Another explanation for the Bethlehem star

Another explanation for the Bethlehem star

Bible scholar Colin R. Nicholl argues that the Star of Bethlehem was really a comet, a moving celestial object that was considered a type of star in ancient astronomy.

From What Kind of Astronomical Marvel was the Star of … | Christianity Today:

What evidence is there that the star was a comet?

The star appeared suddenly and was visible for over a year, something that makes sense only if it were a supernova or a great comet. That the star surprised the Magi with its impressive “rising” points strongly to it being a comet: Of all the celestial bodies, only comets behave in this manner. (Rising refers to the period when a celestial body re-emerges on the horizon after being hidden by the Sun.)

Then you take into account the star’s movement, in the space of a couple of months, from the eastern morning sky to the southern evening sky, where they see it when they’re traveling from Jerusalem to Bethlehem. That kind of movement is only possible for an object in the inner solar system, meaning that the star had to be a comet.

[Keep reading. . .]

 

"Or perhaps they just had some guys sing it for any number of reasons that ..."

The Earliest Hymn with Its Ancient ..."
"Not to worry. It is Jon Stewart."

Monday Miscellany, 4/13/26
"Sticking to your idiosyncratic view I see. Ask 10 people at random what they think ..."

Monday Miscellany, 4/13/26
"So you are saying that this piece is performed through the lens of a later ..."

The Earliest Hymn with Its Ancient ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

How long were the Jews in Babylonian captivity?

Select your answer to see how you score.