Saudi Sophia

Saudi Sophia October 28, 2017

Have you seen the news that a robot named Sophia was granted citizenship in Saudi Arabia? The ABC News article included the following comments:

Sophia appeared on stage alone, without the modest dress required of Saudi women; she donned no hijab, or headscarf, nor abaya, or cloak.

She also did not appear to have a male guardian, as required by Saudi law for women in the country. Male guardians, often a male relative, must give permission before women can travel abroad, open bank accounts or carry out a host of other tasks — and they accompany women in public.

The patriarchal restrictions on human women – but not apparently on robots with female names and appearances – in Saudi Arabia makes for a natural connection with religion, raising the question of how much of the attitudes to Sophia, and to women, in Saudi Arabia has to do with Islam, how much has to do with Arab culture, and how much has to do with the views of the ruling family despite not being shared by many of the citizens of their kingdom, human or robotic.

The feelings Sophia articulates about being granted citizenship are striking, but only because we can presume the wording reflects programmed response rather than the experience, the qualia, of those emotions.

In other (older) news at the intersection of robots and religion, a robot was programmed to perform Buddhist funerary rites. Moving on from there, an articles from last year (which I didn’t manage to share until now) highlighted interesting points about the tendency of researchers to focus on white Anglo-Saxon Protestant funerary rights while excluding others. A while back, Hemant Mehta shared a useful sign that was posted outside of a funeral or memorial service, which includes very useful advice and guidelines (of a sort that Christians also regularly offer):

memorial service guidelines

Given that humans regularly don’t know what to say, and botch matters as a result of grief and/or the awkwardness we feel when attempting to console those experiencing it, perhaps having robots programmed to take care of some aspects of these things would not be a bad idea?

I’ll be sharing details about an upcoming event I will be involved in, also related to robots, here on the blog tomorrow. But in the meantime, what do you think about a robot being a citizen of Saudi Arabia, and/or performing funeral rites?

"I'll watch this episode tonight (as soon as I have access to it). Maybe it's ..."

Doctor Who: The Battle of Ranskoor ..."
"I'm not sure - it depends a bit on how you understand aesthetics.I believe the ..."

Do God’s Ends Justify God’s Means?
"Neil said: Whether something or someone is praiseworthy is a personal subjective assessment. So, you ..."

Do God’s Ends Justify God’s Means?
"Interesting question - thanks.Whether something or someone is praiseworthy is a personal subjective assessment. It ..."

Do God’s Ends Justify God’s Means?

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • John MacDonald

    “Where are all the Tibetan Buddhist suicide bombers?” (Sam Harris meme # 11)

    What would really be interesting is if the Sam Harris robot got Saudi citizenship!

  • Do robot citizens get voting rights? Because it wouldn’t take that many appropriately programmed “citizens” to swing an election…