Analogies

Analogies March 8, 2010

I love analogies.  Here is one from Charles Krauthammer on a conundrum in the health care reform bill:

Obama was reduced to suggesting that his health-care reform was indeed popular because when you ask people about individual items (for example, eliminating exclusions for preexisting conditions or capping individual out-of-pocket payments), they are in favor.

Yet mystifyingly they oppose the whole package. How can that be?

Allow me to demystify. Imagine a bill granting every American a free federally delivered ice cream every Sunday morning. Provision 2: steak on Monday, also home delivered. Provision 3: a dozen red roses every Tuesday. You get the idea. Would each individual provision be popular in the polls? Of course.

However (life is a vale of howevers) suppose these provisions were bundled into a bill that also spelled out how the goodies are to be paid for and managed — say, half a trillion dollars in new taxes, half a trillion in Medicare cuts (cuts not to keep Medicare solvent but to pay for the ice cream, steak and flowers), 118 new boards and commissions to administer the bounty-giving, and government regulation dictating, for example, how your steak is to be cooked. How do you think this would poll?

Perhaps something like 3 to 1 against, which is what the latest CNN poll shows is the citizenry’s feeling about the current Democratic health-care bills.

What are some other analogies that might help us understand current issues?

(This is not a thread about the health care bill, as such. Challenge the aptness of Krauthammer’s analogy, if you wish, but what I’d like to see are more analogies.)

"The New Right isn't new and it isn't right. It is just populism. We've done ..."

Abortion Supply and Demand
"It's accurate, anyhow."

Abortion Supply and Demand
"But abortion clinics are heavily regulated, even in "pro-choice" states and localities, and their medical ..."

Abortion Supply and Demand
"You probably need more than one word to include everything other than "bleeding out on ..."

Abortion Supply and Demand

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!