Last Meal Before Crucifixion

Last Meal Before Crucifixion February 4, 2014

This Cyanide and Happiness cartoon can actually lead to discussion of a serious point (believe it or not). Traditional Christian theology has depicted Jesus as willingly embracing crucifixion. One Gospel has Jesus suggest that he could simply have called a legion of angels to save him had he wanted to.

Presumably the Jesus who emphasized not repaying evil with evil, and who had miraculous powers at his disposal, might be expected to do something more along the lines of what the cartoon depicts, than what Matthew suggests? On the one hand, it emphasizes his own ability rather than depending on angels, while on the other, it doesn't involve violent retaliation.

In my Sunday school class this past weekend, we talked about the problems with suggesting that the cross accomplished forgiveness that God could not extend previously. It makes more sense to see it as an expression of the ever-present character of divine forgiveness. In the cross we see a vision of a God who allows his chosen one to be tortured and killed and yet does not destroy those who carry it out. It doesn't make forgiveness possible, but presupposes that it already is, and demonstrates the extent of grace.

If that does not undermine depictions of God as hateful then nothing will – except perhaps a depiction of God's anointed one escaping by multiplying food rather than resorting to violence. But I still think the traditional version is more powerful.


"Yes, Matthew's bit is weird and pretty much every scholar is a little mystified at ..."

N. T. Wright’s Paul and the ..."
"Here's my guess (lol):James said: What do readers of this blog think? Is the expression ..."

Poor In Spirit and Poor in ..."
"I think it's only problematic to those who have consciously or unconsciously become adherents to ..."

Poor In Spirit and Poor in ..."
"I would be honoured, thanks."

Doctor Who: Demons of the Punjab

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment