Fred Phelps: Why it is not possible to believe that you ate Chick-fil-A because of ‘freedom of speech’

Fred Phelps: Why it is not possible to believe that you ate Chick-fil-A because of ‘freedom of speech’ August 5, 2012

Please stop pretending that the orgy of hate last week at Chick-fil-A had anything to do with free speech.

It obviously did not. I know it. You know it. Everyone knows it.

Fred Phelps.

That’s why if you say you went to Chick-fil-A “Appreciation Day” because of “freedom of speech,” everyone knows you’re just play-acting.

Fred Phelps, buddy. Fred freakin’ Phelps. Fred “God Hates Fags” Phelps of the infamously nasty Westboro Baptist Church.

Fred Phelps proves you’re just playing games.

Phelps is a reprehensible human being, but he’s a skilled publicity hound, so I find it hard to believe that the chuckling hordes of chicken gobblers last week were unfamiliar with Phelps and his body of work. They’ve seen his signs. They’ve seen him on the news, in the paper, on the Web. Their kids may even have played him in the school play.

Everybody knows about Phelps and what he does. And everybody knows that Phelps is free to do it. Free to continue doing it.

Anybody claiming to believe that the freedom to speak against homosexuality is somehow under threat has to explain how such claims could possibly be compatible with the continuing freedom of the deliberately obnoxious Fred Phelps.

And that cannot be done.

You say you went to Chick-fil-A to stand up for the freedom of speech? Nonsense. Fred Phelps.

Fred Phelps, ergo, liar, liar pants on fire. Fred Phelps, therefore, no one believes you.

Fred Phelps therefore no one is able to believe you.

So since no one is able to believe the pretense, drop the act. Last week’s ugly display was not inspired by some noble defense of freedom of speech. There was nothing noble about it.

Fred Phelps. His freedom disproves your claim.

But don’t be too hard on him. After all, he’s on your side, and that’s all that matters, right?

"No, it can't=because its "work with the poor and less fortunate" is often done with ..."

Postcards from the class & culture ..."
"I hope that mood is better now that you know what's going on with you? ..."

I’m going to heaven on a ..."
"As I recall, there was that post-Vietnam. PTSD was just being recognized as a thing ..."

You’re fighting with a ghost
"Thank you! It'll be interesting to see how the results skew, with such a small ..."

I’m going to heaven on a ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Ross Thompson

    I dont mind issues being pushed hard over a long time, if they are issues actually worth pushing.  I just dont think the chick-fil-a thing is.

    So, the problem is that other people have different opinions on which issues are worth pushing than you do? How would you feel if someone complained that they’d been hearing all about this drone-murder thing for two whole weeks, and just give it a rest already?

  • MD

    “the chuckling hordes of chicken gobblers”

    I see what you did there. It just so happens that all Chick-fil-A fryers are male chickens*, so feel free to be poultry gender-specific next time.

    *Not intended as a factual statement