Conservative and Liberal Biblical Scholarship

Conservative and Liberal Biblical Scholarship February 6, 2021

In a recent blog post, Ian Paul pushes back on some points John Barton makes in one of his influential books. I find myself between the two, agreeing with Ian that there is a tendency to treat a widespread academic surmise about the dates of works and other matters as though they were known with a high degree of certainty, almost gospel truth. Yet I also tend to find that Ian prefers conservative dates and views because of his own leanings.

I hope at some point to write a book about the Gospel of John, recognizing that it might indeed have a close connection to an eyewitness, and yet also recognizing that this only makes the problem of the differences between John and the other Gospels more significant and not less. I think that John A. T. Robinson’s arguments about the character of the Gospel of John and the meaning of its Christology have been largely separated, with the latter ignored all around while his willingness to date John’s Gospel early has been pointed to regularly by conservatives and consequently largely ignored by others. His entire argument has far greater merit and nuance than that, and eventually I hope to get back to that question.

If you are among those who have ignored his arguments, I highly recommend Robinson’s book The Priority of John. (His Redating the New Testament is also relevant.) If people would read and seriously wrestle with his arguments, me writing something on the subject might not be necessary. On the other hand, historical study has moved on in important ways since he wrote, and some of the things he wrote as mere tantalizing suggestions deserve to be explored further. He himself might have done this had he not died before finalizing the manuscript, which was edited and published posthumously.

Of related interest:

The startling authority of Jesus in Mark 1 video

The whole city? (Mark 1) Let’s take that with a grain of salt

La justicia superior a la de los escribas y fariseos: la Limosna

The Oldest View of Christ: Found in Only One Greek Manuscript of Luke!

The World of the New Testament (Green and McDonald)

Reading the New Testament as Christian Scripture—Campbell and Pennington

Exploring the New Testament—Walton et al.

Introducing the New Testament—Thompson, Green, Achtemeier

Introducing the New Testament—Mark Allan Powell

An Introduction to the New Testament—M. Eugene Boring

The New Testament in Antiquity (2nd ed)—Gary M. Burge and Gene L. Green

New Testament Introductions and Surveys (NTRG)

The Lord’s Prayer and the Sermon on the Mount (Jan 31, 2021)

The New Testament in Its World—Bird and Wright

The Hidden Twist Ending Of The Prodigal Son Story

God’s Messiah in the Old Testament

Sermon: Freedom, love, covid19 … and Margaret Court

How to pray: a review of Justo Gonzalez’s *Teach Us to Pray: The Lord’s Prayer in the Early Church and Today* (Part 1)

Son, Sacrifice, and Great Shepherd

New MARK16 Ethiopic and Coptic transcriptions and translations on Nakala

Mina Monier lecture at the Catholic BIblical Federation

The Scandalous Particularity of Jesus

New Book: Jesus Christ as Son of David in the Gospel of Mark

From James Tabor:

Who Killed Jesus?

Featured in Popular Archaeology

From Bob Cornwall:

You Are The Beloved

Come and See

Come and Follow Me

True Authority

Finding Jesus in the Storm

Jesus the Healing Revivalist?

Newly digitized older books about Jesus:

The Teaching of Jesus by D. M. Ross

The Gospel that Jesus Preached by A. T. Cadoux

Finalists for best books in New Testament studies

 

"I still remember a sermon when the preacher sympathised with Thomas because he is forever ..."

QAnonsense
"I have, and thanks to your comment and a group discussion on Facebook I am ..."

ChristianBooks Q&A: What Jesus Learned from ..."
""Wokeness" is a vague label like "liberal" that doesn't really say or mean anything. Putting ..."

The Immorality of “Pro Life”
"You are assuming that the termination of a pregnancy at any stage whatsoever is murder, ..."

The Immorality of “Pro Life”

Browse Our Archives



error: Content is protected !!