Theodicy and Thanksgiving

Theodicy and Thanksgiving March 13, 2014

Last Sunday in my sunday school class, we talked about prayer. Perennial questions came up, the most pressing of which was how to avoid having prayers asking for help, and giving thanks for good fortune, become things that cause harm to those around you. It is ultimately the same issue that got Job’s friends into trouble, only the flip side of it. They tried to interpret Job’s suffering in relation to God’s will and activity. Today more often people ignore those who are suffering but confidently proclaim that their own good fortune is an expression of divine providence.

But no one ought to say that, and certainly not confidently. Give thanks, express gratitude, but do so in a way that does not deliver the message that God favors you and dislikes or cares less for those around you.

Here are a couple of images to ponder in relation to this topic:


"On two occasions, Abraham offended his hosts, causing them serious injury. Both Pharoah and Abimelek ..."

Attacking the Bible
"The idea was not at all difficult for Luke to imagine (see Acts 6,5 13,43). ..."

Triangulating on John the Baptist from ..."
"No I just assumed, til now, that you wouldn't appeal to the, I think, unattested ..."

Triangulating on John the Baptist from ..."
"I never said anything at all about Mark being circumcised on account of Jesus. You ..."

Triangulating on John the Baptist from ..."

Browse Our Archives