America’s first Independent president?

America’s first Independent president? 2016-12-02T21:38:59-05:00

Donald_Trump_by_Gage_Skidmore_12Donald Trump not only beat the Democrats.  Before that, he beat the Republicans. Dan Balz argues that Trump, in effect, is America’s first Independent president.

He doesn’t mention it, but Bernie Sanders is an actual Independent, who ran in the Democratic primaries.  So this was the year a big proportion of Americans voted against both party establishments, though in the context of a two-party system.  What Trump did, Balz says, is pull off a “hostile takeover” of the Republican party.

Read his argument after the jump, after which I offer a few thoughts of my own.

From Dan Balz, Donald Trump, America’s first independent president – The Washington Post:

Trump owes his success in part to the fact that he ran for president in an environment that favored change over the status quo. But his luck or genius goes beyond that. It has long been noted that the conditions have existed for an independent candidate to run a serious campaign for president. The level of dissatisfaction with Washington, the anxiety over the economy and the generally sour mood about the future provided the foundation for a campaign by someone from outside the system, who is tied to neither political party and with a promise to shake things up.

What has stood in the way of people running as an independent is that winning the presidency in a system that so clearly favors the two major parties is something of a hopeless cause. That’s a big reason former New York mayor Michael Bloomberg decided not to run several times when he seriously explored the idea.

Trump took the elements of an independent candidacy — the lack of clear ideology, the name recognition of a national celebrity and the personal fortune needed to fund a presidential campaign — and then did what no one seemed to have thought of before. He staged a hostile takeover of an existing major party. He had the best of both worlds, an outsider candidacy with crosscutting ideological appeal and the platform of a major party to wage the general election. By the time he had finished, he had taken down two political dynasties: the Bush dynasty in the primaries and the Clinton dynasty in the general election.

[Keep reading. . .]

I would just observe that George Washington was not a member of a political party–indeed, he warned against them–and he was elected.  Unanimously.  (Though not in an election like ours.  The Electoral College, chosen by the states with no candidates on any ballot, chose him unanimously.)

Also, it will be interesting to see how Trump staffs his administration.  If he only chooses Republicans–“establishment” or not–then his presidency would seem to be Republican after all.

It will also be interesting to see if “Trumpism” survives beyond Trump’s term or terms.  Will other Republicans adopt his philosophy and approach of economic nationalism, as opposed to free market capitalism?  Will this become the new Republican ideology?  Or will it just be connected to his person and not last beyond him, in which case Trump would be an Independent outlier?

Finally, if the general public is sick of both parties, is there a possibility of adding more?  Might there be sub-parties that could also conduct a “hostile takeover” of one or both of the two main players?

 

Photo by Gage Skidmore [CC BY-SA 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

"Springtime is often the hardest time of the year, not the Fall. It's in Springtime ..."

The Dignity of the Work AI ..."
"Good (although quite long) interview. (In contrast to this good piece, Klein's piece about Hassan ..."

The Dignity of the Work AI ..."
"Here's a coincidence. The NYT's Ezra Klein has posted an interview today with Stuart Brand. ..."

The Dignity of the Work AI ..."
"You cannot be a good writer unless you learn rules of grammar, spelling and read ..."

The Dignity of the Work AI ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TAKE THE
Religious Wisdom Quiz

What does "forgive us our trespasses as we forgive"" mean in the Lord's Prayer?

Select your answer to see how you score.