Can Belief in Extraterrestrial Life Coexist with Faith in God?

Can Belief in Extraterrestrial Life Coexist with Faith in God? July 1, 2023

Ethereal scene with fog, trees, bushes, and an odd-looking manmade arch indicative of extraterrestrial life.
Is belief in extraterrestrial life an insult to or acknowledgment of the power of God? /Photo by Ashish R. Mishra on Unsplash

The question of whether belief in extraterrestrial life can coexist with faith in God has long been a subject of debate and speculation. On one hand, proponents of the existence of extraterrestrial life argue that the vastness of the universe and the probability of other habitable planets make it likely that life exists beyond Earth. On the other, those who hold strong religious beliefs often contend that the idea of extraterrestrial life contradicts the teachings of their faith. In this article, we will delve into this fascinating topic and explore the boundaries between belief in extraterrestrial life and faith in God.

What do We Know about Extraterrestrial Life?

To begin our exploration, it is important to have a clear understanding of what we mean by extraterrestrial life. Extraterrestrial life refers to any form of life that exists outside of Earth. While we have yet to discover concrete evidence, the field of astrobiology has made significant strides in recent years. These findings bring us closer to answering the age-old question of whether we are alone in the universe.

Scientists have discovered numerous exoplanets, which are planets that orbit stars outside of our solar system. Some of these may have the potential to support life. Additionally, the discovery of extremophiles, organisms that thrive in extreme environments on Earth, has expanded our understanding of the conditions under which life can exist. While these findings do not definitively prove the existence of extraterrestrial life, they certainly do fuel our curiosity.

The Origins of Faith in God: Historical and Religious Perspectives

Faith in God has been a central aspect of human existence for thousands of years. It has shaped our beliefs, values, and moral frameworks. The origins of faith in God can be traced back to ancient civilizations, in which early humans sought explanations for the mysteries of existence. Throughout history, various religious traditions and belief systems have emerged. Each offers its own understanding of the divine and the purpose of life.

For Christians, faith in God provides a sense of meaning, purpose, and guidance in navigating the complexities of existence. It offers comfort in times of adversity and a framework for understanding the world we live in and the universe outside it. The Bible is the leading source of everything we think, feel, and know about God, ourselves, and everything around us.

God’s Word is particularly silent on the matter of aliens. However, it does have plenty to say on the matter of otherworldly and supernatural beings such as angels and demons. Therefore, we cannot completely discount the existence of life on other planets based on Bible silence alone. After all, the Bible doesn’t say anything about cell phones and computers either, but we know they both exist.

Can Belief in Extraterrestrial Life Challenge Faith in God?

Because of the lack of clear words on extraterrestrials in the Bible, the question of how belief in extraterrestrial life can challenge faith in God is a complex one. Some argue that the existence of extraterrestrial life would undermine the notion of human exceptionalism. It threatens their belief that humanity is the pinnacle of creation. They contend that the existence of intelligent life elsewhere in the universe would challenge the uniqueness of human beings and our place in the grand scheme of things.

Others, however, maintain that the existence of extraterrestrial life is not inherently incompatible with faith in God. They argue that God’s creation is vast and diverse. Because of this, the discovery of extraterrestrial life would simply expand our understanding of His infinite power and creativity. They see the potential for life outside of Earth as a testament to the boundless nature of God’s creation, rather than a challenge to religious beliefs.

Exploring the Boundaries: Different Viewpoints on the Coexistence of Extraterrestrial Life and Faith in God

The coexistence of belief in extraterrestrial life and faith in God is a topic that has sparked a wide range of viewpoints and interpretations. Some apologists have embraced the possibility of extraterrestrial life, seeing it as an opportunity to expand their understanding of God’s creation. They view the search for life outside of Earth as a scientific endeavor that can complement and enhance their spiritual beliefs. The late famed evangelist Billy Graham is one such individual who argued that while aliens could exist, they do not have the inherent sin problem with which we humans are born.

Others, however, have expressed reservations or even outright rejection of the idea of extraterrestrial life. They argue, not incorrectly, that the Bible does not account for the existence of beings from other planets. Such beliefs actually contradict their faith. Answers in Genesis founder Ken Ham arrogantly responded to a question about the presence of aliens in hell by saying, “I don’t believe in aliens, so there will be no aliens in hell!”

These differing viewpoints highlight the complexity of reconciling scientific discoveries with religious interpretations, beliefs, and a careful examination of the Scripture.

Scientific Discoveries and Religious Interpretations: Finding Common Ground

Finding common ground between scientific discoveries and religious interpretations is a challenging, but necessary, endeavor. When faced with new knowledge and expanding horizons, we must approach these discoveries with an open mind. We must be willing to wisely interpret and carefully reinterpret religious texts and teachings. Many religious scholars and thinkers have embraced this approach in their attempts to bridge the gap between science and faith.

One way to find common ground is to consider that some biblical text contains metaphorical and symbolic language that can be interpreted in various ways. By approaching these passages with a metaphorical, rather than a stubbornly literal lens, we can explore how the existence of extraterrestrial life might fit into the broader narrative of faith. Additionally, viewing scientific discoveries as a means of uncovering the wonders of God’s creation can foster a sense of awe and reverence for the natural world. And it can actually enhance our faith in God.

Theological Implications: How Does the Existence of Extraterrestrial Life Affect Christian Beliefs?

The existence of extraterrestrial life has profound theological implications, in that it may challenge traditional understandings of God’s relationship with humanity. If intelligent life exists elsewhere in the universe, it raises questions about the nature of God’s plan and the purpose of human existence. Some religious thinkers suggest that the existence of extraterrestrial life may require us to reevaluate our anthropocentric view of creation to embrace a more inclusive cosmic perspective.

