CLS v Martinez: The Alliance Defense Fund Responds

CLS v Martinez: The Alliance Defense Fund Responds June 28, 2010

In my earlier post I framed the issues behind CLS v. Martinez and noted the first-blush response of David French, senior legal counsel for the Alliance Defense Fund, which argued the case alongside the Christian Legal Society.  The ADF just issued their press release on the case.  Granted, they have an interest in arguing that this does not decide the issue of free religious association on college campuses without discrimination.  Still, they may well be right in their interpretation of the case.  They say:

“The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5–4 Monday to uphold an unusual university policy that forces student groups to allow outsiders who disagree with their beliefs to become leaders and voting members. The court confined its opinion to the unique policy and did not address whether nondiscrimination policies in general, which are typical on public university campuses, may require this.   The court concluded that public universities may override a religious student group’s right to determine its leadership only if it denies that right to all student groups.”

In other words, ADF interprets this ruling as a very narrow one – indeed, so narrow that it does not presently apply at any other college campus.  The question, it seems to me, is whether other college campuses may follow suit and tailor their policies in the image of the Hastings “all comers” policy.  If they did, Christian groups on campuses will be in a very tenuous position.

Clearly, then, the battle for how the ruling is interpretation will be over (1) whether it is a broadly applicable ruling, or a very narrowly defined one; (2) whether other public universities can simply follow suit and use this as a means to de-legitimize religious student groups; and (3) over the remanding issue.  One of the issues (if ADF attorney David French is to be believed – I have not finished reading through the decision myself) was remanded back to the lower court for further exploration.

But another of the ADF attorneys points to the potential for a broadly applicable ruling and its consequences:

“The conflict still exists. This decision doesn’t settle the core constitutional issue of whether nondiscrimination policies in general can force religious student groups to allow non-believers to lead their groups,” explained ADF Senior Legal Counsel Gregory S. Baylor. “Long-term, the decision puts other student groups across the country at risk, and we will continue to fight for their constitutional rights. The Hastings policy actually requires CLS to allow atheists to lead its Bible studies and the College Democrats to accept the election of Republican officers in order for the groups to be recognized on campus. We agree with Justice Alito in his dissent that the court should have rejected this as absurd.”

More to come.

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • RT @patheos: CLS v Martinez: The Alliance Defense Fund Responds #patheos

  • CLS v Martinez: The Alliance Defense Fund Responds #patheos

  • It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

  • Following my own monitoring, billions of persons all over the world receive the credit loans from well known banks. Hence, there is a good chance to receive a collateral loan in any country.

  • When he told me about his illness a few weeks ago I was stunned, and struggled unsuccessfully to hold back the tears. I’m struggling to hold them back now as I write this, but I know he wouldn’t want any of that sadness. In his last email to me he insisted upon talking about something else, even though he evidently didn’t really have the energy to talk at all.

  • But the truth is that I have too many great memories to mention. Paul and I read together on several occasions, both in the U.S. and in England, but it’s not just poetry memories that come flooding back. My son Andy today reminded me of a photo that exists somewhere in an album of Paul seated on our couch with one of our kittens perched on his shoulder. That would have been the very early 90s, I guess. And on one occasion in Aldeburgh I remember Paul running into the North Sea in his underwear. Why? Well, it’s the sea, and it was there. The fact that it was a cold bleak day, and the North Sea is never warmer than freezing, was not going to stop him.

  • I knew Paul for almost 30 years. We met back in the very early 80s, through the magazine (joe soap’s canoe) I was editing at the time. I think the canoe was the first place to publish him in the U.K. We then met in person on my first trip to the U.S. in 1983, and a friendship soon developed that I valued more highly than I can say. Paul visited England on a number of occasions, sometimes for readings I organized, and for one especially memorable tour when he curated an exhibition of Kenneth Koch’s collaborations with artists at an art gallery in Ipswich. I was the town’s local

  • Things were pretty ugly for the offense Saturday during the annual spring game as UW’s defense held the offense without a touchdown. The real score of the game was 3-0 and UW’s QBs didn’t do anything to ease Badger fans’ concerns about replacing Scott Tolzien. The QBs were collectively 22-for-61 passing with three interceptions, a fumble and no touchdowns.

  • He first wrinkle are two new judges, Aerosmith’s Steven Tyler and Marc Anthony’s Jennifer Lopez. The second is the addition into the frays of the competiton of “music industry legend – and mentor – Jimmy Iovine.” Other than this, AI is strickly business as usual.

