Yes, Seders are for Christians. The asterisk in the title above
Last week’s guest opinion piece written by Rabbi Yehiel Poupko and Rabbi David Sandmel entitled “Jesus Didn’t Eat A Seder Meal” was published on the Christianity Today website as a pushback against the appropriation of Passover Seders by a growing number in the Christian community. The two rabbis pointed out that Passover was given to the Jews, and all others should cease and desist.
A year ago, I interviewed Reform rabbi Evan Moffic about this very topic for Christianity Today. (Link here.) Moffic has a different point of view on the subject, to say the least. His words belong in this conversation about Christians and the Seder. The fact is, this is a conversation – an important one. Poupko and Sandmel don’t speak for all Jews. The Jewish community has a saying: “Two Jews, three opinions.” In other words, our history of learning by questioning cultivates an environment where loving, spirited debate is hard-wired into our very souls.
I am a Jewish follower of Jesus and would like to affirm one concern expressed by Poupko and Sandmel, while challenging a couple of other things about their post.
First, I hear and agree with the concern expressed by Poupko and Sandmel regarding appropriation, the definition of which is using for oneself without permission something that belongs to another. It’s a fancy way of saying “stealing”. The issue of appropriation is reason for my *asterisk* in the title of the post, above. Poupko and Sandmel note:
…adopting another’s ritual shows a lack of respect. Even when pursued with the best of intentions, taking another faith’s sacred ritual and transforming it into an expression of one’s own tradition displays a misunderstanding of the complex nature of faith traditions. Good relations between Christianity and Judaism, and by extension, other faiths as well, may begin with acknowledging common principles, but also demand a clear articulation of the profound differences that separate them. However, it is surely not the goal of good interfaith relations for Jews and Christians to co-opt or reshape one another’s rituals for their own ends.
My husband and I have led quite a few Seders for Gentile friends over the years, and we take special care to help participants understand the Exodus account as well as highlighting the post-Second Temple rabbinic liturgy and customs that helped my people tell the story of God’s deliverance from one generation to another. We also make sure to note where the Jewish Jesus expanded upon tradition extant in his day, for example by washing his disciples feet when it was expected that Jews would cleanse their hands before a meal. Most people I’ve known within the Messianic movement are careful to do the same. However, with the rise in popularity of Seders in some quarters of the Church, there are some who may be leading Seders without highlighting (or knowing!) the difference. It would be a great service if every person leading a Seder for Christians would do what Poupko and Sandmel ask: acknowledge common principles and clearly articulate differences.
My first point of contention regarding this piece is the implication “Jesus didn’t eat a Seder meal (so you shouldn’t either, Christians!)”. Dr. Michael Rydelnik, a Jewish believer and professor at Moody Bible Institute, wrote an excellent rebuttal to Rabbis Poupko and Sandmel entitled “The Passover Hustle“. He writes,
The Seder ritual, as it is practiced today, did not exist at the time of Jesus.” Frankly no one disputes that. Certainly, the Seder meal was only codified after the AD 70 destruction of the Temple. However, the authors know very well that the codification was based on the book of Exodus and oral traditions present for generations. So, the last supper was substantively a Passover meal/a Seder with multiple aspects of Seder ritual evident in the gospels.
Jesus lived during the time the Temple was still standing, thus, the focus of his participation in Passover every year of his life was based on the worship prescribed in the Torah. G. Shane Morris wrote a response to the CT article here, and though he aimed straight into the bane of my existence as a Messianic Jew, replacement theology, in the second half of his article, he did support the reality that Jesus participated fully in Passover as it was practiced during his lifetime: “Jesus did not eat precisely the same meal, nor did any Jew while the second Temple was still standing. But this does not mean that there’s no continuity between what happens now and what happened in Egypt over three-thousand years ago (or what happened in Jerusalem two-thousand years ago, for that matter).”
When he stood on the shore of the Sea of Galilee and delivered his Sermon on the Mount, Jesus emphasized that he’d come to fulfill the Law (Matthew 5:17). Bible teacher Lois Tverberg explains:
“Fulfill the Torah” is a rabbinic idiom that is still in use even today. The word we read as “law” is Torah in Hebrew, and its main sense is teaching, guidance and instruction, rather than legal regulation. It is God’s instructions for living, and because of God’s great authority, it demands obedience and therefore takes on the sense of “law.” The Torah is often understood to mean the first five books of the Bible, but also refers to the Scriptures in general. In Jesus’ time, and among Jews today, this is a very positive thing—that the God who made us would give us instructions for how to live. The rabbis made it their goal to understand these instructions fully and teach people how to live by it.
Tverberg notes that the Hebrew word for “to fulfill” is lekayem (“le-kai-YEM”), a word that signifies upholding or establishing something, as well as to fulfill, complete, or accomplish some- thing. Every single shading of meaning of lekayem in Jesus’ minis- try can be seen in the way in which he partook of his final Passover, hours before his arrest, trial, and crucifixion. Jesus upheld the message and meaning of the Seder as he applied its story of deliverance to himself.
When we read the Gospel accounts of the last meal Jesus shared with his disciples (Matthew 26:17-30; Mark 14:12-26; Luke 22:7-23; John 13–17), we can see the references to the basic elements of the Seder as it is still celebrated today. Jesus took these elements and adapted them to demonstrate to his disciples how he’d come to fulfill (lekayem) the purpose and meaning behind this yearly re-enactment of God’s deliverance of his people. Just as others leading Seders have done before and since, Jesus reframed the traditional texts and rituals of the holiday to infuse them with new meaning.
My friend Justin Kron teaches frequently on the Seder, facilitating demonstrations and full Seders for dozens of churches each year. He noted that some in the Jewish community have fears that Seder presentations like the ones he does can and do help Jews understand the Gospel, but adds, “I think they should be celebrating and affirming that Christians are using it to get more in touch with their Jewish heritage. If Christians had maintained this connection back in the Early Church rather than jettisoning it maybe there would have been less antisemitism emanating from it throughout the last 18 centuries.”
My second point of concern is about the position of the piece as a stand-alone op-ed on the Christianity Today website, rather than being presented as a point-counterpoint debate piece where a leader from within the Messianic community or a Christian scholar specializing in Jewish studies was given an opportunity to present a different point of view. I’d hope for the same kind of exchange at CT if the magazine/website printed an article penned by a Muslim, Buddhist or atheist. I’ve been strengthened and encouraged more than I can say by the kind of dialogue CT fosters, and count it a high privilege to have contributed numerous pieces to their website (and very occasionally, their print mag) over the years. I hope that CT will continue the conversation about this topic after Passover 2017 (5777) comes to an end.
Note: On April 10th, CT published this response to last week’s editorial from Mitch Glaser and Darrel Bock.
Have you ever been to a Seder presentation at a church? Attended a Seder led by a Messianic Jew? What was your experience like?