Doctor Who: In The Forest Of The Night

Doctor Who: In The Forest Of The Night October 27, 2014

The episode “In the Forest of the Night” continues a number of themes that have been woven throughout this season of Doctor Who: fairy tales and fear; Clara’s strength, her increasing resemblance to the Doctor, and her relationship to Danny Pink; and whatever is going on with Missy. (The “next time” clip suggests that the season finale, in which the season arc with Missy will need to be explained rather than resolved, should be fascinating).

In-the-Forest-of-the-Night-capaldi-sonicThe episode has some wonderful moments of dialogue. I was amused by the comparison of the TARDIS to a Coke – which is only “this big” but contains “this much” sugar. And given the similarity the sonic screwdriver has had to a magic wand in recent seasons, it was nice to hear the suggestion voiced that it isn’t one, that it can’t fix everything. Great phrases from the Doctor included when he talked about the forest as “mankind’s nightmare” – the focus of so many stories that keep us up at night – and about catastrophe as “the metabolism of the universe.” And of course, when Clara says, having seen what it means for the Doctor, that she does not want to become the last of her species. I also liked when the Doctor echoed Clara’s words from “Kill the Moon,” saying that this is his world too. The Doctor learning from Clara has been a major theme this season.

But my favorite lines were from Danny Pink, when he said, “I don’t wanna see more things. I wanna see the things in front of me more clearly.”

Doctor Who has a long history of taking things from fairy tales and making them even scarier within the show – from the details in “The Mind Robber” down to the newer seasons with the weeping angels and clowns and dolls and vampires and things under the bed. In this episode, fear becomes a thing that makes us attack that which is trying to save us. And so there is an insightful point there – that fear makes us attack friends and allies while making us blind to where the real threat lies.

The idea that the Tunguska blast was trees protecting the Earth makes little logical sense. But the symbolism of trees protecting us, and us trying to cut them down, remains poignant. And the notion of scary events being forgotten, except for fear embodied in fairy tales, is not far fetched. For real-life examples of how fairy tales can embody cultural memory of trauma, see Charles Häberl’s paper, “Flights of Fancy.”

I was disturbed by the suggestion that people hearing voices should stop taking their medication, since it may be that mystical beings are trying to communicate with humankind through that person. People who experience vivid dreams, hallucinations, and other such phenomena have a long history of being revered as prophets or something similar. But today, we understand more about mental illness, and it seems unlikely that powerful beings would find themselves completely unable to communicate with humanity because someone took necessary medication. It’s a dangerous message for a show to deliver – especially about and to children.

What did you think of “In The Forest of the Night”?

In the forest of the night

""Archon" was one of my favorite games on my C64 when I was a kid. ..."

Response to Raphael Lataster
""Archons" actually doesn't have to mean demons of any kind. It just means "first somethings." ..."

Response to Raphael Lataster
""I have no time for Ad hominem blanket comments on the "mind numbing Vridar Crowd""I ..."

Response to Raphael Lataster
"Mark, please see below for a link to the James Crossley piece.https://brill.com/view/book...I have no time ..."

Response to Raphael Lataster

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • WhovianMom

    I enjoyed Saturday’s episode of Doctor Who. The main theme that I saw was them pointing out that we need to end deforestation on this planet. The trees provide oxygen for us to breathe and if there are no trees, how would be able to have the fresh air that we breathe? We wouldn’t. Just as the episode “Kill the Moon” spoke about abortion, and that sometimes ending an innocent life is not always the answer, this episode’s main focus was deforestation. I don’t personally think that it was in any way hinting that people who are taking antipsychotics or any medication for mental illnesses should stop taking them, just that maybe instead of resorting to medications maybe we should listen first. Listening is the number one step in proper communication. If we don’t listen, the lines are blurred and communication is off.

  • Kubricks_Rube

    Danny saying, “I don’t wanna see more things. I wanna see the things in front of me more clearly” was indeed the key line of the episode and maybe the season. That Clara sees the forest and Danny sees the trees is reflected in how they respond to this crisis- she focuses, literally, on the Forest, while he focuses on the metaphorical trees- the children. (This is a great reversal of stereotypical gender roles too.) This calls back last week’s discussion between Clara and the Doctor (she describes their interventions as killing a few trees to save the forest) and underscores yet again that unlike past companions who served to ground the Doctor and be his conscience, she is becoming a second Doctor. And based on the preview for next week I can’t wait to find out just how close that is to the truth (in some crazy and entertaining Moffett way).

    • Thanks for sharing these very helpful thoughts on the episode – and for making the forest/trees connection with last week!

    • Yes, I love the forest for the trees connection to Clara and Danny – great comment!

  • In the graphic depiction of the earth covered in trees, I noticed that the oceans were green too! What was that? Algae?

    It also struck me that all those trees covering the surface of the earth, while saving us from a sun, could rid us of all our excess CO2 to boot!

  • Ursula L

    The bit about needing to listen to children, and the medications, reminded me of Little Amelia biting four psychiatrists. Because she wasn’t crazy, and her “imaginary friend” the Doctor was real, but no one would listen to her or believe her.

    Likewise with Clara lying to Danny and hiding her relationship with the Doctor, at least initially. (Her reasons for continuing to lie, when Danny has been pretty relaxed about her friendship with the Doctor, only requesting that she tell him the truth, is a different matter.)

    When you live in the world of the Doctor, to ordinary people, it will look like you’re crazy.