  • Thank you for this article. That’s all I can say. You most definitely have made this blog into something special. You clearly know what you are doing, you’ve covered so many bases.Thanks!

  • Your article was great, evident by his comments. I am also happy to read

  • Good!Dear friends, thank you for visiting our website ,we are an international trade company . We at competitive price,providing a huge range of Jewellery. You can buy cheap Pandora Jewellery. Welcome to visist here.

  • ralph lauren shirts

  • christian louboutin

  • ed hardy good shop

  • wak aklasdkjfaosfdj

  • Nice Post. It’s really a very good article. I noticed all your important points. Thanks

  • christian louboutin

  • Recently, the world’s largest luggage manufacturer Samsonite travel officially listed in Hong Kong; then, the internationally renowned luxury brand Prada has landed in Hong Kong Stock Exchange. In addition, another COACH (Coach), Choo (Jimmy Choo), Burberry (Burberry) and other brands listed in Hong Kong
    coach poppy bags
    Coach Shoulder Bags
    coach luggage

  • vivi

    Thanks for the best was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well.this was actually what i was looking for,and i am glad to came here!pearl jewelry wholesale online; thanks for sharing the such information with us.subsequently,after spending many hours on the internet at last we are uncovered an individual that definitely does know what they are dicussing many thanks a great deal wonderful post.The freshwater pearl jewelry; thank

  • echo
  • I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

  • This was really an interesting subject, I am very lucky to be able to come to your weblog and I will bookmark this web page in order that I could come back another time.This was really an interesting subject, I am very lucky to be able to come to your weblog and I will bookmark this web page in order that I could come back another time.

    cheap nike shoxnike shox outlet nike shox shoes outlet

  • I am surprise that this page is so beautiful ,so cheap jordan shoees and fashion sunglasses, I think everyone who join in this page will like it , they will be interested in these beautiful jordan shoes and sunglasses .so popular jordan shoes and gucci sunglasses they provide, it is worth reading!

  • Wow,you have a quite exceptional view.I really wonder how you can do that.So marvelous

  • I enjoyed reading your post and I like your take on the issue. Thanks.

    I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading.Nice blog,I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  • laptops battery

  • Your post is excellent. I learn much from your article. Life is a beautiful journey. Everyone can only live but once. Wise people knows that we should enjoy our life. We should care about everything around us. Clothes, foods, friends, families and everything. Come on, make a better world for you and for me. At the same time, I think my website is good as well . Maybe you can have a look at my website and buy a pair of Cheap Nike Air Force One Shoes.

  • Very nice ,I love reading through your blog, I wanted to leave a little comment to support you and wish you a good continuation. Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts.

  • echo
  • Should I Remove theinspiron 1525 battery For A Desktop Replacement Laptop?Well,when using a laptop as a desktop replacement the inspiron 6400 battery

  • What your talking about Diesel Bootcut Jeansis the spin being given to the case by Michael McConnell…I will not accept that somehow liberty is being suppressed just g star rawbecause religious groups cannot get money from a university. That is a real distortion.”

  • this topic is very well cheap MBT shoes researched and i admire the author for discussing it thoroughly

  • The teacher is asking an arithmetic question: “Jack, if you found three dollars in your right pocket and two dollars in your left pocket, belstaff jackets bizwhat would you have?”

    “I must have somebody else’s pants on.”

  • Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you

  • off the shoulder bridal gowns,off the shoulder bridal gowns gorgeous, assured and at ease. So what we’re saying is usually that when the addition of pockets can help you to sense that way awesome!

  • This really answered my problem, thank you!

  • 4763733 beers on the wall. sck was here

  • Wang Mu-sheng 16 years old, had tried to borrow money to make money for belstaff sale the journey to the village where, like out of this village, nook, to make a living in big cities.
    However, the fact that he is just fantastic, because the village there are fundamentally no money to be borrowed.
    Perhaps, if his parents still, then perhaps something can scrape together money for belstaff bag the journey to find ways to Pinlelaoming to him, let him out of this nook village to big cities in the popular hot drink.

  • I really appreciate your article, in fact I think you deserve a thumbs up.whyhpIIfBkAwovr

  • Thanks for not only taking the time to write this, but to even improve the information by making it easy to read and understand.

  • This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work.

  • appreciate your article, in fact I think you deserve a thumbs up.whyhpIIfBkAwovr

  • Colts Manning is looking for a possible successor, says Polian

    Indianapolis – Bill Polian already looking for the next Peyton Manning.

