The Virtue of Bi-Polar Extremism

There are extremists in the Church today, and there are moderates – and all of them are wreaking havoc.  They are causing such distress precisely because they are ignoring, each in a particular way, the strangeness that lies at the heart of Christianity.  It is my contention that the chief problem we face in the Church is not lack of loyalty to Rome, not insufficient concern for the poor, not ignorance of women’s concerns, not liturgical abuse, not theological imprecision, not resurgent triumphalism – though each of these is, I think, cause for worry.  No, the chief difficulty we face is a lack of imagination, the inability to hold opposites in tension, the failure to be, boldly and unapologetically, bi-polar extremists.

Father Robert Barron, from Bridging the Great Divide:  Musings of a Post-Liberal, Post Conservative Evangelical Catholic

Brett Salkeld is a doctoral student in theology at Regis College in Toronto.  He is a father of two (so far) and husband of one.

"If you don’t believe in God like me though you can have as many robit ..."

What would “pro-life” mean in a ..."
"If technology can solve these problems then we will be free, although if humans start ..."

What would “pro-life” mean in a ..."
"Was just looking back over my copy of Brave New World. Here's Controller Mustapha Mond ..."

What would “pro-life” mean in a ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Mark DeFrancisis

    Living in that tension of the Catholic “both-and” is uncomfortable, but at the heart of the faith.

  • Morning’s Minion

    great insight.

  • Gerald L. Campbell

    How does one hold these tensions in balance? The answer is simple enough: through application of the principle of the choice of the lesser of two evils?

    This principle no longer seems relevant in ethics, especially concerning sexual matter. Yet, it is this principle that resides at the heart of sound ethical thinking? Without it, Catholics are left with theocratic authoritarianism.

    Too many vocal and activist Catholics have no philosophical background. They have too much confidence in inexperience. They are theocratic and authoritarian.

  • Peter

    Have you seen that Fr. Barron is working on “The Catholicism Project”– see

    I have always been impressed with his intellect and ability to explain the faith. Good quote.

  • ockraz


    My father (who is not Catholic) used the words “theocratic authoritarianism” Thursday in arguing that the Catholic church, because of its structure, is inferior to the Anglican communion. I wonder what you would have said in response.