On Churches and Ecclesial Communities

On Churches and Ecclesial Communities June 4, 2016

A reader remarks on the tiny kerfuffle among a few Orthodox bishops who said the Catholic Church is not a real Church the other day:

Gives me a chuckle as the tables are turned on us Romans. Didn’t Benedict once describe Protestants as “ecclesial communities”?

Partly correct. Except it was not “Benedict” and its was not a private opinion. Its was the teaching of Holy Church in Dominus Iesus. Because at the heart of the Church is the Eucharist and if there is not a valid Eucharist the Church is not present in its fullness. So the Church distinguishes between true Churches (including, by the way, eastern Churches not in communion with Rome) and “ecclesial communities” which preserve valid baptism but do not have a valid Eucharist (indeed, in some communities, who actively reject not merely a valid Eucharist but any need for any form of communion, symbolic or otherwise). It’s a perfectly rational distinction and is not intended as an insult, but as clarity.

Browse Our Archives