Blessed or Most Honorable? Beatitudes on All Saints

Blessed or Most Honorable? Beatitudes on All Saints November 1, 2019
Blessed poverty?
Photo by Ali Arif Soydaş on Unsplash

“Blessed are…” go the Beatitudes of Jesus, but maybe wrongly in our English translations!

Blessed with critical tools unknown by throughout Church history, our age is gifted with unique opportunities for diving deep into the Gospels! Solemnity for All Saints our Gospel reading is the longer form of the Beatitudes, from the Gospel called “Matthew.” We shared in an earlier blog post about the Woes and Beatitudes and how they function in the Mediterranean core cultural values of honor and shame.

There is nothing more basic to learn about the Mediterranean world of Jesus and the Scriptures than the core cultural value of honor. The Church teaches that the Literal Sense of Scripture comes first. In order to acquire that, one needs to understand Mediterranean culture. Therefore the first interpretation of the Bible—including the Gospels, the Beatitudes, and Jesus!—is Mediterranean culture. Without grasping the value of honor, you are far away from understanding Jesus.

As we have stressed numerous times before, honor is the engine generating all behavior in the world of Jesus. But what is honor?

Honor
The public claim, whether by person or group, to value
and the society’s acknowledgement of that claim.

Blessed should be Most Honorable
Fellow Dying Inmate / All rights reserved

“Blessed are the…”

Throughout the Scriptures are a little over eighty poetic sayings called “beatitudes.” All of these praise, encourage, celebrate, and present honorable behavior. Jesus’ beatitudes found differently in “Matthew” and in “Luke” are no different.

English Bible translations abound with anachronism and ethnocentric blunders. The New American Bible Revised Edition, for all its benefits, is no exception. Every time you see “blessed,” or “fortunate,” or “happy” when reading a beatitude, it’s a mistake. Scratch it out and replace it with “highly esteemed” or “most honorable” is he who does or thinks this way.

So let’s repair the bad work done on these parables by well-meaning yet errant translators.

Blessed are the POOR in spirit…

NABRE Matthew 5:3
Blessed are the poor in spirit,
for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.

Corrected Matthew 5:3
Truly honorable is the one who [cannot maintain and] has lost his honor-status
for theirs is the kingdom of sky vault [politically correct expression of Israelite theocracy, which restores without surpassing their original status]

The Matthean Jesus presents a new basis for honor and honoring someone. It goes completely contrary to ancient Mediterranean social norms to praise the categories of people Jesus does in his beatitudes—the poor, the mourning, and the hungry. These are people who are helpless and cannot defend their honor. Yet Jesus affirms they will be honored by the God of Israel.

“The Poor” are those unable to maintain their social status. In the Bible “poor” never designates an economic situation. Instead, “poor” in the Bible refers to someone who has temporarily lost their honor rating or social status. Now they must do whatever it takes to recover their lost honor, but not one smidgen more than their original status.

Astonishingly, Jesus calls being poor in this sense as being honorable! He says theocracy is theirs. Out of reverence for the God of Israel, in a divinely passive voice, the insinuation is that God will provide their honor and social status in the Kingdom.

Blessed are they who mourn…

NABRE Matthew 5:4
Blessed are they who mourn,
for they will be comforted.

Corrected Matthew 5:4
Truly honorable is the one who [engages in social protest by] mourn[ing],
for they will be comforted [ = theocracy will restore their lost kinship network members].

Those who are poor in the Biblical sense mourn (and fasts), that is, engages in social protest against their unjust condition. But even if their neighbors and kin neglect them, God will comfort them in theocracy.

Blessed are the meek…

NABRE Matthew 5:5
Blessed are the meek,
for they will inherit the land.

Corrected Matthew 5:5
Truly honorable are the meek [ = those who CAN resort to violence to take back their rightful status, but are confident in the God of Israel and therefore choose instead gentle non-violence],
for they will inherit the land [of ancient Israel, and with it, their original honor-status, no more, no less].

Jesus was nonviolent, but his nonviolence should not be confused with that of a Mahatma Gandhi or a Martin Luther King Jr. He was not a pacifist. Although certainly nonviolent, Jesus was deeply embedded into his agonistic culture. He accepted the reality of honor debts and that violent retribution was owed—but Jesus canceled the debt and he promoted canceling the debt among his followers. His nonviolence consisted often of cancelling the honor-debt.

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst…

NABRE Matthew 5:6
Blessed are they who hunger and thirst for righteousness,
for they will be satisfied.

Corrected Matthew 5:6
Truly honorable is the one who hungers and thirsts for righteousness [= who fasts, engaging in social protest],
for they will be satisfied [in theocracy].

This again furthers the Matthean Jesus declaring the poor who mourn as honorable. God will satisfy their hunger for justice.

Blessed are the merciful…

NABRE Matthew 5:7
Blessed are the merciful,
for they will be shown mercy.

Corrected Matthew 5:7
Truly honorable are the merciful [those who fulfill filial obligations to others, who give what is owed],
for they will be shown mercy [the fulfillment of obligations, the giving of that which is owed].

In the Bible, “mercy” means paying your debts of interpersonal obligation to God and neighbor. So with that in mind, you know what a cry for mercy means in the Bible—“Give me what I am owed!” And you should also realize what it means to be merciful in the Biblical sense.