Furthermore, the discovery of life outside of Earth may prompt people from various religious traditions to engage in sympathetic interfaith dialogue. It can serve as a catalyst for deeper theological reflection and a reexamination of long-held beliefs. Ultimately, the theological implications of extraterrestrial life challenge us to broaden our understanding of the divine and our place in the universe.

Personal Perspectives: Interviews with Individuals Who Believe in Both Extraterrestrial Life and God

To gain a deeper understanding of the coexistence of belief in extraterrestrial life and faith in God, I conducted interviews with individuals who hold both these beliefs. These individuals shared their personal journeys and reflections on how they reconcile these seemingly contradictory ideas. I have changed the interviewees’ names to protect their privacy.

Sarah described her belief in God as the Creator of the universe, which includes all forms of life. For her, the existence of extraterrestrial life is a testament to the vastness and diversity of God’s creation. She sees no conflict between her scientific understanding of the universe and her faith in God. Rather, she views them as complementary ways of exploring the mysteries of existence.

In another conversation, Michael described his belief in extraterrestrial life as an extension of his faith in God’s infinite power. He believes God’s creation extends far beyond Earth and that intelligent life exists elsewhere in the universe. For Michael, the discovery of extraterrestrial life would deepen his awe and reverence for God’s boundless creativity.

Finding Harmony: Encouraging Open-Mindedness and Respectful Dialogue

In the debate between belief in extraterrestrial life and faith in God, it is essential to foster open-mindedness and respectful dialogue. Rather than viewing these perspectives as mutually exclusive, we can embrace the possibility of both. In this way, we humbly acknowledge how our understanding of the universe is constantly evolving.

Engaging in respectful dialogue allows us to learn from one another, challenge our own beliefs, and broaden our perspectives. It is through open conversations that we can find common ground and explore the intersections between science and faith. By approaching the topic with humility and a willingness to listen, we can create a space where diverse viewpoints are valued and respected. And this environment of respect may open the door for gospel conversations to take place. Remember what Peter wrote in his first letter to fellow believers:

Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect. (1 Peter 3:15, NIV)

That’s good advice for us to follow, as well.

Some Things to Consider When Making Up Your Own Mind

The Bible doesn’t give us clear answers on the existence of alien life. However, it does give us some clear information on certain key points that should guide our thinking on this issue.

  1. God is the Creator of everything, and He created both the heavens (note the plural) and the earth (Genesis 1:1).
  2. God sent His Son, Jesus, to restore His broken relationship with man through His death on the cross (see Romans 5 and 1 Corinthians 5:3-5).
  3. Since we know Jesus is the only way to a right relationship with God (see John 14:6), then any extraterrestrial beings would have to trust in Him as their Savior and Lord, as well. This is only true, however, if that relationship was broken. Billy Graham, as I stated above, didn’t believe this to be the case.
  4. If these other beings are going to be saved, then Jesus would have had to die for them on their respective planets. However, the Bible tells us that Jesus died once for all, here on Earth (see Romans 6:10). Therefore, one of two things is true. Either Jesus’s death is unnecessary on other planets, as Billy Graham believed, or He only died once for all here and then had to die elsewhere for the other beings who sinned, assuming that they did. But that’s a lot of assuming with no real Scripture to back it up.
  5. Science suggests that any extraterrestrial life that once existed is actually long dead. Like, a really long time dead … before the Earth was formed.
  6. Any curiosity or longing to discover life outside of Earth may actually be a longing for God Himself. Seek Him, and He will tell you everything you need to know (see Jeremiah 33:3)

My take on the issue? I’m a firm believer in Jesus Christ as my Savior and Lord. And I’m cautiously optimistic about the existence of life on other planets. It’s just so hard for me to believe that an infinite God only created living beings on one of the many planets He created. It doesn’t make sense. But then, His thoughts are higher than my thoughts, and His ways are higher than my ways (Isaiah 55:8-9). He knows what He’s doing, even when I don’t.

All I have to do is trust that God’s got this. There are some things I don’t need to know for sure.

Embracing the Possibility of Both Extraterrestrial Life and Faith in God

The question of whether belief in extraterrestrial life can coexist with faith in God is a thought-provoking and multifaceted topic. While it may challenge certain religious beliefs, it also presents an opportunity for deeper theological reflection and a broader understanding of the divine.

By embracing the possibility of both extraterrestrial life and faith in God, we can navigate the boundaries between science and religion with curiosity and open-mindedness. Rather than viewing these perspectives as conflicting, we can approach them as complementary ways of exploring the mysteries of existence.

As we continue to explore the vastness of the universe and search for signs we are not alone in it, let us remember the importance of respectful dialogue and the value of diverse perspectives. In doing so, we can foster a greater appreciation for the wonders of the cosmos and the complexities of our own faith. Let us embrace the possibility of both extraterrestrial life and faith in God and embark on a journey of discovery and understanding.

Thank you for reading this article. If you found it thought-provoking, I encourage you to share your own perspectives and engage in respectful dialogue with others in the comments. Together, let’s explore the boundaries and seek harmony between belief in extraterrestrial life and faith in God.

About Mishael Austin Witty
Mishael Austin Witty is a lover of Jesus, cats, coffee, and books. She is a wife to one man and mother of two girls. She serves as a discipleship coach, Sunday School teacher, children’s church helper, and food pantry organizer. You can read more about the author here.

Browse Our Archives