12th to 13th, in a tie with Yale. Stanford’s was rated the country’s top business school, relegating Harvard to second place. NYU was rated the best part-time business school, and Pace University was 10th. Among research medical schools, Harvard and Johns Hopkins repeated last year’s rankings of first and second place, respectively. Columbia’s College of Physicians and Surgeons was ranked seventh Gucci Belts, down from sixth place last year. Mount Sinai School of Medicine tied for 22nd cheapbeltsonline, andNYU took 26th. In education, Columbia Teachers College was ranked fourth, behind Harvard, Stanford and UCLA. NYU rose to 18th from last year’s rank of 20th. Other notable New York rankings: ? In social work, Columbia tied for third, Fordham tied for 13th and CUNY-Hunter College tied at 17th. NYU was 25th. ? In social work, Columbia tied for third, Fordham tied for 13th and CUNY-Hunter College tied at 17th. NYU was 25th.about： Former Mayor David Dinkins recovering from appende CNN ANCHOR OFF THE ‘CURVE’ DEBT-CUT BID DELAYS STATE BUDGET
In 2003 the third adventure of Tebogo Mokoena was published, Tebogo Fails unfolds with hints of the romantic, though, ironically, the details of the murder scenes in this psychology thriller are rather gory. The author’s leniency for the villain’s fate even baffled and irritated readers,christian louboutin, but Bolaji is unrepentant. But the Nigerian-born Omoseye shrugs off this question with a smile. Omoseye Bolaji and the African Detective Genre By Raphael Mokoena The second,jordan, Tebogo’s Spot of Bother (2001) is probably the most interesting produced by the author, with its double twist ending. ”At the moment I have no inspiration at all. Let me just bask in the emergence of a crop of new young writers in the Free State, like Hector Kunene, Jah Rose and Teboho Masakala!” In Tebogo and the Epithalamion a beguiling young lady disappears and Tebogo manages to track her down in the end. ”The killer goes scot-free, and it happened yet again in Tebogo and the Haka,” Bolaji said grinning. Impossible Love is essentially a love story: the Ghostly Adversary is a taut thriller; whilst People of the Townships was described as “breathless, picaresque, surprisingly funny…” by Aryan Kaganof,air jordan, the white South African movie producer and prolific author. Many essays published on the Tebogo Mystery books, including a full-length study by critic Petro Schonfeld, titled Tebogo on the Prowl (First Edition, 2006). A key to Bolaji’s creativity is perhaps the fact that he began reading mystery novels in his childhood. When asked when readers should another installment of Tebogo Mokoena’s adventures, Bolaji responds candidly: ”Or simplistically, let’s just say the inspiration for the books just come and go intermittently.” “Yes I love the book. In 2005 I was very very sick and should have died really, [but], little by little, I became better, and some inspiration came back a bit after a few years”. “The book is about the strange case of a comfortable young man being killed in his own house during a party, [but], now I feel that the book is tawdry and nowhere near good enough…but strangely enough, many people still claim they love it so much,” said Bolaji In 2000 Omoseye Bolaji, then based in Free State in South Africa (his base) published the first in the Tebogo Mystery series entitled Tebogo Investigates,sac armani, and was surprised at the book’s success. Ask Tebogo (2004) is generally dubbed the weakest of the books, but upon re-reading it recently I was surprised to see that it is actually a powerful story despite the controversial “essays” placed throughout the text. The book certainly has a fair number of twists and turns and one gets the impression that the protagonist, though in a more sober mood, continues to enjoy the ambience of the underworld (a feature in the series) Tebogo and the Haka was followed by Tebogo and the Epithalamion (2009) and Tebogo and the Pantophagist (2010). The last two adventures being unique in the genre in the sense that no one is actually killed. ”That was a wonderful occasion with its transcendental pomp and pageantry that will always be etched in my memory. But I still maintain that the satisfaction of an author mainly lies with readers enjoying their work.” Omoseye was also conferred with the Chancellor’s Medal by the University of the Free State in 2007. Bolaji has also published many other books comprising different genres, which include drama, poetry, criticism, and biography. Certainly, many readers continue to enjoy the fiction churned out by Omoseye Bolaji over the years. Apart from the seven books in the Tebogo Mystery series, he has also published three other novels: Impossible Love (2000), The Ghostly Adversary (2001) and People of the Townships (2003). And all three works share one thing in common, unexpected and sensational endings. Meanwhile in Tebogo and the Pantophagist, Tebogo meets a quirky “scientist” and the plot focuses on a certain “formula” for making humans disappear! In her “Overview” of the Tebogo Mystery series, Petro identifies the following,air jordan pas cher, inter alia: as contributing to the success of the books: friction and suspicion amongst characters; seemingly insignificant details/facts; [Bolaji's] portrayal of his characters,armani jeans, style (the narrator’s use of colloquial lingo); humor, and imagery. “I really don’t know!” he said. “I suppose it was the golden age of reading for leisure in West Africa at the time. In the late 70s and 80s,armani, I loved authors like Peter Cheyney, Agatha Christie, Ellery Queen, Dick Francis,louboutin, and Sidney Sheldon” Bolaji has garnered a lot of reverence and fame as a result of the success of the series,armani montre, after all the genre is exceedingly rare in the landscape of black African writing. Amongst the many honors he has received,christian louboutin pas cher, the one that excites him the most is when he was made a Chief in Ibadan, Nigeria—his country of birth. Bolaji will not comment on Ask Tebogo, though he admits that Tebogo and the Haka (2008) is his favorite in the series. Omoseye Bolaji, the creator of the Tebogo Mystery series, is often asked how he churns out the twists and turns in the intriguing plots in the adventures of Tebogo Mokoena, the sleuth protagonist of his books. “It seems I managed to pull off a really gripping finale, but I won’t say it’s the best book in the series, or my favorite.”Related articles： if you have a deep voice tender writing process. An invitation to bid 申请取保因为爷爷住院 CF美女玩家香香揭秘职业游戏玩家生存境遇