Blessed are the single-hearted…

NABRE Matthew 5:8
Blessed are the clean of heart,
for they will see God.

Corrected Matthew 5:8
Truly honorable are the pure of heart [single-hearted/single-minded person who seeks only to honor God],
for they will see God [in theocracy].

This verse has nothing to do with sexual purity. It has to do with honor concerns. Those poor who will enter theocracy and see the glory (i.e., honor) of God are precisely those who care for God’s honor here and now. God will give them their proper honor and they will never be stripped of it again.

Blessed are the peacemakers…

NABRE Matthew 5:9
Blessed are the peacemakers,
for they will be called children of God.

Corrected Matthew 5:9
Truly honorable are the mediators [those who head-off blood feuds],
for they will be called children of God [ = clients of the Patron, the God of Israel = genuine Israelites = honored].

The Greek for this verse about what the mediators get called is “sons of God” (υἱοἱ θεοῦ) and not “children of God” (τέκνα θεοῦ), which, by the way, happened to be the self-designation of the Johannine Jesus group. Sometimes inclusive language attempts from the translators really distort things. It may tingle our American ears and make us feel good, but our ancestors did not perceive or believe many things that we do.

“Son of…” in the Bible means “having the qualities of…” “Son of God” therefore means “one with divine-like qualities.” It originally meant a holy man, one who can broker favors with alternate reality, the realm of God. Long before the Church came to understand Jesus as the Second Person of the Trinity, he was recognized as and lived according to all the criteria of a Mediterranean “son of God,” or holy man. Such holy men and women are identified by anthropologists in their cross-cultural studies as shamans.

To arbitrate between parties and prevent blood feuds was a great responsibility. Given the intensely agonistic society of Jesus, to be such a peacemaker who heads of violence would require God-like talent.

Blessed are they who are persecuted…

NABRE Matthew 5:10-12
Blessed are they who are persecuted for the sake of righteousness,
for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
Blessed are you when they insult you and persecute you and utter every kind of evil against you [falsely] because of me. Rejoice and be glad, for your reward will be great in heaven. Thus they persecuted the prophets who were before you.

Corrected Matthew 5:10
Truly honorable are they who are persecuted [those hazed/publicly humiliated to conform to other Israelite ingroup norms] for the sake of righteousness [proclaiming theocracy],
for theirs is the kingdom of sky vault [Israelite theocracy].
Truly honorable are you when they insult [shame] you and persecute [haze to conform someone back into their ingroup norms] you and utter every kind of evil against you [falsely] because of me. Rejoice and be glad, for your reward will be great in sky vault [publicly seen, and everyone will see]. Thus they persecuted the prophets who were before you.

As we saw in the story of The Two Lost Sons, the village poor in all agrarian societies face marginalization and ostracism, especially by the greedy urban elites. Any person with surplus who joins the Jesus group will suffer the same fate. “Matthew” is aware of the terrible costs but presents it without compromise (Matthew 12:46; 22:1-14).

Jesus in his counter-structural vision sees things differently than the vast majority of those in his ancient world. Ultimately, the honor and esteem of elites doesn’t matter. What matters is the honor bestowed by God. All honor is public, and all will see God’s honoring his faithful ones. God did this for the prophets who could be seen in the sky vaults above Israel together with the angels as glorious stars.

Conclusion

As we consider all the saints and martyrs today, perhaps some good can come out of observing the perennial temptation to turn them into inhuman things, unrelatable and alien to the human condition. But the saints were and are very human. Christ is the very definition of human, more human than any of us humans becoming precisely because he is divine. He turns the world upside down. How can we be more inclusive of the excluded, more canceling with debts, more loving? Such is the Way of saints—to be human. Such is the Way of Christ.


Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Ame

    I think it’s the case that while Jesus is intentional in subverting the man made traditions concerning honor and shame, there is also a bigger context at play. He’s not just talking about Blessings of his new covenant, but also curses in the form of Woes. The way he presents them ought to look familiar to at least the Scribes, who would recall the declaration of the covenant with Moses and the Hebrews. Jesus is doing more than comparing himself to Moses here. He’s flagging himself as the Messiah ushering in a new covenant, as promised in the prophesy in the Book of Jeremiah. This is not just about not being nice according to Mediterranean sensibilities. The Sermon on the Mount would have been seen by the Pharisees as “fighting words,” a conspiracy to usurp their power as the seat of Moses. And of course, I must acknowledge that this idea is not my own, but what I’ve gleaned from Michal Hunt.

  • davidt

    Oh yea you are hitting on the issues.

    Personally I roll the story back
    to joseph. He was confronted by the “word of God” that he was to have Mary killed. He said screw that screw religion screw all of you i am marrying her she is innocent what the hell is love you idiots?.

    And from.that action a child was born, that love incarnate, died that love incarnate, and rose that love incarnate. And that became the word of God in it’s rejection of writing itself forever defying that it determines what is god who god is even as the text often is rendered into nonsense and fantasy that the texts rejects.

    That’s a powerful paradox.to say the least. It invalidates writing as it’s written as being fundemental and that God rejects and trancends writing and the word of God as being fundemental and that is the word of God.

    That’s a Buddhist koan.of a deep order right there.

  • Ame

    Lol, I like your spirit. But I’ll have to say both yes and no to all of that.

  • davidt

    Oh wrong article. My post has zero to do with it sorry about that.