Mystery Worship Ten: Redeemer Presbyterian

Mystery Worship Ten: Redeemer Presbyterian July 10, 2012

Note:  this is part of an ongoing series.  Mystery Worship One is here;  Mystery Worship Two is here; Mystery Worship Three is here. Four is here. Five is here. Six is here. Seven is here. Eight is here. Nine is here.

For Mystery Worship Ten, I choose Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City.

This church, begun in 1989 by a group of 15, had recently moved into its first permanent home ever.  About 4500 people worship weekly at Redeemer now–with six different Sunday services.

At this link, you will find the history of this church.

Multiple greeters in the airy and light reception area welcomed me and directed me to a set of stairs which descended to the first floor of the worship area.  I assume there is an elevator, but stairs are just a part of life in New York City.

The large, spare looking room featured descending levels furnished with pews. The pews curved around a large and unadorned stage on which sat a piano, altar table set with communion elements (cups in trays), a couple of microphones, a few simple chairs, and a music stand or two.  No windows, as we were in a basement.  Well lit–bright but unobtrusive lighting.  No ornamentation-just basic functionality.

This area could seat at least 450; the balcony probably as many more, and both quickly filled. More could have been accommodated as there was still adequate personal space between people in the pews, but there were no gaping holes.

The extremely helpful and thorough worship bulletin included these words under the “Worship Etiquette” section:

  • We encourage parents to use the fully staffed nursery.
  • Please allow Ushers to seat you.
  • We appreciate your moving to the middle of the row, and avoiding using seats to store personal items to ensure space for visitors.
  • Seat saving is subject to the discretion of the Usher Captain and Redeemer Staff once the service begins.
  • Special seating is available to those with disabilities.

Also, during the announcements (about 10 minutes in), children from Kindergarten to the fifth grade are dismissed for children’s worship, but they must have been registered first.  Parents pick up their children after the service.

This is serious crowd control–what a great problem to have!

The very traditional service was completely set out in the worship booklet: hymns, with music scores included, all readings, prayers and responses, along with space to take notes on the message.  The very well-known Dr. Tim Keller was the preacher that day.  He generally preaches at four of the six Sunday services, but no one knows ahead of time which services he will preach.  There are two other teaching pastors on the staff and they all work from the same Scriptures and topics each week.

His message title, “The World Will Hate You,” came from the Matthew 10:5-25 passage where Jesus gives ministry instructions to his disciples, telling them to heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse the leper and drive out demons.  Jesus also reminds his followers that life is going to be tough–but that they will experience no trials greater than their Master will also experience.

Dr. Keller’s preaching style is relaxed, conversational, somewhat academic, yet clearly engaged with the lives of these New Yorkers who filled those hard, wooden seats.  His almost pleading call for everyone there to be in mission and ministry made me suspect that they have the same problem many large churches do:  lots of people in worship attendance, far fewer involved in hands-on transformational mission work.

Communion, with careful instructions about who may and may not receive the sacrament, a prayer of thanksgiving and benediction ended the 75 minute worship service. The crowds headed out, either onto the street, or to an upper floor for coffee and conversation.

I walked away, having very much enjoyed my time in there.  Yet worship is not for my personal enjoyment, but for the glorification of God, for the hearing of God’s word, and for the change that takes place when the fallible, broken human comes more intentionally into the presence of the Holy One.  I sensed that I had been given just that opportunity there, and received it gladly.

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Progressive Christian
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Ok, So I’m curious about communion and who could and who could not receive it. What were the criteria? I’m familiar with the Catholic conditions, but not others. Also how did that part of the service make you feel? I know some Catholic churches give instructions and some do not before communion. The one I attend does not say in the service or in the worship bulletin who can and who can’t receive communion. I’m not sure how I would feel if conditions were spelled out to me. I’m thinking that it might make me want to not come back depending on what was said.

    • Here’s what they say:

      Redeemer Presbyterian Church welcomes all baptized Christians who actively trust in Jesus Christ for salvation, who are willing to forsake their sin, and who are members of congregations that proclaim the gospel to receive the Holy Communion with us. Baptized children are welcome to receive Communion when they have been confirmed in their faith. If you are not able to receive Communion, please use this time to meditate on one of the following prayers (three prayers follow: One “prayer for those searching for Truth,” one called “Prayer of Belief,” and the third, a “Prayer of Commitment”).

  • Dyan Dietz

    It seems to me that a worship environment that is so unwelcoming to children misses a key point of the good news of gospel of Jesus Christ.

    • Dyan, I certainly agree that the clear directives, “no children in worship” does seem to violate the hospitality of the Gospel. I also know this is NYC–and it may be correct in that context to do so. One of the big issues there is that of strollers–strollers are the autos of the city, every parent with a child has at least two of them, and they are huge, and it wouldn’t take too many strollers in the back of the worship center to create a significant hazard in the case of an emergency evacuation. But having said that, I missed seeing children in worship–there was not a single one there that I could see. I wish I had taken the time to go to the children’s area (I think it was on the fifth floor), but had to leave immediately afterward to catch up with my own family–and their three children also do not attend worship with them.

  • Pingback: A Twist on the Mystery Worship Series | thoughtfulpastor()

  • Pingback: Mystery Worship Eleven: A Missed Opportunity | thoughtfulpastor()

  • Pingback: Mystery Worship Twelve: Memorial Services | thoughtfulpastor()

  • Pingback: freshamateurs666 abdu23na4260 abdu23na42()