Principles of Moral Thought and Action
Written by: Ted Vial
There have been debates in Lutheranism about the role that works do or do not play in salvation.Luther himself taught that even the saved remain sinners (but forgiven sinners); that works cannot merit forgiveness, which is a free gift from God; but that a saved Christian, free from worries about earning salvation, and eager to glorify God, will out of love perform good works for their neighbors.Unlike John Wesley, Luther did not teach that failure to perform good works would put your salvation at risk.Nonetheless, he did expect a good tree to bear good fruit, and if such fruit was not in evidence the claim to be saved might seem suspect.Before God (coram deo) works played no role in salvation, but before the neighbor (coram hominibus) they were necessary.
Despite the fact that Luther taught that salvation is a gift that in no way depends on good works, Lutherans have not backed away from engagement in the world.They have been morally active throughout history.While the first use of the law (moral commandments) in the Bible is to teach us that we cannot fulfill it on our own and need God's grace, the law is useful to the saved as a model of God's will for humans and as a means to discipline the body to conform to that will.The goal of Lutheran morality is to be Christ-like.
Like all Christian groups, there is no unanimity among Lutherans regarding the details of what the law in the Bible requires, and what the model of Jesus requires.The tensions have been particularly strained since the modernist controversies of the early 20th century.At this time the twin developments of Darwinian biology and historical criticism of the Bible led to a rift in all Christian denominations.(Historical criticism was a movement coming largely from Germany that argued that the Bible is best understood, most literally understood, as a historical collection of documents in which different authors are addressing particular audiences of their own contemporaries.)
In the United States this rift is partially institutionalized in the largest Lutheran denominations, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) (about 5 million members) and the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (LCMS) (about 2.5 million members).The LCMS is by far the more conservative.It believes that the Bible is free of error, and that the 16th-century Lutheran confessions (found in the Book of Concord) are in complete harmony with the Bible.This has several results.The LCMS does not enter into fellowship with Reformed churches, but rather rejects and condemns their departure from the Lutheran confessions.They do not ordain women, they oppose abortion, and they condemn homosexual behavior.All, they claim, are unscriptural.
In 1997, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America declared full communion (a relationship of agreement regarding core doctrines) with the United Church of Christ, the Presbyterian Church-USA, and the Reformed Church of America.The ELCA also declared that the major differences between it and Roman Catholicism on justification and salvation had been resolved.The LCMS rejects all these declarations.