…of my bare knuckles brawl this weekend with Scot McKnight (and his Cubbies proxy, Luke):
Cubs 2006 total payroll: $94,424,499
Cubs 2006 W-L record: 66-96
Cubs dollars spent per win: $1,430,674
Twins 2006 total payroll: $63,396,006
Twins 2006 W-L record: 96-66
Twins dollars spent per win: $660,375
That’s a 2.1:1 ratio.
And, what does 2007 hold in store? Well, the Cubbies hired the washed-up, peripatetic manager Lou Pinella for $3.25 million, whereas the Twins continue to employ baseball genius and team loyalist Ron Gardenhire for $1.25 million. The Cubbies will pay $12.4 million to keep over-hyped Carlos Zambrano around for one more year, whereas the Twins signed hometown hero Joe Mauer $33 million to stick around for four years. I could go on and on. But one thing is clear: the Cubs haven’t gotten the message that throwing money at the problem isn’t the answer. Whatever magic Andy McPhail had in Minnesota, he has lost in Chicago.