When God Doesn’t Meet Our Expectations

When God Doesn’t Meet Our Expectations 2017-12-28T09:31:57-04:00

What would you call a friend who is as unpredictable as the weather, who shows up unexpectedly behind the scenes to arrange things in your favor on occasion but who never seems to be around at crunch time? What is the right word to describe an acquaintance who you are sure can help in difficult situations and never is available, but who also has just the right word or advice when you are least expecting it? Unreliable? A godsend? Disappointing?

big bird 2

I just call her Big Bird. Once many years ago, when Jeanne joined my two young sons and I in a new โ€œblended familyโ€โ€”itโ€™s definitely a good thing that one doesnโ€™t know what one getting into when one makes such decisionsโ€”she referred to the Holy Spirit as โ€œBig Bird.โ€ It was a brilliant move on her part, locking into the imagination of a six and a eight-year-old accustomed to regular doses of Sesame Street an unforgettable image of the divine.ย My sons are now in their thirties, and the name my family uses most frequently when referring to โ€œwhat is greater than us,โ€ specifically the Holy Spirit, still is Big Bird. We have shared the nickname with many friends over the years and it seems just random and strange enough to fit.ย  Big Bird was the central topic of conversation at a memorable lunch that Jeanne and I had with a friend once, a conversation in which we compared notes on divine randomness.

As the agreed upon time for lunch with our friend Marsue came and went and Marsue did not arrive, I asked Jeanne โ€œshould I give her a call?โ€ We were meeting in an unfamiliar part of town at a restaurant none of us had eaten at beforeโ€“Samโ€™s Innโ€”an establishment chosen on the recommendation of a friend, and because it is relatively close to where Marsue was dropping her husband Robin off for a VFW lunch that she was happy to escape by hanging out with Jeanne and me. Answering on the fourth ring, Marsue said she was running late and had just dropped Robin off. As I helped her try to figure out how to get from her current location to the restaurant, she hung up. Oh well, I thoughtโ€”if she doesnโ€™t show up in ten minutes Iโ€™ll call her back and give the phone to the waitress or hostess to provide directions.

Five minutes later, in walked Marsue with a story. When I had been talking with her on the phone, she was buzzing through a school zone at least twenty miles over the posted speed limit trying to make up lost time. She met a town cop coming the other way, he did a U-turn with his lights on, and soon she was sitting on the side of the road with a police officer approaching her window. โ€œYou know why I pulled you over?โ€ he asked; โ€œI know, Iโ€™m was going too fast. Iโ€™m late meeting friends for lunch at Samโ€™s Inn, and Iโ€™m not sure where it even is. Can you help me out?โ€ Switching quickly from law enforcement to GPS mode, the officer assured her that she wasnโ€™t far from the restaurant and gave her directions, ending with โ€œplease be careful with your speedโ€”this is a school zone.โ€ He didnโ€™t write her a ticket.

As we caught up on each otherโ€™s past few weeks, a common theme emergedโ€”unexpected challenges that have upset our apple carts of plans. I was in the early months of a year-long sabbatical, which so far had been built around getting into the best shape of my life on my new bicycleโ€“until I tipped over and broke my ankle. Jeanne was โ€œcelebratingโ€ one year of unemployment that day; other than a welcome eight weeks of work in August and September, the job applications of a highly qualified and experienced professional had been met with the sound of crickets chirping. Marsue, a supposedly โ€œretiredโ€ Episcopal priest, was trying to figure out whatโ€™s next. All three of us are dedicated persons of faithโ€”none of us had a clue as to what God might be thinking. But then there are little incidents like Marsueโ€™s with the policemanโ€”if youโ€™ve been doing this faith thing long enough, you will be able to tick off any number of situations like that. Instances where, out of the blue, something gratuitous reminds you that something bigger is going on.

As if on cue, Jeanne offered another example of divine randomness. At the time, we were counting our dollars more carefully than usual because of her unemployment, so when she found an online class on healing that she wanted to take, she wasnโ€™t sure where the $350 course fee was going to come from. Until she remembered that for a while she had been squirreling away extra money here and there, including the money she received in cards for her birthday, in an envelope in the hutch cabinet (she calls it a โ€œbreakfrontโ€โ€”a Brooklyn thing, I think). Her remembrance was that there was $325 in the envelope, and obviously we could find the extra $25 somewhere (I could lay off Dunkinโ€™ Donuts for a couple of weeks, for instance). Upon further investigation she discovered that in addition she needed to purchase $35 of text books, pushing the total to $385. So now an extra $60 was needed. Upon checking the envelope, Jeanne discovered not the $325 she expected butโ€”you guessed itโ€“$385.

I know, normal human beings are inclined to call such events โ€œchanceโ€ or โ€œcoincidence.โ€ But the three of us around the table that afternoon at Samโ€™s Inn have long experience with what the poet Kilian MacDonnell calls โ€œOur preposterous God with a preposterous love.โ€ I noted that this is so typically Big Bird. She can unexpectedly fund an online course perfectly but seems incapable of finding Jeanne suitable employment. She sends Marsue directions to the restaurant by way of a policeman who has stopped her for speeding. She can fill my days and weeks with all sorts of intimations of holiness and yet is too busy to prevent my ankle from being broken when my bicycle harmlessly tips over with me on it. The life of faith I am familiar with has as many WTF?? moments as periods touched by grace. This is a constant reminder that God does not work according to our expectations.

Looking back, I realize that โ€œthings worked out.โ€ My ankle healed, my sabbatical was successful, and only an occasional twinge reminds me that my ankle ever had a problem. Jeanneโ€™s unemployment continued for a while longer, but she now has a full time position that suits her perfectly. Marsue eventually took a โ€œtemporaryโ€ position at a little Episcopal church that badly needed someone exactly like her. I need to learn how, in real time, to recognize apparently bad news as part of the gospelโ€™s good news, news that seldom reveals itself as we expect. Mary OliverMary Oliverโ€™s poem โ€œI Go Down to the Shoreโ€ captures it perfectly.

I go down to the shore in the morning / and depending on the hour the waves / are rolling in or moving out, / and I say, oh, I am miserable, / what shallโ€” / what should I do? And the sea says / in its lovely voice: / Excuse me, I have work to do.


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

I gathered materials for the temple but was told my son would build it instead. Who am I?

Select your answer to see how you score.