    Unlock HQ Video HQ video was made by Akamai
    Colts vice president said Monday night listeners that although the team expects Manning to return from neck surgery or the next season and play at least a few years in Indianapolis, he was already considering, that would be the heir of Star Defender.

    “Peyton at the age when he admits, and we recognize that his career in the home stretch,” Polian said on his weekly radio show.

    “While we expect he will be back, and we expect it will be with us next year, it’s time we give serious consideration to the position we do every year Question: .. What do you use to choose a lawyer and you structure the contract, etc.. “

  • The preferred material for motorcyclists is leather. That’s because leather is flexible and durable enough to help protect you from serious injuries.
    Nike Air Max 180
    Nike Air Max 2009
    air max
    Nike Air Max 2010

  • I have learned a lot from your site. Thanks!! I think you have done an excellent job with your site. I will return in the near future. Cheap NFL Jerseys
    Cheap Jerseys

  • Navie
  • It makes me feel so surprise.I never know there is such a place that I can find cheap designer clothing,The site offers different designer clothing wholesale kinds of LV,Chanel,Coach etc.It’s really a great clothes stores with cheap and high quality.Join it now!

  • This looks absolutely perfect. How much elegance and the sense of art at one place! All these tinny details are made with lot of and knowledge. Looks like people who lived in 18th had much more taste for nice and much more time to enjoy their lives.

  • I really love to read articles that have good information and ideas to share to each reader. I hope to read more from you guys and continue that good work that is really inspiring to us.
    north face shop
    north face
    north face sale

  • Your blog is a great one. What really impresses me is that you are correctly mentioned that there are thousands of tools that are available to create a website or launch one but what matters is that you choose the right one, the one that gives you all that is actually needed.

  • silhouette focus on nfl kid jerseys the louboutin heels entire cutting which closely follows the curves from shoulder to the hem, and flares out buy louboutin into buy louboutin shoes a trumpet shape skirt at the kneed or just below. louboutin boots The fitted bodice and fishtail like skirt just create a dramatic and eye-catching look to the pink ugg boots bride on kid nfl jerseys her big day.

  • wow, helpful site, I found the post are very useful

  • Thank you for sharing your stuff on blog. It is doubtless that we have similar interests. Something are very helpful to me.

  • your artical give me much more useful information. thanks for your help. i’ll suggest my friends to read your artical.Nice one, there is actually some good points ony readers may find this useful, I must send a link, many thanks.Took me awhile to read all the comments, but I really love the article. It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

  • It’s really a nice and helpful piece of information. I’m glad that you so with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  • Nice time to publish this information very useful!I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post thanks!
    UGG KnightsbridgeUGG Knightsbridge Sale

  • 3038535 beers on the wall. sck was here

  • Great and useful designs you have posted .

  • It’s a good blog, and we are funny adopt words and adapt our lexicon to the times.

  • It proved to be very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here!

  • You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.Keep sharing and posting articles like these.This article has helped me a lot.Keep posting this stuff…

  • I will keep your new article. I really enjoyed reading this post, thanks for sharing.

  • Nice piece, i remember looking somewhere else to do with this. Made me want to do another search in yahoo for more info and found

    your blog post. Great piece

  • Are you an animal lover? thomas sabo offers a variety of animal design charms. You can go for rare and exotic to cute and cuddly. All animal charms are sterling silver that is polished for beautiful shine.thomas sabo charm bracelet There is a charm that represents the birthstone for every month. They are beautiful and will dazzle even the most unobservant eye. Along with this, why not add the zodiac sign.thomas sabo jewellery charm bracelet created in a Cameo style. Each one is carved to represent the individual personalities of every sign.

  • Here is a specifically ghd hair straighteners online outlet. If you are looking for genuine ghd hair iron at the cheapest price from an approved website then you have come to the right place! Pink ghd Iv styler Anybody can afford the price of discount ghd hair straighteners at
    For many people, hair styling plays an important role in daily life and hair straightener is a must have style accessory. Ghd straightener is extremely world’s Famous Luxury Hairstyling Tools. And GHD Pink Limited Edition has been leading the hair fashion and very hot among women all over the world. Buying ghd straightener online has become very popular. So many girls and women want to purchase good ghd straightener with reasonable price online in order to keep their hair in a perfect style. Our website lists all the excellent deals from official GHD Shop retail partners, ensuring that you receive the best quality, the cheapest price and the best customer service. Welcome old and new customers, all the cheap ghd straightener is free shipping no tax.