To the Progressive Dissenter loyal only to the Third Vatican Council, he’s Ratzi the Nazi. To the wingnut anti-semitic Rad Trads, he’s a Judaizing fiend.
To me, he is a living embodiment of Chesterton’s remark, “If you hear a thing being accused of being too tall and too short, too red and too green, too bad in one way and too bad also in the opposite way, then you may be sure that it is very good.”
Mark me down as thinking Benedict is very good.