Everybody on both sides of the gay “marriage” debate…

Everybody on both sides of the gay “marriage” debate… May 30, 2012

…appeals to “nature”. Opponents argue that homosex is unnatural. Advocates argue that any urge we feel is “natural” by virtue of its being felt.

Zac Alstin asks, “What do you mean by ‘natural’?”

"Sure it is. Everything you've said moral relativist bushwah designed to make excuses for your ..."

Kavanaugh Joins Court Majority to cast ..."
"Hillary lost. It's over. Move on. Your problem is that you are now reduced to ..."

Kavanaugh Joins Court Majority to cast ..."
"It’s not my “cult”.My FB post the day of the 16’ election:So I vote this ..."

Yep. It is vital to understand ..."
"Prayer and support does not equal “unquestioning loyalty”. Take it easy with the false inferences, ..."

Yep. It is vital to understand ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • What do we mean by ‘is’? What do we mean by ‘mean’? The list could go on and on. This is quite enjoyable.

  • ivan_the_mad

    Thanks for the post, it was a fun read. I enjoy expositions of Eastern thought. Highly relevant, too – the naturalistic fallacy is all too common these days (how very many times in college I tried to disabuse acquaintances of the notion that smoking pot is good because it’s “natural”).

  • I’ve been wondering when this point was going to be made. Homosexual activists have been wanting to have their Natural Law cake and eat it, too.

  • Mark S (not for Shea)

    When someone cuts in front of me in the concession line at the movie, it is part of basic nature to want to smash their face into the candy counter. When someone is rude to my wife in the grocery store, it is quite natural to want to pelt them with tomatoes.

    Just because a feeling is natural doesn’t necessarily make it right. Primal urges do not define morality.

    The whole nature vs. nurture debate is fascinating and fun. But ultimately, it’s all moot.