Siris on Zmirak on Usury

Siris on Zmirak on Usury January 2, 2015

This is the sort of junk Catholics too often have to wade through these days. And junk it is; all you have to do to see that is to read Fifth Lateran on usury and Vix pervenit, both of which are excellent contributions to moral theology, and then Zmirak, to see that the third of these things is junk. Nor is there the slightest doubt what Zmirak is about; he comes out straightforwardly with it: he wants to ignore the moral teaching of the Church whenever he finds it inconvenient to take seriously. Of course, what I really love about the article is the elaborate pretense that you either agree with him or you are taking the Church to be “sacramentally married to every assertion on economics and politics by any pope,” whatever in the world such a lunatic position would actually mean. In reality, of course, we are talking about teaching, and teaching is multifaceted by its very nature; it requires a multifaceted response and self-cultivation on the part of the students — which would be people like myself and other Catholics, including, yes, Zmirak, whether he wants to be the student of the Bishops or not — not the simplistic dichotomy Zmirak is trying to peddle, which is an improvement over exactly nothing.

More here.

What drives me crazy about Zmirak’s style of argument is that he can’t just make his case.  He has to punch below the belt after he makes his case.  He can’t just say “I think you should vote for Romney”.  He has to call you a spiritual masturbator if you choose to vote for a third party.

"A kooky, superstitous fraudster like yourself is in no position to speak of weak minds.For ..."

First Things: Against the Living Consensus
"Ad hominem insults are the resort of weak minds. I notice you take refuge there ..."

First Things: Against the Living Consensus
"So sayeth the dissident. Martin Luther is rolling in his grave."

First Things: Against the Living Consensus
"If people like you are the real testament of that power, then I'd sooner serve ..."

First Things: Against the Living Consensus

Browse Our Archives