Dear America: We’re Not Losing to Cuba

Dear America: We’re Not Losing to Cuba December 19, 2014

3171465176_19128bda0e_zThe end of a five-decades-long embargo against Cuba has people buzzing. some are excited to be able to visit finally, and maybe bring back a few cigars and a bottle of Cuban rum. Others, like Congressman Marco Rubio, are incensed, or are at least pretending to be as a matter of political expedience.

The biggest argument against lifting the embargo, spoken most often and loudest from aspiring Republican presidential candidates, is that we’re giving away the proverbial farm and getting nothing in return. In fact it’s been distilled down even further to a “win/lose” false dichotomy, in which we are the losers of the final Cold War conflict, and the Castro family prevails.

To begin with, we have to look beyond the dictatorship and consider that we are also talking about  more than 11 million people when we talk about Cuba. And to focus solely on what is gained or lost in the most recent prisoner exchange, or what economic or other strategic benefits we can glean from the lifting of the embargo is more than myopic; it’s insensitive and it discounts the humanity of Cuba’s citizenry.

The Cuban people have paid for five decades for this embargo. They’ve experienced separation from loved ones, as well as economic hardship and political isolation from much of the larger world. They’ve become a proxy for the tensions between us and other communist nations with whom we seem to find a way to do business. To suggest we can transact billions of dollars in commerce with China, while strangling the Cuban economy for having similar policies, is and has been nothing less than hypocrisy.

Aside from this, it’s clear enough to much of the world that our embargo has patently failed to achieve its goal of regime change. If anything, our sanctions have served as a rallying cry for the Castro regime to justify the need for their own strong rule, in defiance of their imperialist neighbor to the north. And it’s not that such a dictatorship should be ignored or minimized with regard to its abuse of human rights.  But if two generations have passed without substantial change, I think it’s time to admit we took the wrong approach to begin with.

My hop,e though founded on little more than hope itself, is that Cuba will not become yet another political pawn in the already-mounting presidential circus that will not culminate for another year. Much like in our relations with Mexico, we are too quick to conflate the will and actions of a few political despots or corrupt politicians with the cultural consciousness of its citizenry. And to try to simplify our relationship with one of our closest international neighbors to a win/lose binary is either patently ignorant or egregiously opportunistic.

It’s time to lift the embargo, and to treat our Cuban brothers and sisters like the human beings that they are.

"I think God is so far above and beyond our understanding. Our little pin-prick, two ..."

Why Blood Atonement Theology Weakens God
"Apparently the Jews don't like them either, you won't find the them in the Jewish ..."

Why I, a Protestant, Pray the ..."
"I'm confused ... aren't Christians supposed to follow the bible?"

When All the Church Can Say ..."
"Hello, I really love the work you have in here, I love the way you ..."

25 Christian Blogs You Should Be ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • > If anything, our sanctions have served as a rallying cry for the Castro regime

    I agree, American policy towards Cuba actually had the opposite effect as planned; it made Castro an underdog hero.

  • MesKalamDug

    If Kennedy had followed Jesus’ advice and loved Fidel Castro there would have been a vey different Cuba. It might have stayed communist but I doubt it. The Castro brothers would have disappeared in 1980’s. The Castro regime has endured only because of the US hardline.

    The Law of Unexpected Consequences.

    And a big one for the Golden Rule.