May 27 Flashback:

May 27 Flashback: May 27, 2022

From May 27, 2012, “Thomas More vs. Mary Dyer: The bishops don’t know what ‘religious liberty’ means“:

The U.S. Catholic bishops have decided to make Thomas More the central figure in their summer protests against the government guarantee of equal health insurance coverage for women.

Scott Paeth notes that this choice probably reveals more about the bishops’ agenda than they intended:

Thomas More died for the sake of his conscience. More also caused others to die for the sake of their consciences. He burned heretics at the stake and he pursued William Tyndale mercilessly (a fact that ought to give the Bishops’ Protestant allies some pause). Like the Bishops, what he wanted was not freedom of conscience regarding matters of religion, but for his own view of religious orthodoxy to prevail. And he was willing to make others suffer for the sake of that vision.

This is exactly why the bishops are full of it when they claim that they are fighting for “religious liberty” when they oppose equal health insurance coverage for women.

To fight for religious liberty, one has to understand what that means, and the bishops have made it clear that they simply do not. Like their patron saint, Thomas More, they think that religious liberty involves their liberty to impose their religion on others.

Their “Freedom Fortnight” campaign might be something I could believe or respect if they took for its symbol instead someone like, say, Mary Dyer.

But the “religious liberty” these bishops are fighting for is at the other end of that rope. They don’t care about or sympathize with Mary Dyer’s religious liberty. What they’re upset about is that, unlike the theocratic puritans of 17th-century New England, they are no longer free to do whatever it takes to restrain such uppity women.

"Any question of how to order public society is going to be political. The ultimate ..."

6/29 Flashback: Oreos & pierogies
"And I am the exactly right age to embrace both the hilarious social disruption that ..."

7/28 Flashback: They get paid twice
"It is certainly a coincidence in (short) search of a causation."

6/29 Flashback: Oreos & pierogies
"The majesty of the law strikes again."

6/29 Flashback: Oreos & pierogies

Browse Our Archives

Close Ad