‘Haute Sphere’ Nativity artwork debuts at Cathedral Dec. 7 …

… somewhere in Heaven Baby Jesus is weeping.

‎"For God so loved the world that he manifested himself as a Haute Sphere."

Hat Tip: Clayton Emmer.

About Katrina Fernandez

Mackerel Snapping Papist

  • Kim Vandapool

    I just can’t appreciate this. It makes me depressed about the direction of art – even as the Church is concerned. I’m pretty sure Lady Gaga beat this guy to the punch anyway.

  • Timothy Canny

    I’m pretty sure that is a Bizarro World nativity brought to our world by Bizarro Superman.

  • Sally07

    Hideous!

  • Ink

    ….it’s kinda pretty, but not in any way I’d EVER consider religious.

  • daisy

    Somebody needs a a** whippin’ for that.

  • robertgwirth

    The worst stink I have ever encountered is that of dead Japanese beetles (we had an infestation here this summer). This is worse.

  • Adam Fasen

    I’m not an art critic, so I can’t say if it is hideous or not.
    Only one question: How am I supposed to use this to explain or convey any of the Catholic Mysteries?

    • http://www.patheos.com/blogs/thecrescat Katrina Fernandez

      Exactly, Adam! My column this Friday discusses this more in depth.

      • ds

        Yes. All religious art must be an apologetic tool or its a failure.

  • baileywalker

    Just as I have always suspected. The cathedral in Los Angeles has been assimilated into the Borg.

    I confess that I find the comments by the “Cathedral Pastor” more revolting than this piece of avant grade trash.

  • baileywalker

    Sigh…. spell check needs to be upgraded to include French! Of course I typed “avant garde trash” before my iMac decided to “correct” me. Happy Advent everyone.

  • Anonymous

    This is such a beautiful piece though. When you engage your full knowledge of the scriptures, with just a small bit of information from the artist, you have a view of the whole life of Christ.

    Iconography was used, traditionally, to tell a story to illiterate masses. In the middle ages your typical church goer was illiterate, unable to read the scriptures or engage with them. The art built an understanding of the scripture that could not otherwise be gained. Today that is not the case. Modern art is built on that premise, that the viewer is literate and able to engage in a questioning manner.

    All of this to say, though modern art is limited as a piece by itself, all you have to do is say: “This is a Nativity” and I understand the full implications of it. Modern art is not designed to tell a story, it is designed to connect us with the artist.

    And isn’t that the real goal of the scriptures?

    • Jjwalker

      No. Your mistaken. Your projecting presumptions onto an object, nothing more.

    • Dick Prudlo

      And now Thomas, the illiterate masses are getting their revenge, read the comments.

  • Peter

    Satanic.

  • JudeThom

    Thank you, Vatican II! Thank you, Cardinal Mahoney!
    Thank you, Church of the Novus Ordo!

  • JoshuaFrySpeed

    I can see a bunch of pant suit wearing Sisters of Saint Joseph swooning over this thing. Ditto for the Oatmeal Cookie Womenpriest crowd and Hans Kung, of course. “We must become more Protestant-friendly, my children, we must see the light of traditional iconography in the barest of images. Yes, yes my children.” Etc. Thank you, Vatican II.

  • poetcomic1

    The first creche of St. Francis establishes the childish and naif quality essential to the very idea. Abstraction (which in itself is the opposite of incarnation!) is sophistication and pride, the primacy of purely human ‘mind’ over God’s world. It is glorification of the ‘artist’ as Promethean uber-mensch.

    • Sszorin

      Eh..correct, except instead of “sophistication” it should be [artistic] “sophistry”. “Sophistication” implies a nobility of an effort, and I see none. ..Pupil ‘poetcomic1′, you get A-

  • Althomas41

    This looks like someone left a CD in a microwave. The Churches of days gone by had stain glass with not a word on it and one could look at it and understand what is was saying. Like the Nativity of Our Lord that St. Francis started all those years ago. This work of are is Sickening!

  • poetcomic1

    At a dinner party where Mary
    McCarthy was cooing about the “beautiful symbolism” of the
    Eucharist, O’Connor famously retorted, “Well, if it’s a symbol,
    to hell with it.”  This ‘artwork’ degrades the Incarnation to a sophisticated and ‘adult’ sophistication and symbolism. There is no manger-sepulcher, no child, no Mary, no nothin’ except a warm sentimental glow in a geometric shell that glorifies the blind and inhuman chemical process of crystal-formation.  It is literally a ‘heart of stone’.  

  • Pat

    Nanu Nanu


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X